Places to stay near Neversink Reservoir

Book unique vacation rentals, homes, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals near Neversink Reservoir

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
Two kayaks, colored yellow and orange, rest on the grassy shore of a serene lake. A small dock extends into the calm water, reflecting the colors of a sunset sky. Trees line the horizon, completing the tranquil lakeside setting.
Cottage in Livingston Manor
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Hot Tub * Private Dock * Quiet Lake Home

Hi, I’m Anna. I’m so glad you’re here, and I’d love to welcome you to The Glass House! Here are a few things I think you’ll especially enjoy about the house. Highlights – You’ll love the: Peaceful waterfront setting – tucked away on the lake, yet just minutes to town Year-round hot tub – the perfect way to unwind after hiking, or exploring Family-perfect layout – two spacious levels with a game/media room and screened porch Kayaks & life vests – easy, safe access to the water for all ages

Guest favorite
A cozy outdoor seating area is surrounded by trees and fallen leaves. Four red chairs are positioned around a wooden table, with a fire pit in the center. String lights are draped overhead, creating a warm ambiance in the natural setting.
Home in Livingston Manor
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

Parkston Schoolhouse

Relax and unwind in this historic converted one-room schoolhouse. Built in 1870, the Parkston Schoolhouse served all grade levels in the Livingston Manor area. The schoolhouse was retired and converted to a cozy cottage style home in the mid 20th century and has recently been renovated into a stylish tiny home getaway. The home is tucked into the hillside along the beautiful, winding Willowemoc Creek and is set amidst a lush Catskill landscape just a five minute drive from Livingston Manor.

Guest favorite
A spacious living area is highlighted by large windows allowing natural light to fill the space. The hardwood floor complements a dining table with chairs, and a cozy seating arrangement near a fireplace. Decor includes plants and a guitar in the corner.
Home in Parksville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 224 reviews

Cooley Mountain House *Hot Tub*

Remove the walls between you and nature in this spacious, vaulted and sun-drenched getaway. Nestled along a mountain stream on a quiet country road in the heart of the western Catskills, this fully redesigned house blends modern comforts with rustic styling, offering you and your guests an open invitation to kickback, “work from nature” or keep playing til sunrise. Under two hours from NYC, and less than 15 minutes from Livingston Manor, Cooley Mountain House keeps everything within reach.

Guest favorite
The all-black A-frame cabin is framed by lush greenery, showcasing its distinctive triangular shape. A set of wooden stairs leads to the entrance, flanked by a deck that extends to the front of the home, inviting guests to relax and enjoy the natural surroundings.
Place to stay in Livingston Manor
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

Designer A-Frame + Barrel Sauna | Vogue-Featured

As seen in Vogue, Domino, Hudson Valley Magazine, and more. NightFox A-Frame is an all-black, architecturally significant cabin located in the Western Catskills hamlet of Livingston Manor. With the local area known for foodie-centric dining experiences, breweries, fly-fishing, hiking, and more, this year-round, 2-bedroom stay is the perfect escape from the city. The a-frame is known for its interior style, with a focus on Scandinavian comfort with 70s mod influence. @nightfox_aframe

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Woodbourne
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 251 reviews

Catskills Mountain Sanctuary

Our cabin is located in the stunning Catskills area of Neversink, NY. A perfect hideaway to embrace a mountain visit, with modern conveniences. 2 acres of private, park-like land, that’s incredibly zen and encourages wandering. Sit near our koi pond, or relax on our decks–each with a view of Lake Paradise. A peaceful sanctuary, our 2 Bedroom cabin features a seasonal (Nov-Apr) wood-burning fireplace, views of nature, and modern amenities for those who don't want to fully unplug.

Top guest favorite
A modern house is nestled among lush green trees, showcasing a spacious deck with outdoor seating. Large windows allow natural light to fill the interior, while the surrounding foliage creates a sense of privacy and tranquility.
Vacation home in Parksville
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 224 reviews

Dreamy Catskills Mountain Getaway w/ Yoga Studio

This stunning house has been renovated and offers total privacy and serenity - sitting on 5 acres at the end of a quiet road. The Mountain Terrace has an indoor wood stove, a deck with a beautiful view, a fire-pit, 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and a double high ceiling in the main living space. There is a washer/dryer, a dishwasher an artist cabin and a private yoga studio. An easy 15 min drive to Livingston Manor for great restaurants, shopping and activities. Pet friendly.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a blue farmhouse cottage is shown, featuring a metal roof and a welcoming front porch with two white chairs. Lush green grass surrounds the house, complemented by blooming hydrangeas and decorative potted plants. Trees and open land are visible in the background.
Cottage in Grahamsville
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

“Green Meadow Cottage”, updated 1850’s farmhouse.

