Goodyear Lake vacation rentals

Book unique houses, vacation rentals, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A cozy living area is displayed with warm wooden walls and a plush sofa adorned with vibrant pillows. A small green side table complements the space. A wood stove is positioned nearby, with a window allowing natural light to illuminate the area.

Cabin in Bovina Center

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews

Delightful Cabin with Extras

Come to beautiful Delaware County and settle into serene and comfortable surroundings for a restorative getaway in any season at this lovely Bovina cabin. Enjoy the hot tub, wrap-around deck, firepit, and pristine pond on 8 acres of rolling hillside property. *Notes: While our Air BnB Plus photo shoot was taken in winter, the cabin is a fantastic year-round respite, beautiful in every season. Also - each adult beyond 2 is $25 per night, but we do not charge for children, so do not include kids in your guest # (but let us know). Inside this 2- bdrm Catskills cabin, you'll find an open living/kitchen space with comfy couches and wood stove. Outside, there's a wrap-around deck with grill and hot tub. The cabin sits mountainside on eight beautiful acres of meadows, forest, a fantastic swimming pond and a fire pit. Swimming pond, deck, grill, fire pit, outdoor hot tub, wi-fi, and great local dining and festivals. Nearby farm stands, hiking, skiing, fishing, golf, tennis, and low-key town pool (in Andes). Amazing beef cattle are just down the road, so if you'd like some for the grill, we can put it in the fridge! We live right up the road so are readily available to answer all of your questions and provide whatever we can to make your stay memorable. The cabin is on Bramley Mountain in the beautiful town of Bovina Center. Neighboring farms offer organic veggies, grass-fed meat, cheese, and milk. The town also has top-rated Catskill dining, including Brushland Eating House, Table on Ten, and the Mountain Brook Inn. We're three hours from NYC by car. A beautiful ride! Buses also run regularly from Port Authority to nearby Andes or Delhi, so if you don't have a car, we're happy to pick you up. Fully equipped kitchen, 2 bedrooms (1 queen bed and 1 full bed), blow-up bed, games, books, DVDs and video streaming access.

Top guest favorite

A winding gravel driveway leads to a red house on a grassy hill, surrounded by open fields. A single tree stands nearby under a partly cloudy blue sky, providing a natural focal point in the landscape.

Home in Canajoharie

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

2 homes on large private mountain views getaway

Rent these 5 bedroom 4 bath houses for your next vacation. House sits on top of a hill and has breath taking views, amazing sunrises from the master suite and sunsets from the great room. Home has octagon shape great room with open timber ceiling, large indoor fireplace. Very large and great kitchen for your cooking. Studio has a projector style TV 100 plus inches. Red House/game room with additional 3 queen log beds, full kitchen and bathroom, laundry etc. This home has beautiful open timber.

Guest favorite

A gravel driveway winds through a well-maintained yard, leading towards distant mountains under a clear blue sky. Sparse trees and an American flag add to the serene landscape, indicating a peaceful outdoor setting.

Apartment in Halcott Center

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Mountain View Apartment

We offer a quiet and extremely clean place. We are only 6 miles from Belleayre Mtn Ski Center. Restaurants are nearby. You’ll love our place because of the neighborhood, the outdoors space, the light, and the kitchen. Our place is good for couples, solo adventurers, and business travelers. WIFI is 300mbps. We have security cameras outside only, EV Charging station on the property. We now have an outdoor fire pit (wood not included). We also have a standby generator in case of a power failure.

Guest favorite

Home in Windham

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Catskills Retreat: Hot Tub | Fireplace | Firepit

Year-Round Catskills Retreat Escape to Five Star Cottage in Windham, NY, just 2 hours from NYC. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home features stunning mountain views, a cozy wood-burning fireplace, a hot tub, and a large deck for year-round enjoyment. Ski in the winter, and explore nearby hiking trails, lakes, and waterfalls in the warmer months. Ideal for families and groups seeking adventure, wellness, or a peaceful retreat. Book your stay today and experience the beauty of the Catskills!

Guest favorite

A renovated cottage exterior is displayed, featuring warm wood siding and large windows. A wooden deck with a railing extends from the house, leading to a yard adorned with native grasses and shrubs. A tree stands nearby, enhancing the natural surroundings.

