Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Sister Bay

Very cozy with all the amenities and a beautiful view of the bay to go with. Would stay here again!

We had a fantastic stay! The place was beautiful, peaceful, well-maintained, and had everything we needed for a relaxing getaway. We especially loved the sauna and firepit, which made the experience even more special. Tiffany was incredibly responsive and helpful anytime we had a question. Highly recommend and would definitely stay again!

John and Tracy's home is beautiful. Exactly as described. We enjoyed every minute of our stay. There was plenty of room for our family to spread out and have private space when necessary. We grilled and made breakfast every morning, played lots of games, and enjoyed local restaurants for dinner. We also had music playing constantly through the beautiful speaker system. My son and I also enjoyed 3 games of chess! Loved the board. As it was our first family trip to Door County, we did not know what to expect. Thank you to John and Tracy for meeting our every need. It was an amazing weekend, and we ended at the Farm with our 1 year old granddaughter. Highly recommend both the Airbnb and the Farm!

Goathaus is the GOAT! My family enjoyed a stay here over a fall weekend with our close friends - being the offseason in Door County, we were looking to be leisurely and slow down a bit, and Goathaus was the perfect place to do just that. The house was super clean and beautifully done in a midcentury modern with a touch of cool sci-fi vibes, the surrounding property is gorgeous and serene with views of the lake, there were plenty of fun activities and games at the house for our 4 kids ages 5-8 to keep busy with, and with downtown Sister Bay just a short drive down the hill, good food and drink options were easily accessible. We appreciated the welcome package and book of "How to Stay" instructions/recommendations from our hosts, along with the delightfully witty and helpful labels placed around the house to proactively address any wonderings about how to work this or that. Goathaus has everything you could want for a peaceful Door County retreat!

Our stay at Alyssa's couldn't have been better! Her home was not only inviting and cozy but was also exceptionally clean and comfortable; everything was spotless! Our family of 6 had plenty of room and felt right at home. And, Alyssa was a wonderful host...very friendly, welcoming, and responsive. We'd definitely rebook with her the next time we are in the area.

Perfect stay! The house was clean, host was extremely responsive, and the location was central to everything in Door County. Would definitely recommend and would definitely stay again! Thank you!

We loved the waterfront location and had been trying to get a stay here for a while. The cottage was comfortable, cheery, and had a nice kitchen setup. It was in a great location, easily walkable to downtown for the farmer’s market or to the beach. The garden and outdoor living space was spectacular as well and we spent time reading and eating on the deck, along with visits from the resident dog Sara. Alisa is a personable hostess and this is a great place to stay. We love Sturgeon Bay and the accommodations made it a great weekend getaway.

We absolutely enjoyed our stay! This is a lovely spot! This has to be the most clean place we have ever stayed! It was not only clean but super comfy & cozy! Beautiful views of the trees from the porch as well! We loved our stay and hope to be back!

Had a great time at this cute studio apartment. Everything you need for a short vacation. Minutes away from great restaurants and close to scenic locations. The best part is the view from the studio and the pier/beachfront. Good recommendations from host! A must stay!

Kathleen was a terrific host who provided many touches to make our stay comfortable. Coffee, tea, movies, kitchenette all made our stay very pleasant. We especially like how close we were to our favorite Egg Harbor restaurants and shopping. Thank you for such a clean and thoughtfully appointed room for our getaway!

We loved the apartment. It was very cute and well maintained. Pet friendly, and very accommodating. There isn't a pizza cutter, but we have yet to stay at an Air BNB that has one. Lol! Overall, it was lovely and will stay again when we come back.

We loved it and are planning our next trip to go back. Great location, quiet and nice neighbors.

Logan’s place is a lovely comfortable house with all basic needs catered for a getaway to Door County & surrounding places. Everything was perfectly in order and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The collection of books for guests was amazing and people can read to their children as well. I give this place 5 stars

This was a great place to stay for my trip to Door County! The apartment was super clean and decorated so nicely. The apartment is located in a nice quite neighborhood and other guests on the property were quiet and lovely. I'd absolutely stay here again!!

It’s a great place to stay for a weekend trip to door county. Everything is a 15 minute drive. Great place to unwind after a long day, and quiet.

Perfect place for our girls weekend. Enjoyed the quiet, cozy atmosphere.

This home was in a great location with a beautiful view. we enjoyed our stay in Oconto while we were fishing. Great place to relax

The cabin itself was clean, quiet and an amazing place for nature lovers. The trail on the farm itself is peaceful, and the nearby Algoma beachfront and Kewaunee nature trail are beautiful as well with a nice variety of wildlife, birds and plants. Highly recommended and will definitely come back again when we are in the area.

We had a great time staying at the cabin. It is perfect for a lowkey getaway and the location can’t be beat. Hoping to come back again soon!

Such a cute cottage, perfectly clean, nice amenities and beautiful outdoor space.

Great cozy springtime stay. It was nice to use the wood burning stove and hang out in the large common area.

Amazing place -- the island and bay are beautiful, the cabin is cozy and has everything you need for a weekend (or more) of relaxation & fun. Hosts are friendly & responsive. We had a wonderful time, hope to return again in the future.

We had a wonderful time staying in the cabin by the bay/lake in Gills Rock. There is a beautiful hiking spot just minutes from the cabin and it was a nice quiet neighborhood to do my morning walks while I waited for my husband to get motivated. 4 State Parks we visited in the area with Newport being the closest (less than 10 minutes I think) and a "Dark Sky Park" (aka Star Viewing) Everything was simple from check in to check out. There is no TV in the main bedroom (I am one of those people) but it worked out and we couldn't have been happier with this AirBnB for our anniversary. What a beautiful area. We prefer off season travel as apposed to overcrowding and Door County in April is great if you are in to the that. We felt like we had places all to ourselves. Would recommend this place for year-round travel. Thank you Gregg and Family for letting us stay in your cozy piece of history. Docs Hideaway in Gills Rock is awesome!

Great stay at Plum Bottom— peaceful, clean & comfortable! Awesome host with tons of Door County recommendations:)