Become a host

House vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Superhost
Four rustic wooden Adirondack chairs are arranged around a stone fire pit in a grassy area beside Oaks Creek. The lush greenery contrasts with the flowing water and dense trees in the background, providing a peaceful outdoor setting for relaxation.
Home in Fly Creek

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 277 reviews
Guest favorite
The exterior view of Camp Havon reveals a two-story building nestled among trees, with multiple decks and large windows. The landscaped garden features stone paths and greenery, complementing the natural surroundings. The structure's varied textures and materials add visual interest to the inviting atmosphere.
Home in Maryland

Private waterfront home on Goodyear Lake!

Camp Havon - is a wonderful home on picturesque Goodyear Lake! The private waterfront is a rare find being that it is flat and grassy right by the water! That is not often the case with waterfront homes. Enjoy all the water fun swimming, fishing and or boating. You can bring your own boat or rent a kayak from the shop on the lake. When you're not indulging in water activates you can enjoy the the wonderful views of Goodyear Lake from the firepit on the patio by the house or one of the many level

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews
Top guest favorite
A view from a private porch showcases a spacious green yard surrounded by trees. A storage shed is visible in the background, with a basketball hoop nearby. The intricate white railing features a nature-inspired design that complements the serene outdoor surroundings.
Home in Schenevus

Main Street in the Mountains. See sights & scenery

Enjoy nature: hiking, fishing, (backyard creek/nearby lake) or enjoy the sights. Located 20 minutes from Cooperstown, Oneonta, & Cobleskill. Be moments from local attractions: Baseball Hall of Fame, Farmer's Museum, & more like local breweries (Ommegang), baseball camps; Dreams Park/All Star Village, colleges: Hartwick, SUNY Oneonta, & SUNY Cobleskill, & Bassett Healthcare locations. If staying in, there's high speed internet, streaming channels, washer & dryer, private porch, & access to yard

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in Franklin

Gorgeous Cabin w/ Epic Views near All Star Village

Retreat to this Unique, Private Cabin on 14 private acres. Enjoy the vast mountain views and endless stars from the cozy front porch or the screened private balcony off the master bedroom. Enjoy the meditation chapel and heated guest house. Eat from apple and peach trees. Essentials include pellet stove, washer/dryer, fire pit BBQ and all essential appliances. 13 mins to the Cooperstown Baseball All Star Village. 2 miles to the Historic Village of Franklin. Vibrant Oneonta is 12 mins away.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews
Top guest favorite
A scenic view of Cooper Creek's property is captured, featuring a rainbow arching over green fields and trees. Various buildings, including the main house, are visible in the background against a backdrop of soft blue skies and hints of clouds.
Home in West Oneonta

Cooper Creek

Cooper Creek is a valuable piece of central New York history that was built in the late 1700s. This homestead once included an outhouse, a spring house, a Cooper shed, and a proud hand hewn timber barn. Robby and Eileen Robbins purchased the property in 1984-finding it in desperate need of plumbing, electricity, as well as emergent repairs in order to preserve as much history as possible. The 18th century beams,& the wooden pegs used instead of nails helps it maintain its unique identity.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews
Top guest favorite
A spacious bedroom is highlighted by a large bed with a dark wooden frame, accented by various pillows. The room features two windows with light-filtering blinds and is illuminated by mounted wall sconces. The rich hardwood floor complements the room's contemporary design.
Home in Oneonta

Beautifully renovated interior, large 3 BR 2.5 BA

Beautifully 100% renovated interior with large master suite, 2 large bedrooms, laundry, formal seating area, living room and dining room. Solid hardwood throughout, tiled bathrooms, Large kitchen with granite counters and new appliances. Cleanest accommodations you will find. The exterior of the house is unattractive but the upgrades underway. Please excuse the mess while we continue to improve the home and make it one of the nicest Airbnb stays in the area. You will not be disappointed.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews
Top guest favorite
A cozy outdoor space features comfortable seating and a modern fireplace, set against a stunning backdrop of lush trees and a colorful sunset. A hot tub is visible nearby, inviting relaxation. Soft lighting adds a warm touch to the tranquil atmosphere.
Home in Lexington

Valley View Chalet: AC, Hot Tub, Firepit, Games

Spacious, peaceful lux cabin atop the Catskills. Enjoy mountain views and soak in the hot tub. Catch up in the vaulted room by the stone fireplace w/ a wide game selection, with a 2nd living room downstairs. Host a dinner party with our fully equipped kitchen. 20 mins to 6 towns. Visit breweries, antique shops, dine, hike, fish, golf, or relax. Great for groups, families, kids & pets. Fast 600mb internet, AC, EV charger, generator. WFH, newborn, pet friendly. 3+ nights get discounted rate

