House vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Our stay was amazing! We were looking for a peaceful stay for our anniversary and the house whas exactly what we were hoping for. It was immaculate and everything was well thought out. We will definitely be back if we come to the area again!

The house is really gorgeous. Everything was very new/modern, clean, and comfortable. We enjoyed cooking meals in the kitchen overlooking the stunning view out the back. The hot tub and fire put were nice amenities to enjoy. The BBQ seemed to not be working, but other than that, no complaints. Location wise, the property is located in the northwest Catskills, near Stamford, NY, and convenient to many hiking spots in the area as well as nearby towns. The property itself its up on a hill, in what felt like a secluded and private spot, which made it feel like a real getaway and retreat. In sum, recommend this Airbnb for the nice amenities, modern touches, and amazing view.

We had a wonderful weekend! The views were spectacular! We attended a wedding in Andes and the location was perfect.

Cassandra is an excellent host - home was great for what we needed for our Cooperstown tournament. Greet location to the park, excellent restaurants close by, and anything that popped up, she was responsive and quick to resolve. Would absolutely recommend this place and host!

Home was clean and just as described. Unfortunately the weather has not cooperated so far this spring and we weren’t able to enjoy the pool and outside area but that was out of anyone’s control. We were made well aware of this far in advance. We attended our nieces wedding at The Rosemary at Spano Lake and this was only a 20 minute drive to the venue and easily accommodated our family of 8 adults, 1 child and a baby.

John was a fantastic host and I am already looking forward to our next stay. If your looking for a great place to stay while staying in the Catskills then I highly recommend John's place.

Great place!! Stayed for the baseball tournament. Super close to the fields!!

A Hidden Gem for the Perfect Long Weekend! This place is absolutely stunning—so peaceful, private, and exactly what we needed for a long weekend getaway. One of my favorite things was how secluded it felt. It truly gave us that “escape from the world” vibe. We had the best time paddle boarding on the pond, soaking up the sun, and even getting in some friendly pickleball matches. The space is beautifully maintained, with everything you need for a relaxing and fun stay. Perfect for families. One tip: don’t forget the bug spray! We didn’t pack any and ended up being a feast for the mosquitos. But honestly, even that couldn’t take away from how magical this spot is. Can’t wait to come back!

We had a great visit while at Dmitri's house. It rained and was cold while we were there at the end of May. But the house was so comfortable and the scenic location made up for the bad weather. The house was very clean, has many amenities, including great natural light throughout the home, spacious bedroom spaces, modern decor, a fully equipped kitchen, four full bathrooms, a sauna, and a hot tub. The surrounding property, deck, and outdoor space is beautiful; although we didn't have a chance to enjoy it fully due to the weather. We would definitely book this home again.

We had a lovely stay at this cozy country retreat. The surroundings were peaceful, with beautiful views. The home was clean, well-equipped, and had all the little touches that made it feel welcoming. Our host was responsive and made sure we had everything we needed. It was the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy some quiet time away from the city. Highly recommend!

Colone Cottage was warm and welcoming and perfect for our two night stay to attend our daughter’s graduation from Hartwick College.

We had a lovely stay! Stocked kitchen to prepare everything you need to keep you fueled up while enjoying the outdoors. This home has everything the family needs to take full advantage of the lake and the yard. We were pleasantly surprised to be able to play badminton and kick around a soccer ball after kayaking on the lake. And at night the game room is stocked with various games to keep you and your family entertained. So grateful to have spent our long weekend here. Highly recommend.

Brent was an exceptional host for our three-night riverside stay. Despite the rainy weekend, we thoroughly enjoyed our time here. The location was perfect - just a 20-minute drive from Cooperstown, making it an ideal base for my father's bucket list trip to the Baseball Hall of Fame. The area offers diverse dining options, from charming greasy spoon diners to impressive farm-to-table restaurants. We appreciated the peaceful river setting and convenient access to attractions. Would definitely stay here again and recommend to anyone visiting the Cooperstown area!

