Vacation rentals with a fireplace in New Buffalo

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Quick stats about vacation rentals with a fireplace in New Buffalo

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 90 vacation rentals in New Buffalo

  • Nightly prices starting at

    New Buffalo vacation rentals start at G$35,393 GYD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 4,610 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly vacation rentals

    80 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities

  • Pet-friendly vacation rentals

    Find 40 rentals that welcome pets

  • Vacation rentals with a pool

    40 properties feature pools

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    40 properties have a dedicated workspace

  • Wi-Fi availability

    90 of New Buffalo vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across New Buffalo rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    New Buffalo stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

Top-rated fireplace rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The open main living area features a stone fireplace underneath a wooden mantel. A circular dining table is set near large windows, while a plush sectional sofa and unique coffee table enhance the cozy atmosphere. Natural light floods the space, accentuating earthy tones.
Cabin in Michiana
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 280 reviews

Romantic Getaway in the Dunes for a Couple—Hüüsli

Cozy, charming, romantic and modern. Huusli is the perfect place for a couple to getaway, not too big, not too small. Soaring ceiling with wood burning fireplace greets you in the main living area with an updated kitchen, remodeled bathroom and two adorable bedrooms. Bonus is the four-season room where you can have all your meals or enjoy your morning coffee surrounded by nature, but without the fear of bugs. Make new memories, celebrate an anniversary or just relax in this magical place.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area showcases a light-colored sectional sofa adorned with plush pillows. Large windows allow natural light to fill the room, revealing wooden flooring and eye-catching artwork on the walls. A dining table is visible in the background, complemented by a minimalist plant.
Home in Michigan City
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 339 reviews

House of Zen: Peaceful Modern Cabin on Tryon Farm

The House of Zen is an architect designed home situated in the woods, part of a sustainable farm community on 170 acres. Only an hour drive from Chicago, and close to Indiana Dunes National Park, it is the ultimate escape. The perfect getaway for couples, creatives and nature lovers who want some peace, quiet and space. Explore the farm trails & enjoy the wildlife and soothing sounds. Note: We have a 3 night minimum stay during summer, but open up 2 night stays 1-2 weeks before if possible.

Top guest favorite
The cabin's exterior is framed by colorful autumn foliage, with vibrant red leaves and dappled sunlight filtering through the surrounding trees. Stone steps lead to the entrance, enhancing the rustic charm of the well-maintained landscape.
Cabin in Michiana
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 246 reviews

Luxury Cabin Getaway •2 min to Beach• 1hr Chicago

Luxury meets nature: forest cabin steps from the beach, 1 hour from Chicago. Book your escape to our designer log cabin on Lake Michigan just steps from the beach and nestled in a peaceful forest, it’s the perfect retreat. Built in 1932, our charming cabin sleeps 8 in 4 bedrooms. Enjoy 2 living areas, a stone fireplace, fire pit, games, puzzles & books. Featured in Country Living and the NYT, it’s perfect for families, friends, or retreats. Book now and create lasting memories in Michiana.

Guest favorite
A spacious backyard is enclosed by wooden fencing, featuring a green lawn, a sandbox for children, and a colorful outdoor mural on the shed. A seating area with patio furniture is visible, complemented by landscaped flower beds. The sky is bright with scattered clouds.
Home in New Buffalo
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 210 reviews

In-town Lovely Home! Steps to Starbucks & Beach!

Spacious 3 bed/1.5 bath home in-town! Walk to beach, Starbucks, Stray Dog, grocery! Enjoy the fully fenced yard playing outdoor games from the shed, and a sand box for the kids! Grill and enjoy fire pit after a day of wineries, shopping in the local shops, galleries, antiquing, and casino. Outdoor live music starts Memorial Weekend on weekends to Fall until around 2 am at Casey's behind property as well as New Year's. Noise machines in each bedroom. Pet fee $150, 2 dogs MAX. Wp#acnbwmech22

Top guest favorite
A cabin exterior is presented, featuring a screened-in porch that offers comfortable seating. The structure, painted in a muted green tone, is surrounded by trees and foliage. A set of steps leads to the porch, creating easy access to the welcoming retreat.
Cabin in Union Pier
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Walk 2 Lake/Shops | Hot Tub | King Bed | Fireplace

Tucked away sophisticated cabin in the heart of Downtown Union Pier. Killer location that's just steps away from dining and drinks: Black Current Bakery, Neon Moon Gelato, Union Pier Market, and Union Pier Social. Townline Beach is a 10 minute walk, and the cabin is right off the bike path. Seeds Brewery is just down the road and local Wineries are 1 mile away. Back home enjoy a relaxing hot tub (available year round), wood burning fire place, spacious screened in porch & outdoor fire pit.

Guest favorite
The modern tree-house structure is illuminated by warm lighting, showcasing large windows that reflect the surrounding trees. A screened porch with seating is visible, extending from the main building, creating a connection with nature.
Home in Michigan City
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 328 reviews

TRYON FARM MID-MODERN SPA IN THE WOODS

Come, enjoy our Tryon Farm modern spa. A Sustainable luxurious open concept tree-house in the woods. Minutes from the beach with an outdoor sauna, Hottub, shower, and Mr. Steam. Perfect for two or a family/group adventure. A true destination with Yoga studio, Mirror by LuLu lemon and wellness elements. The house is a perfect balance of art and nature and luxury and spiritual. Treat yourself to a farm to table, hand made, locally sourced chef services for an extra special experience.