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews
Top guest favorite
A tranquil lake is framed by vibrant yellow iris flowers and lush green foliage. The house is visible in the background, surrounded by dense woodland, with a sloped roof and large windows reflecting the natural beauty of the surroundings. Soft clouds drift in a blue sky.
Home in Otego

Secluded Lakefront Art Retreat with Stunning Views

Welcome to our sweet lakefront paradise, a secluded pyramid house nestled on 60 acres in the Catskill foothills. Guests find it peaceful and restorative: a perfect balance of design and modern comfort. Our home features a thoughtful selection of books, original art, and sculptures throughout. Many guests say they leave feeling refreshed and inspired. BASEBALL FAMILIES: This setting is completely private yet conveniently located. We are just 8.9 miles from Cooperstown All-Star Village.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews
Top guest favorite
A firepit surrounded by five wooden chairs is positioned on a gravel area, offering expansive views of the rolling hills at sunset. String lights above enhance the ambiance as the sky transitions into warm hues of orange and purple.
Home in Jefferson

Catskills Mountaintop House w/ HOT TUB and VIEWS!

Welcome to the best sweeping views in all of the Catskills! This secluded getaway sits on more than 8 acres of land without a neighbor in sight! Whether you are looking to vacation with friends and family, or a romantic escape, this is the place for you. Enjoy this 3 BD 2.5 BA home year round, including our 8 person hot tub! Amenities galore including outdoor firepit, lounge chairs, sledding, BBQ, ping pong, board games, TV and more. This house is perfect for travelers of all types!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews
Top guest favorite
A well-appointed kitchen area features a central island with four stools, ideal for casual dining. Modern appliances include a refrigerator and microwave, complemented by cabinets showcasing glass doors. The spacious layout is illuminated by ceiling lights and natural light from adjacent areas.
Home in Milford

Best Bet! 10 mins to Baseball Hall of Fame!

Beautifully appointed, immaculate, comfortable home, with a spacious deck and mountain view just 10 minutes from Cooperstown and 1. 6 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park. Convenient to hiking, fishing, kayaking, great restaurants, and all that Cooperstown has to offer. Our home offers an inviting great room with kitchen, dining room, and living room perfect for family gatherings. There is a small study/gaming room too. Comfortable beds, and quick wifi are the icing on the cake!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews
Top guest favorite
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed layered with a light-colored blanket. Natural light filters through large windows adorned with light curtains, illuminating the room. A stylish rug adds texture to the hardwood floor, while modern pendant lights hang from the ceiling.
Home in Worcester

Tranquil Countryside Escape

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful house in the countryside of New York. A newly renovated 3 bedroom with an expansive yard gives you plenty of space to have fun both inside and outside. Nestled between the mountains the surrounding towns allow for plenty of outdoor activities for all to enjoy. We are also only a 30 minute drive to Cooperstown and the famous baseball hall of fame. Come experience the serentiy and opportunities that this house/location have to offer!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews
Guest favorite
A charming home with a red metal roof is set against a clear blue sky, surrounded by lush green lawn and trees. A spacious driveway leads to the front entrance, enhancing the inviting appeal of the property.
Home in Otego

Bailey's Creek

Tucked up in the hills outside of Oneonta, this property is convenient to the baseball tournaments, but enjoys the quiet of the country. This home is set in a private setting with room to roam in the large well manicured yard with a stream running through the middle of the property. Guests will be able to gather together in the open concept kitchen, dining room and living room area and share many memories. This 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home is waiting for you and your family.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Popular amenities for Goodyear Lake house rentals

KitchenWifiPoolFree parking on premisesAir conditioning

House rentals with a pool

Top guest favorite
A wooden hot tub is situated on a spacious deck, offering views of rolling hills and a blue sky dotted with clouds. The bubbling water reflects the sunlight, creating a serene atmosphere conducive to relaxation and enjoyment of the surrounding natural landscape.
Home in Delhi

Catskills Barn Apt with MTN views on 34 acres

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 318 reviews
Guest favorite
A spacious deck features two comfortable chairs and a round table at its center, offering a clear view of the expansive Catskill Mountain landscape. Lush greenery and rolling hills stretch into the distance under a bright blue sky.
Home in Stamford

Hawk View

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews
Top guest favorite
A dog sits upright on a wooden chair at a kitchen countertop. The space features warm wooden accents and a cozy atmosphere, with a sofa and dining area visible in the background. Natural light filters through a nearby window, highlighting the dog's glossy coat.
Home in Downsville

Trout fishing on the Delaware

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews
Top guest favorite
An aerial view captures the expansive 20-acre estate, surrounded by lush greenery and mature trees. The property features well-manicured lawns, a built-in heated pool, and a serene lake visible in the distance, offering a sense of natural seclusion.
Home in Maryland

