Beach house vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique beach houses on Airbnb

Top-rated beach house rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these beach houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

A clear view of Lake Michigan is presented from a wooden deck. Sandy pathways lead down to the beach, framed by lush greenery. The tranquil blue waters stretch toward the horizon under a bright blue sky.

Home in Michigan City

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Lifetime Memories-Big Beachfront House 8 BR 5BA

Lakefront 8Br 5Bath (Sleeps 24). Unobstructed views of Lake Michigan & steps to beach. Firepit, WIFI, Big Weber Gas grill, fireplace, etc. Lower level (walk-out) redone with LR, 3BR, new Bath and laundry. 1st floor open plan - new kitchen, bath, and wood floors! 2nd & 3rd floors brand new - 2nd floor with 4 BR & 2 Ba - 2 BR w/doors 2 deck facing lake! Spiral stair to 3rd floor loft/Br w/6 twins, Full Bath & deck. Beach is virtually private at this, the far end of Michigan City's public beach.

FamilyValueWalkability

Guest favorite

A modern home is situated on a sandy lot beside a small private lake. Large windows reflect the surrounding greenery, while a sloped roof adds to the architectural design. The outdoor seating area is visible, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Home in Stevensville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

Bright & Modern Home: Heated Pool Open 5/20-10/4

The modern architecture and bright and airy design of the home provides a relaxing, inviting and luxurious space for guests. The home: -is set on an a sandy lot, facing a small private lake -has 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a den and a loft -has an 8-person hot tub and private pool -is equipped with top of the line kitchenwares -includes outdoor amenities such as kayak, canoe, fire pit, grill, yard games (Jenga and corn hole), etc. -allows pets but must be included in the booking and pay a pet fee

ValueFamilyGetting around

Top guest favorite

The rear exterior of the home is showcased, featuring a spacious deck illuminated by string lights. A private hot tub is positioned nearby, and a dining area with a long wooden table is visible. Lush greenery surrounds the space, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Michigan City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Beachfront Hot Tub All Year | Outdoor Grill | Wave

Beachfront Home! Welcome to Waves on Lake Michigan, your ultimate beachfront retreat—just steps from the sand and surf! This beautifully updated home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and lakeside charm for your next getaway. Step outside to soak in the private hot tub under the stars, relax on the spacious deck with a drink in hand, or enjoy a cookout in the backyard designed for fun and connection. Whether you're lounging by the water, grilling with friends, or falling asleep to the

LocationFamilyBeach

Superhost

Home in Michigan City

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Aqua Breeze/Lakefront, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, 3 Decks

Experience the best of Lake Michigan from this 4BR, 4.5BA home with 3 private en-suite bedrooms and an open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area. Enjoy easy beach access via a sandy path to Lake Michigan, plus 3 outdoor decks, an upper deck with dining and gas grill, private hot tub, and fire pit. Minutes from the Indiana Dunes, National Park, Washington Park, Zoo, Lighthouse Premium Outlets, wineries, breweries, shopping, and local dining. Perfect for family vacations and group getaways.

LocationBeachView

Top guest favorite

A charming lakeside house is set against a backdrop of lush greenery, featuring large windows that invite natural light. A private dock extends into the water, accompanied by four kayaks neatly arranged beside it. Lounge chairs are positioned around a fire pit on the lawn.

Home in Dowagiac

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Magician Lakehouse Escape

This Magical Lakeside Escape offers a perfect blend of luxury and comfort, making it an ideal destination for relaxation. Take a stroll on the private dock, swim in the sandy bottom waters, or kayak the shoreline. The spacious living area offers panoramic views, with breath taking sunsets. Enjoy cozy evenings by an indoor or outdoor fire. Spend the day on a (rentable) pontoon. Experience the magic of lakeside living at the newly updated Magician Lakehouse and create unforgettable memories.

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

Guest favorite

An aerial view captures a cluster of chalets arranged around a spacious parking lot near the water's edge. The surrounding landscape features lush greenery and tranquil blue waters, with various outdoor amenities visible, including pools and recreational areas.

Home in Stevensville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Lake Michigan Beach Cottage + Pool + Games

Escape to our newly remodeled chalet that is steps away from Lake Michigan. With 6 beds, it's the perfect getaway for couples, families, or small groups. Enjoy access to a private and public beach, pools, sports courts, fishing ponds, and playgrounds. Located next to Lincoln Township Park and near Grand Mere State Park plus nearby breweries, wineries, and distilleries. Relax, explore, and create unforgettable memories at this cozy lakeside retreat. Your perfect vacations awaits!