Top guest favorite
A bright living area features a comfortable gray sofa adorned with decorative pillows, paired with a light brown armchair. Large windows provide views of lush greenery, while a striped rug anchors the space. A coffee table with a bowl sits at the center, enhancing the cozy atmosphere.
Home in Sawyer
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

The treehouse at Warren Dunes

Looking for the perfect Harbor Country getaway? We've got you covered! Just 90 miles from Chicago and adjacent to Warren Dunes State Park, this beautifully remodeled home hidden in the trees is the perfect escape. With accommodations up to 6 on four levels of living space, you'll enjoy an indoor/outdoor living experience like no other. Conveniently just 200 yards from the beach with walking path access at the end of the street and easy access to all the activities this area has to offer.

Top guest favorite
A modern house is situated amidst lush greenery. A wooden walkway leads to the entrance, framed by trees and underbrush. Large windows reflect natural light, blending the structure harmoniously with its surroundings while offering a glimpse of the cozy interior.
Cabin in Michigan City
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 303 reviews

The Little House at Tryon Farm

The little house is located within a 170-acre modern farm community filled with open meadows, woods and dunes. Minutes to beach, 1 hour to Chicago. Relax and enjoy the property or head out to explore the lakeshore, wineries, and great area restaurants! Two bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a fully appointed kitchen, living area w/fireplace, and a large screened in porch. Large windows flood the house with natural light and will make you feel like you're living in the treetops. A perfect getaway!

Guest favorite
The spacious screened-in porch features a mix of seating options including a wicker chair and multiple cushioned chairs arranged around a central gas fire pit. Natural light filters through the screens, revealing a serene outdoor view and wooden flooring that enhances the inviting space.
Townhouse in New Buffalo
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews

PumpHouse- Walk Everywhere! Private porch firepit!

Escape to Prime Downtown New Buffalo – Just 70 Miles from Chicago! Nestled one street off the main strip with easy parking. Walk to beaches, marina, Amtrak. Chill on private screened porch with gas fire pit. Rent bikes, boats, kayaks. Grab bites at Stray Dog, Ghost Isle Brewery, Oink's ice cream and Casey’s. Shop boutiques, sip local wines, catch harbor sunsets! Stroll Galien River Park's boardwalk or hit Four Winds Casino. Tee off at Whittaker Woods golf, minutes away.

Guest favorite
Home in New Buffalo
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

New buffalo Farmstead main home pool hot tub

5 bedroom 2 bath 2200 sq ft modern farmstead , 2 minutes to new buffalo and beach and all its offerings , 18x36 new heated shared pool open 5/20 to 10/ 20 and hot tub open year round maintained at 104 f . Property on 3 acres with plenty of room for kids to play , 26 apple trees and woods , ride host bikes to new buffalo .. Best of both worlds in country , close to town .There’s 1 other home on 3 acre property, this home and 1 guest home ( rented separately) .

Superhost
The cabin is nestled among lush trees, with soft outdoor lighting illuminating the entrance. Large windows reveal a welcoming interior glow, while a small outdoor seating area is visible nearby, blending seamlessly into the surrounding natural environment.
Cabin in Union Pier
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 382 reviews

McComb's Cabin, Union Pier, MI

Giant trees welcome you down the drive back to the cabin in the woods. The cabin, along with my house and a small cottage reside on the 2 1/2 acre property. A contemporary cabin of steel and pine with vaulted ceiling and sky lights. Open living space, inviting queen size bed, luxury rain shower, full kitchen but no stove. A wood burning fireplace- fall through end of March and outside fire pit. Public beach a 5 minute drive away. Kids accepted.

Guest favorite
The kitchen showcases a stainless steel stove and microwave, complemented by open shelving. A dining area with six metal chairs is positioned near the entrance to the living room, which features a sofa and a wall-mounted television.
Home in New Buffalo
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 446 reviews

Sq Toe's Last Resort:Pet-Friendly*Fenced* GameRoom

Nestled in the heart of New Buffalo, this modest two-bedroom home offers a quiet retreat. Steps from Whittaker St's boutiques and eateries, and the marina and beach just a gentle stroll away. It's a space of simple comforts: a queen bed, cozy bunk beds, and a convenient sofa bed. The fenced yard, with its patio, bar, fire pit and grill, is perfect for relaxed gatherings. The thoughtfully updated garage game room provides an added touch of leisure.

Popular amenities for New Buffalo fireplace rentals

When is the best time to visit New Buffalo?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Avg. priceG$46,843 GYDG$49,550 GYDG$48,717 GYDG$57,461 GYDG$65,164 GYDG$89,939 GYDG$109,925 GYDG$110,758 GYDG$72,243 GYDG$72,659 GYDG$56,212 GYDG$53,089 GYD
Avg. temp-4°C-3°C3°C9°C15°C20°C22°C22°C18°C11°C4°C-1°C