Relax with friends or family in this cozy updated 19th century farmhouse cottage set on 5 acres surrounded by pasture and forest. This is truly a rural setting to enjoy the serenity of nature. Centrally located, a leisurely country drive will take you to quaint towns, spectacular hiking, fine dining and more. Visit our many breweries and distilleries or just take a drive and explore. Bring your bikes and ride the gently rolling wooded roads… or not. It’s your vacation.

Guest favorite
Two wooden Adirondack chairs are positioned on a dock overlooking a calm lake at sunset. A kayak with an oar rests nearby, and the water reflects vibrant hues of orange and pink, bordered by trees in the background.
Cabin in Ferndale
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 301 reviews

Cozy Lakefront Catskills Cabin—2hrs from NYC!

This beautiful lakefront cabin is located at the end of a peaceful road adorned with tire swings and wildflowers. It is situated in a private community on a SMALL 3 acre lake, offering the perfect setting to enjoy morning coffee on the dock, taking refreshing afternoon swims in the lake, going for evening kayaking rides, and stargazing. We've recently added AC for all 3 bedrooms. Lastly, we offer 2 kayaks and 2 SUP's for your enjoyment. Best of all, 2 hrs from NYC.

Guest favorite
An aerial view showcases a charming farmhouse surrounded by lush greenery and the Catskill Mountains. A rectangular in-ground pool is visible in the backyard, bordered by a grassy area. A quiet country road runs alongside the property, contributing to the tranquil setting.
Home in Grahamsville
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Spacious Catskills Farmhouse on over 5 acres!

Summer is the best time to visit the Catskill Mountains! Come enjoy our large in-ground pool! Enjoy a hike at one of our local trails or nature preserves. Try your luck at the casino, spend a day at the indoor water park, or play a round of golf at one of the local courses. You will feel right at home in this charming & restored 5BR farmhouse. Located on 5+ acres near the great Catskills Forest Preserve, this is a great place for four-season recreation.

Top guest favorite
A cabin with a red metal roof is nestled among tall trees beside a gently flowing creek. The structure features large windows, allowing natural light to fill the interior while offering views of the surrounding greenery.
Home in Livingston Manor
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 435 reviews

Peaceful creekside retreat near Livingston Manor

Welcome to our peaceful little cabin, designed for full immersion in nature. Lounge by the creek with the firepit or hammock, gaze out XL windows, or cozy up by the fire in the living room - every detail invites you to slow down. Tucked on a quiet road just minutes from hiking trails and Willowemoc fly fishing, we’re also only a winding 15-minute drive to charming Livingston Manor, a quintessential Catskills town, and less than 2 hours from NYC.

Top guest favorite
An outdoor fire pit surrounded by natural stone is set among a serene landscape. Comfortable seating is arranged nearby, offering a peaceful spot for gathering. Lush greenery and trees frame the property, with the home visible in the background against a soft, colorful sky.
Home in Parksville
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

Catskills: Hot Tub, Games & 10 Acres

Luxurious Catskills family retreat on 10 private acres, just 1.5 hrs from NYC. This meticulously remodeled home comfortably sleeps 9 guests and features a year-round outdoor hot tub, game room, and dedicated workspace. Perfect for nature lovers seeking modern comforts and serene ambiance. Enjoy a private pond, fire pit, and ample space for relaxation and adventure in the beautiful Sullivan Catskills.

Guest favorite
A hot tub is filled with clear water, surrounded by a spacious green lawn. Blue skies and scattered clouds provide a serene backdrop, while a firepit with seating options is visible nearby, inviting relaxation amidst nature.
Home in Town of Neversink
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Modern Riverside in Orchard, Hot tub and Firepit

In the remains of an ancient apple orchard next to the Neversink River sits a modern house with mountain views and valley comforts. With a huge lawn and deck, hot tub and patio with firepit, BBQ gill and the river, it has all you could need for a great country weekend! The evenings are perfect for stargazing and warming your feet by the fire, and days are spent in quiet at the river.

Popular amenities for vacation rentals near Neversink Reservoir