Skip to content

Sister Bay cottage rentals

Book unique cottages, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Sister Bay

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Entire cottage · Sister Bay
Beechwood Cottage - Secluded A-Frame in Sister Bay
Completely escape from your every day life at the cottage with only a short 5 minute drive to everything Sister Bay has to offer. Our cottage is located on a 1.6 acre private wooded lot surrounded by beechwood trees. The cottage has a large open deck in the front and a spacious screened in porch in the back. The interior is decorated with a warm mid-century modern charm and is equipped with everything needed for a relaxing stay.
G$50,806 GYD per night
Entire cottage · Fish Creek
The Glass House on Birch Bluff
The Glass House on Birch Bluff is named in honor of Fredrica “Fritzie” Glass who had it built in 1969. Fritzie was an artist, teacher and author who led a rich life both in Milwaukee and Door County. We’ve tried to honor her love of nature and beauty in this space. The cottage sits atop a private bluff on three gorgeous acres in Fish Creek. It is a wonderful place to be alone and unwind, and yet a short distance to all that Northern Door County has to offer!
G$39,507 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire cottage · Sister Bay
Elegant Retreat in the Heart of Door County
A delightful retreat in perfect DC location. Ideal for a romantic weekend for a couple or perhaps for a family with two younger children. The retreat has two very large rooms, one featuring a sumptuous King bed, glass-topped table and four upholstered chairs, the other has a library/living-room feel - with several hundred books decoratively arranged. This has a Queen Sofabed, largeTV with Cable Netflix & Prime, and mini-fridge, microwave, coffee-maker & basic dinnerware. Pretty, private patio.
G$47,350 GYD per night
SUPERHOST

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

  • Cottages
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Stay near Sister Bay's top sights

Photo of Sister Bay Beach
Sister Bay Beach6 locals recommend
Photo of Al Johnson’s
Al Johnson’s34 locals recommend
Photo of Door County Creamery
Door County Creamery16 locals recommend
Photo of Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille Sister Bay
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille Sister Bay21 locals recommend
Photo of Husby's Food & Spirits
Husby's Food & Spirits16 locals recommend
Photo of Sister Bay Bowl
Sister Bay Bowl14 locals recommend

Other great vacation rentals in Sister Bay

Hotel room · Sister Bay
Swedeinn: New motel room #7 downtown Sister Bay
G$24,599 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire home · Sister Bay
Sister Bay Eclectic Cottage
G$98,303 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Hotel room · Sister Bay
Swedeinn: New motel room #15 downtown Sister Bay
G$28,773 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Barn · Sister Bay
Three Sister's Cottage Barn Retreat
G$60,436 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire cabin · Sister Bay
NEW! "SPRUCE RETREAT" - for a special vacation
G$55,780 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire home · Sister Bay
NEW! For a stylish, relaxed and fun vacation!
G$48,344 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire rental unit · Sister Bay
Updated Studio Apartment in Downtown Sister Bay!
G$35,272 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire condo · Sister Bay
NEW! Modern Sister Bay Condo < 1 Mile to Beach!
G$30,263 GYD per night
Hotel room · Sister Bay
Swedeinn: New motel room #14 downtown Sister Bay
G$28,773 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire condo · Ephriam
Remodeled Ephraim Condo with Fireplace #301
G$28,358 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
Entire rental unit · Sister Bay
The Yoga Pad - Open & Eclectic
G$29,071 GYD per night
Entire guesthouse · Fish Creek
Vintage Mod Cottage with fireplace & soaking tub!
G$49,195 GYD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Door County
  5. Sister Bay