Vacation rentals with lake access in Goodyear Lake

The Carriage House at Arran Fell Farm

A slice of heaven 7 miles from Cooperstown 16 min from Cooperstown Dreams Park.Immaculate,quiet, peaceful working rescue farm. Come and unwind and sleep in the hammock.Large firepit,outdoor games,animal interaction. Complimentary free range eggs, oj, butter, bagels,cream ,coffee and tea provided. Outdoor gazebo with bbq grill.Pick your own veggies when in season. Hike the trail or take a paddleboat or canoe on the pond. Try some fishing, interact with rescue animals. One of a kind experiences.

The Lily Pad

The Lily Pad is a comfy one room king bed cottage with a porch overlooking the pond. A private full bath is close but not attached (attached to our home for plumbing purposes, but you have a private entry). The paved path is well lit. The cottage is insulated, heated,air conditioned, has electricity,Wi-Fi, and a smart tv used with your accounts. Fishing pole provided. The cottage is separated from our home by a garage. We leave guests uninterrupted unless they want to interact/need anything.

Stunning Pvte Lakehouse•Swim•Hike•Mntn Views•F/pit

Wake up to stunning mountain views & enjoy a coffee next to your own private lake surrounded by 5 secluded acres of the bucolic Catskill Mountains. Swim in the clean, clear lake; lie out on the swim dock; row across the lake in the row boat; grill on the wrap-around porch; cook for friends in the gourmet kitchen, or simply relax by the fire (wood-burning fireplace + lakeside FIREPIT). Mins to breweries, hiking & the trendy town of Phoenicia. You need never leave! This is the ULTIMATE getaway.

Beautiful Farm Cottage & Majestic Waterfall

The Sparrow House is a beautiful farmhouse with a private trail to a majestic 120' waterfall. With vintage wallpapers, eclectic antiques, a cozy fireplace, an outdoor cedar sauna, a large fenced in yard surrounded by honeysuckle vines and a spectacular mountain view, the house is a perfect getaway spot in unspoiled nature and still-wild forests of the Catskills. The waterfall is a truly magical place and considered a sacred site. The house is not appropriate for loud groups or parties. 🙏🦋🙌

PRIVATE LAKE-FRONT Rustic Cabin by NYC Designer

VOTED MOST IDYLLIC SETTING IN THE AREA! Ideal spot on The Lake to slow down, stay a while, and get immersed in the rhythms of the region….. ...through the scenic valleys and country roads brings you grazing sheep and cattle, meandering streams, open fields, mountains and lake views, and finally to a picture perfect lake front cabin called Green Acres on Whiting Hollow Lake. “It’s not every day, you can get so far from the everyday. Yet, so close” MOST BOOKED Airbnb in The Catskills!

Modern Lake Retreat, Sleeps 8, 5 min to Colgate

- 🌅 Waterfront lake views - 🚣 Self-serve kayaks & paddleboard - 🛏️ 2 bedrooms + trundle bed + pull-out couch (sleeps 8) - 🎓 5 minutes to Colgate University - 🕹️ Giant Connect Four - 🎯 Lawn games - 🔥 Electric fireplace - 🍳 Fully stocked kitchen - ☕ Drip & Keurig coffee maker - 🛁 Linens & towels provided *⚠️ Lake Moraine is currently drawn down 10 ft through 2028 for a NYS dam project. Kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing continue unaffected at the Colgate Boathouse next door 🚣*

1820's Farmhouse 182 acres/Private Swimming Pond

Oak Hill Farm c1824, this farmhouse has been fully renovated with a modern take on upstate luxury. Situated on 183 acres of its own land, the house benefits from the views across the valley, spring fed swimming pond and a private mountain top. Enjoy morning strolls through our open hay fields, cookout on the covered deck with a wood burning smoker, gas grill, fire pit. The property has mowed trails through the hay fields, large pathways that are for hiking, foraging, wild life sighting.

Catskills Peakes Brook Cabin-Creek, Pond & Privacy

Take a breath at Peakes Brook Cabin, our cozy and private cabin on a pond, with the brook steaming nearby. Our beloved property is perfect for couples needing to escape the city, decompress and deplug. You're minutes to charming Delhi and other Catskill villages, with nature all around, and our canoe ready for you. We are happy to welcome your doggies, but not your cats due to allergies. Please note that cabin has a kitchenette, not a full kitchen. Looking forward to hosting you!

Contemporary Cabin w/ Hot Tub, Lake & Fireplace

Ticking all the boxes, this beautiful cabin has everything you could want for your retreat from city life! Five acres of private forest encapsulates the perfect seasonal mood as you step from the great room onto the huge wrap-around deck. Relax and enjoy the property with its hot tub, fireplace, A/C, BBQ grill and poolside loungers. For the adventurous at heart, check out the community shared lake access (non fishing), rivers, hiking trails and ski stations right at your fingertips.

Grand View Cottage

Large deck with great view overlooking Silver Lake. Grill available. Dock with one Row Boat and two Kayaks available for your use. One mile walking trail around the lake. Plenty of fishing. Cozy interior space with wood stove. Upstairs loft is a kids space with a winding staircase. All wood interior with full kitchen. Plenty of space. Great Italian restaurant and others within minutes of the cottage. 40 minute drive to Cooperstown. Close to several businesses. Internet only

Dreamy Catskills mountain getaway w/ yoga studio

This stunning house has been renovated and offers total privacy and serenity - sitting on 5 acres at the end of a quiet road. The Mountain Terrace has an indoor wood stove, a deck with a beautiful view, a fire-pit, 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and a double high ceiling in the main living space. There is a washer/dryer, a dishwasher an artist cabin and a private yoga studio. An easy 15 min drive to Livingston Manor for great restaurants, shopping and activities. Pet friendly.

Little Green Lake House

Owned and styled by an artist couple with the dream of creating a place for others to escape, reflect, and feel reinvigorated by nature, this rustic lake house sits right on the banks of Summit Lake in the Catskill Mountains. This thoughtfully renovated 1940s cabin is perfect for couples seeking a romantic weekend, small families wanting a restorative break, writers and artists looking for inspiration, or anyone in need of a quiet, peaceful sanctuary.