Pet-friendly vacation rentals in New Buffalo

We had a great stay! The house was perfect. It was nice and clean with a great rooftop deck and screened in porch. The location could not have been better, walking distance to everything in town. Everything was easy as far as check in and check out with a book explaining everything in the house. Mark was great at responding to questions. I would highly recommend staying here.

This is the second year I rented this place for my birthday weekend away with friends. The house has so many accommodations for sleeping and different sitting areas. However, the main event is the kitchen. My friends and I love to cook and that's why we came back a second year in a row. The kitchen is unbelievably well-stocked with anything you might need to cook. There are multiple sinks so someone can be cooking while someone else cleans. The layout is perfect for people to hang out with whoever is cooking. There are two ovens. It is a dream. The house feels comfortable and lived-in, and it feels like there has been a lot of thought and intention focused on the user-experience. Cannot say enough nice stuff about this house, cannot recommend enough. Will be coming back for my 29 birthday.

Such a lovely place to relax and unwind with family! They truly had all the amenities you could think of, which is so wonderful. We enjoyed Three Oaks which is 10 mins away and offers great restaurants and shops.

Donna’s home was amazing!! We felt so safe, comfortable, and relaxed during our trip. I highly, highly recommend it for your girls trip!!

Lovely home, many well thought out perks like fans in upstairs rooms and beach toys for kids! Info said it was an easy short walk to beach so I spent a whole lot more than I usually would. With children it would not be pleasant and is really not a short walk (and is on a semi busy road) & beach is down a whole lot of steps. BUT there are parking spaces so it was fine. Within the house, the steps are fairly steep at parts & there are 2?big ones going into house &!these were hard for my 70 year old mom w knee issues. So if person reading reviews is one of those people, this might not be THE place. That being said, it is very short walk to community pool & host is very responsive & house is beautiful! My mom mostly stayed within first floor including an awesome bed/bath on ground floor. There are games (although I didn’t love the Ouija board 🫣😂) . This would be a great place for multiple family / friends to split cost ;) Its very beautiful & community pool & hot tub are great!

We loved this place!!! Amazing location-so close to downtown. Very clean house with beautiful lot on the corner. We enjoyed the large hottub as well. Missy was a great host!

Thank you Hannah, we had the perfect country stay!

Igor's Prairie Home was the perfect backdrop for my husband and adult children to take a break and reconnect as a family. The home is beautiful and so comfortable. We enjoyed the great hot tub and sitting around the fire pit. Oh and I don't want to forget to mention the tree house! How clever 🌞. Location is perfect for anything you'd like to do in the area because the house is located with easy access to Red Arrow highway. Either way you go there is plenty to see and do. Everyone wants to stay at Igor 's again and my son in law has already recommended to his parents. So I know we'll be back. 😎⛱️

Greg is an amazing host. Beautiful walkable area, full of nature. The pool and pool table provide hours of entertainment. Top notch Airbnb. Would definitely recommend.

This is our 3rd year in a row to come for an extended Labor Day weekend and bring our kids and/or grandkids. We love the setting. The pool is perfect for the younger kids and the adults appreciate the beauty of all the surroundings, including at poolside. If we could change anything at all we would add another bedroom as we can't quite get all of our extended family here at one time. That said, we would like to return for a 4th year at Labor Day weekend time next year. The combination of beauty, privacy, amenities, condition (always in great shape!), and proximity to lovely South Haven can hardly be beat!

We I had an amazing time at Home in Lakeside! The host was super friendly and helpful, making sure everything was perfect from the start. The place was really well-done, with nice decor and everything we needed. The pool area was perfect, and it was a great place to relax and have fun with the family or a big group of friends. The beach is just a short walk away, and the sunsets there are breathtaking. The location was perfect - we know the area well because we used to own a cottage in Union Pier, and this place is only a short drive away. We felt right at home and would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a memorable stay.

Things that are criminally underrated in the listing and reviews: The memory foam mattresses, the temperature controls in every room, and the flock of domestic ducks. That mattress cured my arthritis, eczema, and acne, and the ducks cured my depression. My friend and I were in town from across the state so that she could have surgery. We needed a place that was more quiet and private than a hotel, but still close enough to St. Joseph that we had easy access to food and medical care. Nina's place was exactly that. There is a bit of road noise, since it's directly on a semi-busy road, but the photos clearly show that, so we weren't surprised. Other than that, it was incredibly quiet, and had some lovely white noise from the pond and quiet duck quacks. Nina was always responsive via message, but her check in and check out instructions were so clear that we didn't need to communicate much. Would definitely stay here again if I'm ever in the area.

