Become a host

Waterfront vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique waterfront rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated waterfront rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these waterfront rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Superhost
Four rustic wooden Adirondack chairs are arranged around a stone fire pit in a grassy area beside Oaks Creek. The lush greenery contrasts with the flowing water and dense trees in the background, providing a peaceful outdoor setting for relaxation.
Home in Fly Creek

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House

ViewRiverQuiet

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 277 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cabin in Jefferson

Experience a Catskills Lodge

Our modern log home is set up with fine things like Turkish towels, local artisan soaps & the softest sheets. The tasteful decor has an mcm vibe w/industrial touches. Wander outdoors, swim, follow a creek, slip into the forest, hike back, cook dinner in a state of the art kitchen w/ a pantry full of fun gadgets. Relax by the fireplace, sit outside & watch the stars, light a fire. We provide blankets & wood. A welcome basket & a fully stocked coffee bar for the early mornings are waiting for you.

RiverViewIndoor spaces

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews
Top guest favorite
The A-frame cabin is surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage, showcasing hues of gold and orange. A welcoming red door stands out against the green exterior. A wooden deck extends from the cabin, providing an inviting entry point amidst the natural landscape.
Cabin in Margaretville

The Waterfall Casita: A-frame with 30ft Waterfall

Nestled among Hemlock trees & steps from a 30 ft waterfall is our cozy A-frame cabin. Sitting on 33 private acres connected to state land, enjoy waterfall views while sipping coffee in front of the fireplace. The casita was intentionally designed to feel like a home away from home. In summer, cool off in the waterfalls & private streams, in autumn take in the stunning foliage & in winter ski/snowboard at Belleayre (25 mins away). Alder Lake & the Pepacton Reservoir fishing are a 10 min drive.

ViewRiverSleep quality

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 273 reviews
Top guest favorite
A rustic cabin is set against a backdrop of lush greenery, featuring a spacious wooden deck with a dining table and chairs. Inside, a cozy sleeping area showcases a neatly made bed with soft linens, while the warm wood interior adds to the inviting ambiance.
Cabin in Oneonta

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands

Summer baseball renters please note: availability is Dreams Park tournament schedule ONLY -- not All Star! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! Built in the 18th century, it now boasts an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake 5 mins away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!

ViewParkingHiking

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene view of the cabin set amidst lush greenery, with a calm stream flowing nearby. The deck is visible, and seating areas are arranged on the manicured lawn. Surrounding trees offer a sense of seclusion, enhancing the natural ambiance of the location.
Cabin in Hardenburgh

Catskills Cabin Oasis: Hot Tub, Hike, Creek, Relax

Escape to a secluded Catskills cabin with hot tub, forest views, fireplace, and walkable access to Balsam Lake Trailhead. Relax in the hot tub under the stars, enjoy coffee on the deck beside a babbling creek, and unwind by the historic fireplace built in 1920. Just 10 minutes to Belleayre Mountain for skiing, tubing, hiking, and lake days. Perfect for couples getaways, family weekend escapes, hiking trips, ski weekends, and year-round Catskills adventures. Welcome to Catskill Cabin Oasis!

ViewRiverValue

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews
Top guest favorite
A tranquil lake is framed by vibrant yellow iris flowers and lush green foliage. The house is visible in the background, surrounded by dense woodland, with a sloped roof and large windows reflecting the natural beauty of the surroundings. Soft clouds drift in a blue sky.
Home in Otego

Secluded Lakefront Art Retreat with Stunning Views

Welcome to our sweet lakefront paradise, a secluded pyramid house nestled on 60 acres in the Catskill foothills. Guests find it peaceful and restorative: a perfect balance of design and modern comfort. Our home features a thoughtful selection of books, original art, and sculptures throughout. Many guests say they leave feeling refreshed and inspired. BASEBALL FAMILIES: This setting is completely private yet conveniently located. We are just 8.9 miles from Cooperstown All-Star Village.