Close to CooperstownPool Home with Valley View!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews
Top guest favorite
The exterior of the house features a single-story design with a welcoming porch adorned with chairs. A well-maintained lawn surrounds the property, with a circular pathway leading to the entrance. Trees and shrubs add greenery, while a colorful shed and car are visible in the background.
Home in Oneonta

Wood Chip Station

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews
Guest favorite
A serene outdoor area features a turquoise pool surrounded by a spacious patio. The inviting seating arrangement includes stylish lounge chairs and a shaded table area. Elegant lamp posts are positioned around the pool, enhancing the relaxed ambiance, while a decorative sculpture adds character to the space.
Home in Oneonta

Arianna

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews
Guest favorite
Home in Cooperstown

All-Star Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Arcade, 2 Game Rooms

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews
Guest favorite
A comfortable living room features two soft sofas adorned with decorative throw pillows. A wooden coffee table sits centrally on a patterned rug, while large windows allow natural light to brighten the space. A mirror on the wall enhances the room's openness.
Home in Oneonta

Cooperstown Baseball Rentals - Columbia House

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Weekly house rentals

Superhost
Home in Maryland

The Goodyear LakeShore Lodge

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews
Guest favorite
The exterior of a recently renovated house is shown, framed by lush green trees. A wooden deck leads to the front door, which features a decorative wreath. The light-colored siding and multiple windows create a welcoming entryway.
Home in Maryland

The Roost: Cozy Lakefront Vacation Getaway

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews
Top guest favorite
A new wooden dock stretches into the calm water of Goodyear Lake, framed by lush green hills in the distance. The surface of the lake reflects the blue sky and white clouds, creating a serene atmosphere ideal for relaxation.
Home in Maryland

Goodyear Lake Rental - Lakeside Baseball Getaway

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews
Superhost
A tranquil view of the Susquehanna River reflects the surrounding greenery and structures, including a mix of residential buildings and docks. Lush trees line the banks, providing a serene backdrop against the bright blue sky with scattered clouds.
Home in Portlandville

Waterfront Cooperstown Rt 28 Discounted OffSeason

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene waterfront view is captured, showcasing calm waters bordered by green trees and lush vegetation. A wooden deck extends along the water, providing a peaceful space to enjoy the scenery under a clear blue sky.
Home in Portlandville

Eagle River

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 80 reviews
Superhost
Home in Portlandville

Riverview - Grill, Private Dock, Lake Access!

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in Oneonta

Diamond on 7

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews
Top guest favorite
The kitchen showcases an open-concept design with warm wooden accents. A large dining table surrounded by wooden chairs is positioned under a stylish light fixture. The space features a stainless steel refrigerator, countertop appliances, and natural light streaming through a nearby window.
Home in Oneonta

Comfortable Luxury Near Cooperstown and Colleges

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Private house rentals

Top guest favorite
Home in Oneonta

GameRm-Waterfall w/Deck-Slp28-FirePit-PavilionVIEW

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews
Top guest favorite
The contemporary house is surrounded by vibrant greenery, featuring a manicured lawn and colorful flowering shrubs. Large windows reflect natural light while the rooflines create a modern aesthetic. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, offering a welcoming approach to the home.
Home in Oneonta

Emmons Hill Escape

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews
Top guest favorite
The farmhouse is presented with a charming exterior featuring a covered porch equipped with rocking chairs. Flower boxes enhance the entryway, and the well-maintained lawn provides a spacious area for activities. The sky above is partly cloudy, adding to the serene atmosphere.
Home in Oneonta

Cooperstown Baseball Rental: Welcoming Farmhouse

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews
Top guest favorite
A two-story house is set amid wooded surroundings, featuring a beige facade with dark shutters. A welcoming front porch is adorned with two wooden chairs and a small table. A gravel pathway leads to the entrance, providing easy access.
Home in East Meredith

Birch Hollow, a Tranquil Catskills Home!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews
Guest favorite
Home in Oneonta

The Birchwood

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews
Top guest favorite
The image features a welcoming cottage exterior, with a wrap-around porch framed by vibrant pink flowering plants and lush green foliage. A large tree is positioned nearby, adding to the natural beauty of the setting. A paved pathway leads to the entrance, inviting guests to explore.
Home in Schenevus

Cherry Creek Cottage - Cooperstown

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 96 reviews
Guest favorite
A two-story house features a light pink exterior with decorative white trim. The front porch is adorned with railing and decorative elements, offering steps leading to the entrance. Lush greenery surrounds the property, providing a natural backdrop.
Home in Oneonta

Convenient to everything Oneonta and Cooperstown!!

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 75 reviews
Superhost
Home in Oneonta

Charming Farmhouse in Oneonta

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Destinations to explore