We had a wonderful time at Mary’s property. Top notch amenities, beautiful and private location, and a seamless experience communicating with Mary prior to our arrival. We would absolutely recommend this listing, and hope to return for future getaways!

Really enjoyed the cottage for our family of four. The place is walking distance to the beach and a local playground. We enjoyed staying in nature but being able to drive to New Buffalo for restaurants or other things. Highly recommend for a weekend getaway.

We met here with college friends and their families and had a wonderful time. There is a wide variety of books, games, and activities; we really didn’t need to bring our own! The hosts were very responsive and even drove out with trash bags when we messaged that we couldn’t find any. Highly recommend!

Cozy , warm log cabin ! Great spot for long weekend with 3 generations , children loved the heated pool and fun walk to the beach , great screened in porch !

Me and my pup stayed here for a quick peaceful weekend getaway and it was the best experience we could ever ask for! The place was super clean and just like described and the sunset at the private beach was so beautiful. Alyese was super friendly and helpful and was quick to respond if I ever had questions! I would 100% visit this cute place again with Bruno! 🥹

Donna is a wonderful host! The cottage was the perfect spot for a quick getaway—it had everything we needed for a relaxing stay. We especially loved the large, fully fenced-in yard for our dogs and the screened-in back porch, which was perfect for unwinding. The kitchen was beautiful and well-equipped, and the quiet neighborhood made for a peaceful retreat. Plus, it’s within walking distance to the shops and restaurants in Three Oaks, which was a big bonus. Be sure to check out Dreihart Wines and 6 Linden while you're in town, offering amazing German-style wines and a great selection of specialty groceries and imported foods. If I had to mention one downside to our stay, it would be that the beds felt a bit worn and not as comfortable as we’d hoped. That said, everything else about the stay more than made up for it, and I’m still giving Donna and her charming cottage a full 5 stars!

Had the absolute pleasure of taking my wife to Rudy + Deanna's Airbnb to celebrate our first anniversary. Both co-hosts were very responsive, very friendly, and shared a ton of useful local knowledge for us to make our weekend special! The Airbnb itself was gorgeous - pristine inside with all the amenities you could need. The four of us (two dogs, yes they are pet friendly) had a wonderful time and would absolutely recommend this place to others wishing to visit Michigan City! Thanks again!

The house is so great! Jess provided such impeccable details and was so helpful! We felt comfortable, safe and confident during our stay. This was our first ‘official’ vacation with our 2 year old, so we very much appreciated all of the toddler friendly amenities. We had such a great peace of mind throughout our stay. Everything is so clean and maintained well. We loved the board games! We had interesting weather during our stay (hot and cold!), so we enjoyed the open space of the house and all of the seating options both indoor and outdoor. Overall a great experience !

Lots of space to spread out! We loved the bonfire and the pool table! Kitchen very well equipped! Very walkable to great restaurants and the beach.

Incredible accommodations! We only stayed 2 nights and the weather was not agreeable. Unfortunately, we couldn't use the fire pit nor witness the amazing sunsets. We did enjoy the Michigan lake shore wine trail - you don't need sunshine for that adventure and visited the delicious bakery twice! We will definitely return!

We had a lovely adults only trip to Carla’s place. Walking distance to lots of restaurants and shops and a quick drive to the lake and dunes. The home is super cute and our group loved the double living rooms and large kitchen. Every bedroom was comfortable and well appointed. We look forward to returning soon!

My wife, our dog and I stayed at the farmhouse for a long weekend to relax away from the city. It was the perfect country escape- peaceful, tranquil and still a quick drive to everything we wanted to explore. We mostly went to New Buffalo for restaurants and kayaking, and to the Indiana Dunes for hiking. The farmhouse was tastefully decorated with upscale amenities (like the coffee maker we decided to purchase when we got home). Mornings were spent reading on the screened in porch, listening to the birds and watching the chickens outside. There’s plenty of seating if you have a larger group, with tables inside and outside for meals. Stefanie was a wonderful host, her guidebook has great recommendations of things to do in the area and she gave very helpful instructions for the house. We definitely hope to return sometime as it’s so close to Chicago! Perfect weekend trip.