ViewGetting aroundTV

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews
Guest favorite
The cottage is elevated on a hill, featuring a large wooden deck surrounded by landscaped greenery. Multiple large windows provide a view from the deck, with a path leading up to the entrance. The setting is wooded, offering a sense of privacy.
Cottage in New Berlin

Grand View Cottage

Large deck with great view overlooking Silver Lake. Grill available. Dock with one Row Boat and two Kayaks available for your use. One mile walking trail around the lake. Plenty of fishing. Cozy interior space with wood stove. Upstairs loft is a kids space with a winding staircase. All wood interior with full kitchen. Plenty of space. Great Italian restaurant and others within minutes of the cottage. 40 minute drive to Cooperstown. Close to several businesses. Internet only

BeachViewDecor

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews
Top guest favorite
A two-story home is showcased with light blue siding and stone accents. The front features multiple large windows and two spacious balconies. Seating is arranged on the lower patio, complemented by a grill. Surrounding greenery and trees enhance the property’s natural setting.
Home in Richfield Springs

Luxury Cooperstown Area Lake Home with Amenities!!

2027 Summer Bookings open 10/1, we only accept 6 night stays aligned with “Cooperstown Dreams Park” schedule, see their site for schedule. “Allstar Village” schedule does not align with us. The 2027 season is 5/30-8/22/26. Beautiful 3 bedroom on Canadarago Lake, 15 min. drive to Cooperstown. We now have 6 kayaks, a pedal boat, & a paddle board! Enjoy coffee viewing the peacefulness of the lake, if mornings aren’t for you, It is as beautiful at sunset with wine.

ViewTVSolo travel

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 306 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cabin in Summit

Little Green Lake House

Owned and styled by an artist couple with the dream of creating a place for others to escape, reflect, and feel reinvigorated by nature, this rustic lake house sits right on the banks of Summit Lake in the Catskill Mountains. This thoughtfully renovated 1940s cabin is perfect for couples seeking a romantic weekend, small families wanting a restorative break, writers and artists looking for inspiration, or anyone in need of a quiet, peaceful sanctuary.

ViewBackyardAccuracy

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cabin in Otego

Cozy log cabin in the mountains

Cozy log cabin in the mountains located 5 mi from city of Oneonta & 25 miles to Cooperstown. Attractions include Cooperstown hall of fame, Cooperstown All StarVillage, Cooperstown Dream Park, Ommegang Brewery & golf. Family friendly atmosphere that includes a 3 bedroom house with kitchen amenities, a charcoal grill, and fire pit. The house has WiFi with a smart tv in each of the three bedrooms. Screened-in porch that overlooks a lake-sized pond.

BeachViewParks

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews
Guest favorite
A porch area is visible, featuring a pair of chairs and seasonal flower decorations in pots. The entrance is adorned with potted plants, while the façade of the building displays wooden siding and multiple windows. A yard with greenery is seen in the background.
Apartment in Cooperstown

One Bedroom Apt Near Dreams Park and Hall of Fame.

The apartment has one bedroom with queen bed, a bathroom, living room/ kitchen, a cott, and WiFi. We're located on 2 rivers, in a beautiful scenic valley near Cooperstown, 5 miles from Dreamspark, and one minute to the Cooperstown Train, which offers various themed rides as well as hand carts. We're 3 miles from famous Ommegang, and 2 other breweries! 20 miles south is Hanford Mills, an authentic 19th century water powered factory!

ViewRiverQuiet

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews
Guest favorite
An aerial view showcases the Over Water Bungalow with a green metal roof, surrounded by serene waters and lush greenery. The cabin features a wrap-around deck, enhancing access to nature, while the peaceful setting invites relaxation.
Cabin in Otego

Catskills Over Water Bungalow on Lake Albanese!

Catskills Cabin Rentals has designed and built one of the most unique places in the Catskills. Located on Lake Albanese is New York's first Over Water Bungalow featuring 2 bedrooms 1.5 bathrooms. The living room has a wood burning fireplace made with handcrafted stone. In front of the fireplace the home has a glass floor to see fish, turtles, frogs, and more! The home is located on 200 acres with only 4 other log cabins.