FamilyLocationBathroom

Guest favorite

Two yellow adirondack chairs are positioned on a well-maintained green lawn, overlooking the expansive view of Lake Michigan. Bare trees line the area, and the clear blue sky reflects on the water's surface.

Home in Lakeside

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Enjoy your own private beach on Lake Michigan

Freshly renovated Lake Michigan home with beautiful private beach. Living room, sun room and dining area comfortably fits group. Bright, new kitchen with huge island, pro range, dishwasher. Four newly appointed bedrooms sleep 10 comfortably. Two fully renovated bathrooms, towel warmer. Beachside gear hut has chairs, umbrellas, more. Walk to Whistle Stop and Roadhouse. 10 min to New Buffalo, Sawyer, Three Oaks. Year-round amenities: fireplace, outdoor fire pit, Jacuzzi hot tub.

LocationValueIndoor spaces

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story red house is showcased, featuring a welcoming porch with railings. Large windows allow natural light to fill the home, and a paved pathway leads up to the entrance. Surrounding trees enhance the setting's natural charm.

Home in Michigan City

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

Beachwalk Resort Stunning 4-Bed + Loft - Sleeps 18

NOTE: I CAN OFFER EARLY CHECK-IN/LATE CHECK-OUT OFF SEASON SUBJECT TO AVAILABILITY. Stunning newer home featuring beautiful open floor plan with amenities for the whole family. Exceptional property in the award winning Beachwalk Resort. When not at the beach, you can comfortably sit back and enjoy a cup of tea in the screened in porch or a glass of wine around the firepit while the kids compete in a friendly game of air hockey. Come on in and let your vacation dreams come true.

LocationFamilyGetting around

Guest favorite

A round, dark outdoor table is surrounded by two cushioned swivel chairs with blue and white patterns. The scenic view of Lake Michigan, with gentle waves and a sandy beach, is visible in the background, framed by lush greenery on either side.

Home in Union Pier

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Lakefront 4BR w/private beach & panoramic views

Bring along the family or come with a group of friends for a memorable stay on Lake Michigan at 'Shangri La' 4-bed, 3-bath, single level home in Union Pier! Enjoy the private beach just steps away, stunning panoramic views of Lake Michigan, the big yard overlooking the lake, the look-out patio on the bluff, the roof deck for magnificent views and sunsets! Our home is spacious and fully equipped with everything you need for your perfect getaway!

ValueLocationGrill

Superhost

Home in Bridgman

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Quaint Dunewood Cabin with Private Beach Access

This is a fabulous opportunity to get away to a secluded beach house just an hour and a half from downtown Chicago. The house is less than 500 yards from a semi-private beach and has a lovely screened-in porch- that overlooks a pristine dune forest. Going to the beach is the most popular activity, but fruit picking, biking, hiking, golf, tennis, and go-carting are also available nearby. The house sleeps 8-10 people, in a quaint retro setting.

ValueFamilyOutdoor spaces

Guest favorite

The exterior of a blue lake house is shown, surrounded by lush greenery. Seating is provided in the foreground with several blue adirondack chairs arranged around a small stone circle. Large windows invite natural light into the spacious interior.

Home in Paw Paw

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Eagle’s Nest

Relax with the whole family at this beautiful all sport lake house. Enjoy a boat ride, kayak, paddle board, bon fire, or cozy up in the great room for a movie, while the kids swing away on the indoor swings! After 10 guests there is a 50$ per person fee over the age of 2 yrs. Pontoon rental available No pets 3 night minimum June, July, August , 2026 All NEW!!!! AIR CONDITIONING in whole house!!!!

LocationFamilyOutdoor spaces

Guest favorite

A wooden deck is shown with a table and four chairs, each adorned with floral cushions. Lush green trees provide natural shade, and a view of Lake Michigan is visible in the distance, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Home in Lakeside

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Lakeview Bluff

On a gentle bluff overlooking Lake Michigan with 125' of private beach. Spacious deck with magnificent views of the setting sun. Enjoy million dollar views of Lake Michigan and your own private beach at this classic family property. Relax on the spacious deck with magnificent views of the setting sun. Play all day with access to a beach house stocked with beach toys, paddleboard, and chairs.

LocationFamilyBathroom