House vacation rentals in Sister Bay

This place was wonderful!! Clean, beautifully decorated, private, and a great location. The beds were comfortable and the backyard a great place to hang out. Located between Sister Bay and Ellison Bay it was a perfect location. Just to note, both bathrooms are on the first floor, so if you have anyone in your group with mobility issues they would need to sleep in the bedroom downstairs. My friends and I had a wonderful time in Door County and Emily’s place made it even more enjoyable. I would definitely recommend this as a place to stay!!

Great place to stay with 4 couples to celebrate a 40th birthday! Super location, awesome amenities, clean, more than enough room.

Our family vacation was absolutely what we wanted on Washington Island, and especially at Essa's home! We wanted a quiet, relaxing place, and we definitely got that. We seriously felt like we were on a secluded island....didn't see one person until we drove to the other side of the island! If you are looking for a place to get away from the everyday hustle of life, Essa's place is where it's at. We got up in the mornings and had coffee and read on the 4 season's porch, sat on the beach, played games, watched movies, and had bonfires in the evening. The only bad thing....the week went to quickly!!!!

We had a wonderful time here! So clean and cozy! The hosts were so helpful and responded timely to questions! Would definitely come back!

The house was just as described with amazing amenities. Would stay again, loved how walkable it was to Sister Bay!

We loved the waterfront location and had been trying to get a stay here for a while. The cottage was comfortable, cheery, and had a nice kitchen setup. It was in a great location, easily walkable to downtown for the farmer’s market or to the beach. The garden and outdoor living space was spectacular as well and we spent time reading and eating on the deck, along with visits from the resident dog Sara. Alisa is a personable hostess and this is a great place to stay. We love Sturgeon Bay and the accommodations made it a great weekend getaway.

We enjoyed a long weekend with both sets of parents and our toddler and infant. Lots of thought and detail at the house that made it feel cozy and comfortable. Beautiful space! Having the kids room with kid stuff made things so nice and convenient. One thing we didn’t realize when booking was that one of the advertised bedrooms was in the open loft so to access the other bedrooms and upstairs bathroom you were walking though the bedroom space. Would book again.

Second time guests. Awesome home. We plan to be back next year.

Everything was great! Extremely clean! Loads to do, lots of fun! Amazing arcade games!

This is the cleanest Airbnb we have ever rented! Everything we needed was included. Beautiful location! The pool was and extra perk that we enjoyed. I would definitely rent this place again.

We had an incredible stay! Stacie was an absolutely wonderful host. So kind, and very responsive, flexible, and helpful with check-in. The property was perfect- private, with lots of amenities that made us feel right at home. We spent 3 nights here with 11 people and there was plenty of room for everyone. While it feels remote, the town of Sturgeon Bay is very close so you get the feeling of being out in the country with the convenience of being close to town. We also loved being able to say good morning to the adorable cows. All in all, we had a 100/10 stay and will hopefully return soon!

Newly renovated with thoughtful details. Comfortable beds. We had access to a small backyard which was great for our dog. The pool and surrounding area was clean and great for the kids (even though it was not quite warm enough outside). Great location!

Large home, perfect for a large group of friends or family. Great inside and multiple outdoor hangout areas. Perfectly located near coffee shops, bars, etc. No complaints - highly recommend!

Loved this place! The location is perfect. We started each day with coffee on the balcony and ended each day with wine on the balcony. Beautiful view of the harbor. We made a couple meals in the kitchen. Kitchen was fully stocked with all pots, pans, utensils and everything we needed. We got great sleep on mattresses. I want to buy the mattress for home. We walked into Egg Harbor every day for coffee and shopping. We went to 2 plays nearby, antique shopping, vintage pop ups and ate at great restaurants. I can’t say enough. We already booked for next year.

The condo was so beautiful and clean! Felt like I was at home and such a beautiful view in the back of the condo! Chris was very clear on the instructions the only thing that was missing was the unit number but not a big deal at all. The place was worth what we paid to stay there. I will for sure be staying here again next year I believe we have started a tradition!! Thank you Chris for such a beautiful place that made us feel at home!

excellent property and well worth what we paid. we enjoyed the decks and the views and the ability for walk access to many areas for breakfast and dinner. thanks

We loved our stay at Goathaus. The owners have gone above and beyond to ensure no space is neglected. The kitchen is extremely well stocked, with everything we needed to pull off a Thanksgiving dinner. A lot of modern updates to blend with the MCM themes inherent in an A-Frame. Cleanliness was a 10 out of 10. Unfortunately for us it was bitter cold with the wind, so we didn’t use the outdoor spaces, but it’s clear those spaces have not been overlooked. There’s even a view of the bay in the distance. Overall this is a beautiful home and the welcome gifts from the owners add to the good vibes. The main floor bedroom was perfect for my parents with no steps. We won’t have a lot of trips left where we can bring them along, so it’s great when the experience is all you can ask for, as it was for us at Goathaus!

We had an amazing stay at John and Tracy’s Airbnb! The view of the lake was absolutely spectacular—sunrises and sunsets were pure magic. The property was spotless and clearly well taken care of, with every little detail thought through. John and Tracy were fantastic hosts—welcoming, responsive, and full of great local tips. The highlight for our family was the massive game room, complete with a pool table and a huge variety of games. The kids had a blast, and honestly, so did we! It made for some unforgettable evenings. This place truly felt like a home away from home, and we’re already talking about when we can come back. Highly recommend!

Jill’s furniture was very comfortable. We enjoyed the outdoor furniture, fire ring and grill as well. The quality of the house and furnishings were great. Thank you Barb and Don

This was the perfect weekend in door county for our family group of 8. The location was great and centrally located in Door County. The place was beautiful and private. Each room had views of the surrounding nature and it was stunning. I would highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone!

We had such an enjoyable stay, and thank you for all your help. It's a great place and was just what we were looking for!

We had a wonderful stay at this adorable home! The house was spotless and felt very welcoming from the moment we walked in. One of our favorite parts was the backyard—it was private, peaceful, and such a great spot to relax. Everything was exactly as described, and you can tell the hosts really care about the guest experience. They were quick to respond and very helpful anytime we had a question. We’d definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a cozy, clean, and comfortable place to stay!

We had the best time on our visit to Sister Bay to celebrate our son’s first birthday, and the Scandia Retreat was the perfect place for us to stay for the weekend. We loved that it was walkable to the Main Street of Sister Bay! We felt right at home and so comfortable there, and Caley was so responsive and helpful with all her communication. We look forward to future stays back in Sister Bay!

We had a great stay at the Door County A-Frame! The house was immaculate, the furniture was very comfortable, and there were nice little touches like robes in the bathrooms. The neighborhood was very quiet, the house was right down the block from the lake, and only 5 minutes from the downtown area of Egg Harbor. Kevin was a really easy host to get in touch with and always had a quick response. If you're looking for a nice place to stay in Door County, this is the place to be!