ViewConditionCheck-in

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Popular amenities for Goodyear Lake waterfront rentals

KitchenWifiPoolFree parking on premisesAir conditioning

Waterfront apartment rentals

Top guest favorite
A spacious bed adorned with white linens sits against a wall featuring a decorative tree of life design. Soft lighting is provided by wall sconces on either side. A decorative pillow adds a touch of comfort, with a bedside table displaying a clock and additional items.
Apartment in Cooperstown

The Carriage House at Arran Fell Farm

ViewLocationAir conditioning

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews
Top guest favorite
Lush, vibrant trees display autumn colors reflecting on the calm waters of the lake. A serene shoreline is visible, dotted with boats, while two graceful sculptures of herons stand in the foreground, enhancing the tranquil lakeside setting.
Apartment in West Edmeston

Blue Heron Lake House on Gorton Lake

ViewPetsLong stay

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene view is presented from a window, showcasing the calm water of a river bordered by grassy banks. In the background, gentle hills are visible under a clear blue sky. Nearby buildings feature charming architectural details, enhancing the quaint village setting.
Apartment in Margaretville

Binnekill Views Apt.1 in the Catskill Mountains

RiverViewWifi

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews
Top guest favorite
The image captures a view of a serene lake framed by tall pine trees. The calm water reflects the surrounding landscape, with wooden homes visible along the opposite shore. A clear blue sky completes the tranquil scene, enhancing the natural beauty of the area.
Apartment in West Edmeston

Lakehouse on Gorton Lake.

ViewFamilyHospitality

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews
Top guest favorite
A charming red farmhouse is set against a clear blue sky, surrounded by lush greenery and rocky landscaping. The structure showcases multiple windows and a steep roof, blending harmoniously with the scenic Catskill Mountain backdrop.
Apartment in Delhi

The Holstein Suite at the Carriage House

RiverViewBackyard

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews
Guest favorite
A wooden swing hangs from a porch, facing a serene lake view. Lush green grass and scattered trees border the water. A picnic table sits in the distance, offering a space for outdoor dining. Sunlight reflects off the lake, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.
Apartment in Richfield Springs

Breezy Point -New construction, amazing waterfront

ViewAccuracyKitchen

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews
Top guest favorite
A spacious living area is presented, featuring a brown leather sectional sofa and an ottoman, complemented by decorative pillows. Natural light enters through two large windows, illuminating a decorative area rug and a side table. A mirror and a lamp enhance the room's functionality.
Apartment in Delhi

Riverside Bliss Private 2nd Floor Apartment

ViewRiverAccess

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviewsA serene winter scene is captured, featuring a gently frozen pond surrounded by snow-covered rocks. In the background, a spacious white house is nestled among tall trees, with sunlight illuminating the landscape and casting soft shadows on the pristine snow.
Apartment in Fleischmanns

Belleayre Mountain Private Luxury Ski Retreat

ViewIndoor spacesHospitality

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Waterfront house rentals

Superhost
A craftsman-style home is surrounded by lush greenery and vibrant flowers. Tall trees and a bush with pink blooms frame the front porch, which features dark wooden planks. Bright blue accents on the house create a welcoming contrast against the natural surroundings.
Home in Stamford

The Catskill Craftman Cabin

ViewFamilyWalkability

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews
Top guest favorite
Aerial view captures the chalet nestled amongst lush greenery, with a large lake reflecting the surrounding mountains. The expansive property showcases dense trees leading to the water's edge, providing a serene atmosphere in a secluded natural setting.
Home in South Kortright

Lakefront chalet w. hot tub, game room, & kayaks

ViewBeachBathroom

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene waterfall cascades over moss-covered rock shelves, creating a tranquil pool at the base. The surrounding area is framed by dark, textured stones and lush green foliage, contributing to a peaceful, natural environment.
Home in Middleburgh

