
Vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6
*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House
ValueFamilyHiking

Private waterfront home on Goodyear Lake!
Camp Havon - is a wonderful home on picturesque Goodyear Lake! The private waterfront is a rare find being that it is flat and grassy right by the water! That is not often the case with waterfront homes. Enjoy all the water fun swimming, fishing and or boating. You can bring your own boat or rent a kayak from the shop on the lake. When you're not indulging in water activates you can enjoy the the wonderful views of Goodyear Lake from the firepit on the patio by the house or one of the many level
LocationFamilyHospitality

The Goodyear LakeShore Lodge
Welcome to the Goodyear Lakeshore Lodge.This quaint country style retreat is located in the heart of the Catskills playground. Just steps away from the majestic Goodyear Lake. Only 10 minutes drive to Cooperstown. A picturesque village with a sense of nostalgia through its "Norman Rockwell" charm. Visit the famous Baseball Hall of Fame. Take a stroll on the romantic streets sipping an old style cream soda . End the day around the campfire back at the Lakeshore Lodge. Enjoy your memorable stay!
LocationFamilyHospitality

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands
Summer baseball renters please note: availability is Dreams Park tournament schedule ONLY -- not All Star! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! Built in the 18th century, it now boasts an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake 5 mins away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!
FamilyLocationHiking

Cooper Creek
Cooper Creek is a valuable piece of central New York history that was built in the late 1700s. This homestead once included an outhouse, a spring house, a Cooper shed, and a proud hand hewn timber barn. Robby and Eileen Robbins purchased the property in 1984-finding it in desperate need of plumbing, electricity, as well as emergent repairs in order to preserve as much history as possible. The 18th century beams,& the wooden pegs used instead of nails helps it maintain its unique identity.
LocationFamilyOutdoor spaces

The Mill House: An Enchanting Stream-Side Retreat
Nestled in the heart of the Catskills and just a 2.5-hour drive from NYC, escape to the perfect fall retreat where you can reconnect with nature and enjoy the serene beauty of the season. This historic gem underwent a recent restoration, marrying its saw mill heritage with contemporary luxuries, including a Nest thermostat, smart speakers, keyless entry, and fast wifi. Original exposed post and beam construction and Scandinavian-inspired design make for a unique and cozy atmosphere.
LocationFamilyWalkability

Luxury Cooperstown Area Lake Home with Amenities!!
2027 Summer Bookings open 10/1, we only accept 6 night stays aligned with “Cooperstown Dreams Park” schedule, see their site for schedule. “Allstar Village” schedule does not align with us. The 2027 season is 5/30-8/22/26. Beautiful 3 bedroom on Canadarago Lake, 15 min. drive to Cooperstown. We now have 6 kayaks, a pedal boat, & a paddle board! Enjoy coffee viewing the peacefulness of the lake, if mornings aren’t for you, It is as beautiful at sunset with wine.
LocationValueKitchen

At Home Base North
Enjoy the Cooperstown experience while having all the comforts of home. The Baseball Hall of Fame (6 miles), Brewery Ommegang (5.4 miles), and The Cooperstown Dreams Park (0.5 miles) are all conveniently located. Scenic views from the large-covered deck of the rolling hills set on 20 acres. Check out all of the amenities including high speed internet, central air, and a BBQ grill. View our other “Home Base” listings here on Airbnb, all in the vicinity of one another.
FamilyLocationHeating

Catskills Over Water Bungalow on Lake Albanese!
Catskills Cabin Rentals has designed and built one of the most unique places in the Catskills. Located on Lake Albanese is New York's first Over Water Bungalow featuring 2 bedrooms 1.5 bathrooms. The living room has a wood burning fireplace made with handcrafted stone. In front of the fireplace the home has a glass floor to see fish, turtles, frogs, and more! The home is located on 200 acres with only 4 other log cabins.
ValueFamilyAir conditioning

Lakefront, family friendly home -Baseball campers!
- Lake/waterfront home on Goodyear Lake. - Conveniently located close to local baseball camps, SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick college - Large lake view patio and yard for games or campfires and lakeside deck and dock. - Enjoy swimming, excellent fishing, and watersports. Row boat on site for guests. - Updated spacious home, including a fireplace and air conditioning. - Away from it all, but close to all amenities!
FamilyLocationGetting around

Creekside of the Moon A-frame Cabin
Creekside of the moon A-frame glamp. Float, fish and play in the Catskills. Glamp on the Charlotte Creek in a newly built modern tiny a-frame. Sleep under the full moon. A giant moon light hangs over the bed(s) with a stunning reflection in the window at night over the creekview. Perfect for a romantic getaway, fishing trip, or glamping spot in the Catskills. Close to Cooperstown, NY IG @aframe_moon
ValueFamilyHeating

"Far from the Madding Crowd" Cozy Cabin Retreat
Cabin Clack is a quiet, stream-side retreat bordering 1000 acres of wild trails in NY State Forest. The cabin is a historic hunting cabin from circa 1935. The cabin is good for a couple, solo adventurers, or families (with kids). We welcome pets, and they will love exploring the secluded forest and the freedom of our virtually traffic-free dead-end road. There is a spring fed pond you can swim in.
ValueLocationDecor
Popular amenities for Goodyear Lake vacation rentals
Lake side house rentals in Goodyear Lake

Secluded Lakefront Art Retreat with Stunning Views
FamilyValueOutdoor spaces

The Catskill Craftman Cabin
LocationValueQuiet

Lakefront chalet w. hot tub, game room, & kayaks
ValueFamilyIndoor spaces

Catskills Luxury Cabin
ValueLocationBathroom

Beautiful Farmhouse & Majestic Waterfall
LocationFamilyParking

Beautiful Big Lake Front home near Cooperstown
FamilyLocationLayout

Restored Farmhouse & Private Lake on 100+ Acres
LocationFamilyWalkability

Belleayre GrandHouse 6 BRs w/Hot tub/Sauna/Game RM
LocationValueGrill
Goodyear Lake house rentals

Best Bet! 10 mins to Baseball Hall of Fame!
ValueLocationCheckout

Oaks Creek Guest Cottage
FamilyLocationCheck-in

Catskills Mountaintop House w/ HOT TUB and VIEWS!
LocationFamilyTV

Main Street in the Mountains. See sights & scenery
LocationValueWalkability

Close to CooperstownPool Home with Valley View!
LocationFamilyCheckout

Waterfront Cooperstown Rt 28 Discounted OffSeason
FamilyLocationHospitality

Eagle River
FamilyLocationParks

Diamond on 7
LocationFamilyLayout
Other great vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Tall Pines is a 4 bedroom cottage with lake access
FamilyLocationGetting around

Stay Golden
FamilyLocationCleanliness

Hemlock Hideaway – Luxury Cabin - Relax & Getaway
FamilyValueIndoor spaces

Cozy one bedroom cottage 19 miles from Cooperstown
FamilyValueQuiet

1 mile to ASV, newly renovated with EV Charger
LocationFamilyDecor

Kennedy's Cottage
FamilyValueSleep quality

Cooperstown/ Oneonta Cottage #3- Old World Village
LocationFamilyAccuracy

Riverview - Grill, Private Dock, Lake Access!
LocationFamilyAccuracy
Destinations to explore
- New York Vacation rentals
- Montreal Vacation rentals
- Philadelphia Vacation rentals
- Washington Vacation rentals
- Boston Vacation rentals
- Ocean City Vacation rentals
- Pittsburgh Vacation rentals
- Niagara Falls Vacation rentals
- Jersey City Vacation rentals
- Portland Vacation rentals
- Mississauga Vacation rentals
- Newark Vacation rentals





