Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Goodyear Lake

We had an awesome time at Landon’s property. The kids loved interacting with and feeding the farm animals, specially the horses and sheep. The caboose was a pleasantly unique experience with great views, mood lighting, and comfortable beds. Girls loved going up and down the sturdy ladder to the loft bed in the cabin. The cabin is very thoughtfully appointed, with hot water supply and made our stay very comfortable despite the overcast weather. Our girls are looking forward to be back again soon to spend more time with the farm animals. Landon was always quick to respond and house info / instructions were succinct.

We stayed for a few days at the zen cottage and it was the most relaxing and peaceful weekend. The cottage is exactly has described and super clean. Alma and James were very helpful and welcoming. Overall had an extremely enjoyable weekend and hope to come back soon

Absolutely stunning place, Kim and Russel are great hosts! Would surely be returning for another family stay!

Eileen has a beautiful spacious home for those who want to get away from hustle bustle and noise. Every room is neat and tidy and furnished beautifully. There are plenty of kitchenware to use if you’re dining in at the BnB during mealtimes. She also supplies tons of entertainment from movies/retro games/board games to entertain for hours on end! When it comes to sleep or naps every there are multiple comfortable beds with plenty of extra pillows and blankets for extra warmth and comfort! I can’t recommend her and her property enough for anyone staying in the Oneonta area!

What an excellent stay - this airbnb was incredibly well stocked with kitchen supplies, games, extra linens, really anything that one could want. Amenities were high quality and very thoughtful.

We love this place so much Confy, warm and clean Second visit this year and plan to go back next year again Great hosts

Beautiful space. Amazing countryside vibes. Fun hike down to the waterfall, great kitchen for cooking and a fun night in. There was lots of quaint stuff to do in nearby Middleburgh: thrifting, diners, 50s milkshake bar, antique book stores, hikes, breweries, and more. We loved that there was so many towels for the sauna and swimming. One note: give yourself a lot of time for the sauna to heat up. Instructions were clear and they gave us lots of local recs. Also LOVED the hammocks -- lots of cozy nooks to hang for a chill girls weekend. We might be back again! A great stay.

Exceptional stay at Samantha’s property. Perfect for exploring Fly Creek and Cooperstown. The backyard was stunning - we loved playing games, relaxing, and wading in the water. Would definitely stay again!

We stayed 2 nights at Bob and Jackie's place with our 2 kids. The apartment was clean and prepared for our arrival which we really appreciate (an extra bed was already made for our kids to sleep). There was enough space for the 4 of us, the kitchen is fully equipped too. Although it was raining heavily during our stay, we could enjoy our time outside because of a little covered area on the back of the building with a view to the woods and a grill that we enjoyed using as well. Thanks Bob and Jackie for a nice and peaceful stay!

This is my second stay at Melinda and Kim’s Airbnb. They are the most wonderful hosts, and the place is beautiful and comfy. Melinda goes above and beyond with everything she does.

We loved how quiet and peaceful the location was. We also loved the homey touches- the local books, the honor store out back, the fact that there was the cafe under the apartment. The setting was beautiful and we loved falling asleep to the sound of the brook and the spring peepers!

The brick house at Eagle Ridge Farm was a great home base for us to spend a long weekend in the Catskills. The place was well kept, with a comfy bed, and a great view out the windows. Scenic, but only a few minutes from Arkville and Margaretville, where there are great options for food and drink! We were also recommended great hikes by the host. Would happily stay again!

It really is like being at home. It is a beautiful cabin, surrounded by lots of snow and lots of pine trees. lots of towels and lots of blankets. We really had a great time, and Myrna and Mike, they are really great and very friendly. one hundred percent recommendable

David and Merry were some of the kindest and most generous hosts we’ve ever met. They went out of their way to make our stay perfect, even choosing not to rent out the other part of the house during our visit to give us more privacy. They welcomed us warmly, shared great local tips, helped us book a restaurant and even sent us a bottle of wine there. The house was beautiful, super comfortable, and had everything we needed. We felt truly cared for and would absolutely love to come back!

The apartment was very comfortable. The fresh eggs and other breakfast items were a great surprise. The location was perfect for let us get away from Dreams Park between games. Our daughters had a great time feeding the animals and jumping on the trampoline.

We had a great stay at Cornerstone! We were in town for a baseball tournament at Cooperstown All Star Village, and it was an easy drive back and forth to games. It had a homey feel, was clean, and had beautiful surroundings. The hosts were also friendly and always responded to messages quickly. Definitely met our family’s needs. Thank you for having us.

Very cute and convenient stay. We had everything we needed and more. We would recommend this place to anyone desiring to get away and enjoy the Catskills.

My wife, dog and I stayed four nights over Memorial Day. The home/cabin, was private, secluded, well-maintained, clean and very comfortable. Unfortunately, we had four days of rain and cool weather, but we never felt confined, bored, etc. The outdoor grill, inside wood burning stove, privacy, tv streaming options, large table for games, etc. made the trip very enjoyable, relaxing and fun. Also, it goes without saying, our AUD cattle dog, seemed to enjoy himself and there were many places on the property for him to explore. Finally, it was very quiet during the day and evening; whereby, there were no distractions or obstacles to relaxation or sleep.

For price the place was great. Location for us was perfict I have spent 75 plus years in the area. If you like solatude its perfect. For a veiw walk the road down towards the pond then make a left and follow the power line to the crest of the hill over looking the western end of the Catskills. Place could use a few more plates and smaller bowls for A cerial breakfast. Place is perfect for 5 but can sleep 6. I would stay here again. .

Absolutely Amazing Cabin Retreat!** I had the pleasure of staying at this beautiful cabin, and it exceeded all my expectations. The location is incredibly private, offering a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle. The cozy atmosphere made me feel right at home, and the welcoming vibe was evident from the moment I arrived. The fire pit was a fantastic touch—perfect for relaxing evenings under the stars. The grill allowed for some delicious outdoor cooking, adding to the overall experience. The bedroom is stunning, with a charming design that made sleeping there a true pleasure. I also loved the wood style decor throughout the cabin; it added a warm, rustic charm that I found absolutely captivating. We will definitely be back soon! Highly recommended for anyone looking for a peaceful, beautiful, and cozy getaway!

If you’re looking for a cozy weekend away in the Catskills, this is the place!! Everything about Pamela and Alan’s cabin was absolutely perfect: the cleanliness, the amenities, their friendliness, the vast space, and bonus: the grill and hot tub. My partner and I loved every minute of our time spent at the cabin and truly made some great memories staying up here. I cannot recommend this place enough and thank Pamela and Alan for being incredible hosts!

What a beautiful place and warming hosts! I had an amazing time at the home and the town was filled with wonderful people, food and relaxing atmosphere. I will definitely be back 🙏

This is a lovely cabin, very cozy and nicely decorated. Beautiful surroundings and the view amazing. It was easy to check in and we were greeted with cookies and eggs from the farm up the road. Very nice! And we loved the little kids play nook! Communication with the host was great and she was very responsive. The two beds were comfortable but the futons were not. We had to have the kids sleep on the two futons due to the size of our group and thought it would be ok but I don't think those futons should be considered for sleeping. They were very hard and the surface was not even. Other than that, we had a lovely stay and would recommend this cabin.

We were very happy with this cabin. Even more attractive than the photos. The dogs loved the backyard. We grabbed a pizza from the local pizza place, which was really delicious. We only spent one night here as we were traveling through, but if we ever need somewhere to stay in the area again, this would definitely be our first choice.