Beautiful Farmhouse & Majestic Waterfall

RiverViewHiking

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in Franklin

Restored Farmhouse & Private Lake on 100+ Acres

ViewAccuracyCheckout

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews
Guest favorite
Home in Prattsville

The Fireside: An Expansive Catskills Escape

RiverViewSkiing

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews
Superhost
A serene lakefront view is presented, showcasing clear blue waters under a bright sky. The deck extends from the home, providing an inviting space for relaxation. Nearby foliage adds a touch of natural beauty, with distant hills visible across the lake.
Home in Richfield Springs

Beautiful Big Lake Front home near Cooperstown

ViewAccuracyValue

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews
Guest favorite
A vibrant red barn is set against a backdrop of rolling green fields and colorful autumn foliage. The surrounding trees display shades of orange, yellow, and green, while distant mountains rise under a clear blue sky.
Home in Town of Gilboa

Mountain Views & Private Stream

ViewRiverOutdoor spaces

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews
Guest favorite
The charming mountainside house features a rustic wooden deck with railings, providing an inviting outdoor space. A mixture of blue siding and stone accents characterize the exterior, surrounded by lush greenery and trees, creating a peaceful natural setting.
Home in Big Indian

Catskills Hiking Skiing Belleayre Full Moon Resort

ViewRiverTV

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Other waterfront vacation rentals

Superhost
A white two-story farmhouse stands adjacent to a flowing stream, surrounded by lush green grass and trees. The porch offers a welcoming entrance while the natural landscape creates a peaceful setting, enhanced by the sound of the nearby water.
Cottage in Hobart

🌟Riverfront Cottage W/2 Bedrooms Catskills 🌟

RiverViewIndoor spaces

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews
Guest favorite
A private hot tub is set against a backdrop of lush greenery and rustic wooden panels. Soft lighting illuminates the area, creating a calming environment. A wooden bench is positioned nearby, further enhancing the serene setting.
Farm stay in Harpersfield

Three Willows | Pond, Sauna & Treehouse Retreat

ViewAir conditioningDecor

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews
Guest favorite
An aerial view showcases a modern dome structure on a spacious property, illuminated against the night. Surrounding pathways are lined with lights, enhancing the serene outdoor setting. Nearby, a tent with soft lighting hints at an inviting gathering space.
Dome in Hobart

Mtn View Lux Dome w/ Heated Plunge Pool

ViewHot tubAmenities

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews
Guest favorite
A tiny cabin with a unique Japanese-inspired design is nestled among tall trees, accompanied by a gravel pathway and a small fire pit. The cabin's natural wood exterior blends with the forest surroundings, creating a serene atmosphere beside a flowing brook.
Cabin in Downsville

Tiny glamping cabin with mineral spring hot tub

ViewRiverAccuracy

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 355 reviews
Guest favorite
A spacious living room features large windows that offer a view of the lake. A red sofa and comfortable chairs are arranged around a central area, complemented by a bookshelf filled with books and decorative items. Natural light floods the space, highlighting the wooden ceiling.
Cabin in New Berlin

Silver Lake Cabin w/ Own Lake! (near Cooperstown)

RiverViewBiking

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 307 reviews
Guest favorite
A gravel pathway leads towards a rustic wooden cabin, framed by evergreen trees. Natural stone formations and a grassy area provide a welcoming approach to the home, which features a deck overlooking the surroundings, inviting a sense of connection to nature.
Cabin in Jefferson

Dino's Black Bear Cabin

ViewQuietLocation

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cabin in Margaretville

Outdoor Sauna; Secluded Creek; Dog-friendly

RiverViewAccuracy

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews
Guest favorite
The exterior of a recently renovated house is shown, framed by lush green trees. A wooden deck leads to the front door, which features a decorative wreath. The light-colored siding and multiple windows create a welcoming entryway.
Home in Maryland

The Roost: Cozy Lakefront Vacation Getaway

ViewRiverAir conditioning

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Destinations to explore