Home in Andes

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Andes Hemlock House

Renovated peaceful and stylish cottage for the ultimate cosy getaway. Easy access during the snowy winter season. Our house sits on a tranquil piece of property surrounded by lush garden that runs along a creek. Within a 20-minute walk from NYC bus stop to home. Very close to the charming village of Andes with all amenities: grocery and antique stores, galleries, restaurants, tap room, swimming pool, tennis courts. Shed converted into office space available for remote work. @andes_hemlock_house

Guest favorite

Cabin in Big Indian

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 319 reviews

Romantic Cabin with Sauna & Wood Fired Hot Tub

Voted GQ 18 Best Airbnbs with Hot Tubs. Under three hours from NYC and just 10 minutes off of Route 28, our rustic cabin is tucked away far from the rest of the world. Nestled in the woods perfectly situated on a hill the five acres of land make you feel completely removed from the city. The property includes a sweeping lawn, a deck for dining or star gazing, an outdoor fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill. Then there's the outdoor wood fired hot tub and sauna - the highlights! (#2022-STR-003)

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Livingston Manor

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Cozy mountain top home - views, 5acres & a gym.

Located 2hrs from NYC, 7mins from Livingston Manor and close to Belleayre and Plattekill ski mountains. Sat atop a mountain, with 5 acres that sweep away from the property revealing stunning long distance views. Beautiful light throughout - front room with fireplace, full renovated kitchen, lounge, dining area, master bedroom, 1 large guest room, office / single bedroom, 2 bathrooms and huge covered back porch + a full home gym complete with Peloton bike, Peloton tread + ping pong table.

Guest favorite

A modern cabin design features broad wooden slats and floor-to-ceiling glass doors. A spacious deck includes loungers and a hot tub, surrounded by lush greenery, enhancing the outdoor aesthetic. Soft lighting illuminates the seating area, creating a welcoming environment.

Home in Hunter

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Modern House with Mountain View @Getawind

Experience luxury and comfort in our newly built property. Marvel at the breathtaking panoramic views of Rusk mountain through floor-to-ceiling windows. Unwind in the sauna or hot tub, and gather around the fire pit for cozy evenings. Enjoy outdoor movie nights with our projector, or savor grilled delights in the patio area. Warm up by the fireplace, explore Ski resorts, Golf Clubs and more. It's the perfect retreat for families and friends. Book now and create unforgettable memories!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Shandaken

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

A Place Called Home in The Catskill

Peaceful. Serene. Quiet. That's how it feels when you spend your time at my Catskills cabin. With a 3400 sq ft of living area, nestled in a 2 acre lot of land with picturesque mountain views, it is a perfect getaway destination. For those looking for fun activities, it is located only 15-45 mins away from 3 ski resorts (Bellayre, Hunter and Wyndham) and is close to many hiking trails and exciting towns of Phoenicia, Woodstock, Tannersville & Kingston. Think Unwind. Relax. Enjoy.

Guest favorite

A serene river flows gently through a verdant landscape. Lush greenery lines the banks, with scattered rocks partially visible in the water. A gazebo can be seen in the distance, nestled among the trees, under a bright blue sky dotted with white clouds.

Home in Phoenicia

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

Heart of Phoenicia: Serene. Cozy. Close to all.

"Such a cute place with cabin-in-the-woods vibes but all the conveniences of being in town." What Shannon said in a 5 star review after her stay. I couldn't have put it better. Relax and reconnect in this calm and quiet little house nestled in the center of our cool village. You're on the doorstep of hiking trails with breathtaking views and gorgeous trout streams. Lounge around a glowing campfire in the back yard with S’mores or spin viny. On NYC bus route and ski shuttle.

Superhost

A wooden dock is positioned by a calm river, surrounded by lush green trees. The vibrant foliage reflects the tranquility of the natural setting, while the water gently ripples in the foreground.

Home in Middletown

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Riverfront! Swim, Fish, Hot Tub & Game Barn.

Fish, Tube, Hot tub and Game room! All in one property! This exquisite riverfront home has 3 bedrooms and a sleeping loft. This magical property is 7 acres on the River. Bellayre beach 15 mins and Windham mountain biking 30 mins. Hike, s’mores by the fire, hang out in the 3 season game barn equipped with a pool table and darts, have a drink in the riverside hot tub. 5 mins to retro bowling and restaurants. NO FIRST TIME RENTERS ID VERIFIED/REVIEWED RENTERS ONLY.

Top guest favorite

A view from the covered deck showcases rolling hills and lush greenery. The well-maintained lawn leads into a natural landscape with trees and shrubs, creating a serene atmosphere. Overcast skies complement the vibrant shades of green, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Cottage in Milford

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

At Home Base Yellow Cottage

Enjoy the Cooperstown experience while having all the comforts of home. The Baseball Hall of Fame (6 miles), Brewery Ommegang (5.4 miles), and The Cooperstown Dreams Park (0.5 miles) are all conveniently located. Scenic views from the large-covered deck of the rolling hills set on 20 acres. Check out all of the amenities including high speed internet, central air, and a BBQ grill. View our other “Home Base” listings here on Airbnb, all in the vicinity of one another.