This is our third visit to the lake house and we absolutely love it. Love everything about it. As well as the owners of course. Super responsive and personable. The standard has always be very high each time. Dependable. Highly recommended. We can't wait to go back! Thank you so much, Elise

This was the perfect setup and location for our trip to Cooperstown Dreamspark. We shared the house with another family and it was super comfortable and a perfect distance from the park to easily drive back and forth. It was also very close to downtown Cooperstown. I highly recommend this house!

We loved our stay at Robert's Bohemian Cabin! It has lots of charm, was very comfortable, and very clean. A very private location with great views. Fully equipped. Location was convenient to our visit to SUNY Oneonta. Robert was very quick to respond to our inquiries. We plan to return in the future.

Awesome place. It's exactly as advertised, a lot of space to hang out and pretty secluded. The fire pit is awesome, TV worked well, kitchen full outfitted and everything clean. Thanks!

A diamond in the rough! We came here for our first wedding anniversary and it was the perfect place to relax, connect, and make memories. Everything about the property is pristine. The amenities like the sauna, hot tub, and fire pit are easy to use and work perfectly. The setting is secluded and private. The property and interior were clearly designed with thought, care, and great taste. The place has everything you need for a comfortable stay. We bought food at the local market and cooked and ate in the yard. While we didn’t find a ton of local restaurants or places to go in the surrounding area, we loved Butterfield Cafe and the Frog Pond farm market. Pete and Sandy were responsive and easy to communicate with. We hope to return someday.

Our stay was wonderful and for the first time the pictures matched the descriptions and the views were gorgeous. Nice and quiet area I would recommend to anyone that wants getaway. Scott was an awesome host, very proactive and great communicator.

I had a wonderful time at Justine's beautiful countryside, modern farmhouse. Gorgeous setting up high in the mountain range with an incredible view of the mountainside. Open lot with lot's of space. Absolutely gorgeous open first floor concept with incredible deck. Super comfortable and great kitchen set up with all you need to cook. House is well stocked with necessities. Upstairs is lovely and both bedrooms are super comfortable with room darkening shades and nice ceiling fans. I could sit for hours and look at the mountains. Like you are in your own heaven. Justine lives in a private cabin on the property and comes and goes which I really liked as she was super accessible and not in your way at all. She was so gracious and I had a great time. 5 star property. You will not be disappointed. Great hiking destinations and lakes nearby and 3 cute restaurants with in a 10 to 15 minute drive. You are in the country and it is amazing. Thank you Justine! Beautiful art!

The location was very convenient to the fields and had plenty of room. We loved the decor and the surrounding area, will definitely book here again.

We had a wonderful stay at Robert’s property while celebrating our child’s 2nd birthday. The home was beautiful, spacious, and impeccably maintained—exactly what we were hoping for. Even though the weather was a bit rainy at times, we were lucky to get some clear moments to enjoy the lovely surroundings, and the space was cozy enough to enjoy indoors as well. We invited a few friends over to celebrate, and everyone had a fantastic time. The home was perfect for hosting a small gathering and created a warm and welcoming atmosphere for our special occasion. Robert was an outstanding host—very responsive and thorough in making sure we had all the information we needed about the property. He clearly puts a lot of care into both the home and his guests’ experience. We stayed for two nights and truly didn’t want to leave. It was a memorable trip for our family, and we’re so grateful for the experience. Thank you again, Robert—we’d love to return in the future!

We LOVED this house. All of the common areas were actually larger than expected. There was ample space in both the front room and family room with multiple couches and two TVs. The laundry room was clean and there was leftover soap. The kitchen was well stocked with leftover items from previous renters which helped (condiments, spices, soap, etc). There were games in the dining room and plenty of blankets/pillows. We did bring our own fans because the house did not have any. The downstairs bathroom didn't have an overhead fan and the windows didn't open so most activities had to happen upstairs or the room wouldn't clear out but it was not a dealbreaker. The house was literally 5 minutes from All Star Village which was sooooo convenient considering we were there multiple times a day all week. Dunkin Donuts and Dairy Queen were walkable as were other local places to eat. We will be back in 3 years for our younger son! Very grateful to have found such a special place. Highly recommend.

Had a great stay. Cozy and sweet cabin, designed well and comfortable to stay in. Also loved the little creek behind it.