Vacation rentals with lake access in Goodyear Lake

We enjoyed staying at Isobella and Pierre’s place. It was clean, comfortable, and convenient. Beautiful decor with lots of space to relax. Our dogs loved exploring the backyard and were very much at home inside. We appreciated the basket of doggy towels and dog shampoo; well used during our rainy stay. The only negative for us was the sulfur smell in the water (a natural phenomenon in the geological area). Beyond the home- Pierre’s dining recommendations did not disappoint!

We had a wonderful time at Alicia and Jamie’s home in Livingston Manor. The home itself was spacious, tastefully decorated, and comfortable. And the property was fantastic- beautiful and very private yet close to town. Speaking of the town, Livingston Manor is charming and definitely worth exploring, as is nearby Roscoe. Overall a great time. We look forward to returning.

Great home!!!! Spacious and very clean. Veronica was a great host that made sure we had everything we needed. If back in the area, I would definitely stay here again.

Fell in love with this lake house. It was a surprise for our mom for Mother’s Day. She loved her vacation as we all did. It’s a perfect retreat on the water with beautiful sunsets and lots of wildlife to watch and the sounds of nature were so lovely. A real gem this place is so much so we reserved an extra night. None of us wanted to leave and we all look forward to returning again soon. The home and all amenities were perfect as was the host . Thank you.

We stayed at Adam’s house for two nights with family to celebrate our son’s graduation from SUNY Delhi. We really loved the house, the view from the large covered deck was beautiful. The photos in the listing were very accurate, it’s a great house that is well stocked, very comfortable and clean. Adam was great at communicating with us, answering any questions. Check in was very easy. We look forward to coming back in the future, great house!

We had a great stay at Victoria's house. The pictures of the house are accurate and Victoria was a very responsive /helpful host. The land and particularly the stream are much more beautiful and expansive in person than we were expecting. Do yourself a favor and go explore the grounds. The setting is private, serene, and a great way to recharge your battery. I would highly recommend this property if you like the outdoors and wants to have a quiet and relaxing trip where you can reconnect with nature.

Absolutely loved this house, this lake and surrounding area. The house was ideal for us. We had a full house with 10 guests for our son’s wedding. Could not have been more perfect. Adults loved the house, spa and views. Grandkids fell in love with the lake and dock. (And pet carp!) Rich was very helpful with questions and left clear instructions (and wonderful stories) at the house. We talked about coming back even before we left. Cheers!

Bills place is great. Perfect for a peaceful getaway on the water by yourself or with a small group.

My wife and I stayed here last year for the first time and we came back again this year because we really liked this place. The hosts were friendly and accommodating and made us feel welcome. The place was clean and well kept and the 3 bedrooms gave us more than enough space for our needs. They even let our cat stay here which most places won't allow. We really liked the location, the park like property, and being within walking distance to the town pool and the local deli. Thank you again Mustafa and Olena for a wonderful stay!

Perfect place to stay and had an EV charger.

This is my second stay at Melinda and Kim’s Airbnb. They are the most wonderful hosts, and the place is beautiful and comfy. Melinda goes above and beyond with everything she does.

Bernie was a great host. He met us to greet us and check us in and show us around the place because it is a little unique. The house is wonderful and oozes with history. There are a couple things about the set up of the unit to be aware of. The kitchen is completely enclosed within the house so there are no windows and no way to exhaust fumes - just be aware of this so you do not unwittingly set off the smoke alarm and disturb the neighbors in adjacent units. Also, the door to the bathroom, which is between the two bedrooms within the cottage unit doesn't lock, so you will need to come up with a system to alert your travel partners when someone is using the bathroom to avoid walking in on each other. Other than those two points for awareness, though, everything else is great. The bedrooms are huge, the beds are comfortable, the linens are pristine, the kitchen has everything you need, and the house is right by Otsego Lake and only a block from Main St. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay.

Francine and Vince were wonderful hosts. They went out of their way to make us feel comfortable and provided many suggestions for local places to visit. The location was perfect for us since we were in town to watch our son play baseball. We were close to both All-Star Village and Dreams, which was perfect. The lake was also beautiful. My husband and I had a great time during our stay.

This place was exactly as advertised — an apartment in a beautiful old home, located in a lovely part of Cooperstown. The host provided plenty of towels, basic toiletries, and Keurig coffee pods. The apartment felt even more spacious than it appears in the photos. Our interactions with the hosts were limited, but they were prompt and professional — and everything was as expected so we didn’t need to reach out (how it should be!). Check-in and check-out were both seamless. We visit Cooperstown every year and wouldn’t hesitate to book this place again.

Paul is the best host I have ever communicated with through Airbnb. He is extremely responsive and keeps a very clean place. Will be staying here for years to come.

We loved our stay here! The apartment was very clean and updated and the rooms all stayed cool even when hot out. Beds were very comfortable. The hosts were so responsive and helpful. Would definitely stay here again. Thank you for a great week!

The cottage was amazing: clean, solid construction, great water pressure and an overall beautiful home. We utilized the canoes, kayaks and paddle boards as well as the fire pit and gas grill. The beds were very comfy and there were plenty of blankets.

Amazing area, amazing scenery, worth the money

Went away for the weekend and it was the perfect getaway for us (+ our dog) from the city! Quiet, peaceful, had all the amenities we needed to stay in (hot tub, porch seating, fire pit and streaming on TV), and close to some restaurants and a few cidery/breweries if you wanted to go out. Place was super clean and hosts were very responsive. Would definitely come back and stay for longer if we can next time.

We were looking g for a place for our family of seven while our son did ASV for Cooperstown. This house was perfect to either All Star Village or Dreams Park. There were cute little amenities and the hosts went above and beyond for the little touches they had at the house. It was clean, comfortable, and well stocked. Felt right at home. Air in each room was cold and had its own remote. Great outdoor space and use of games and fishing poles. I will recommending to all my baseball friends who are coming for the tournament.

Beautiful location with lakeside view. Such a peaceful and cozy home. We had everything we could have needed - canoe, kayaks, bikes etc. 20 minutes from Cooperstown Dreams Park. Absolutely gorgeous. One of my most memorable vacation spots. Highly recommend.

Lovely quick getaway from the city! Views are amazing from the property. Easy check in and out … host communicated quickly!

Thank you Myles! We had an amazing and memorable weekend for my son’s graduation! The house and its surroundings where perfect!

We had an amazing time at the house. It was much better than the pictures…very peaceful, private, well furnished in a beautiful location. Highly recommend and we would definitely return.