Vacation rentals with outdoor seating in Shelter Island

Spent a long weekend here with one other couple and had an amazing first trip to the North Fork. Karine's home was beautiful and close to everything we wanted to see, and her recommendations were excellent and super helpful! I hope to come back soon and would absolutely recommend this place to others. Thank you Karine!

The house was very clean, well-decorated and cozy. The appliances were all updated and nice to use. We enjoyed staying in the area as it was half way between Sag Harbor and Southampton. Would stay again. Thanks for the hospitality!

It was a lovely stay. Great location. House felt like a home and had great vibes.

Isabel's home was in a beautiful location with easy accessibility to town and had all the necessities. Home is neat and clean and Isabel was responsive to our questions. Just a heads up.. although the post says air-conditioning it is not central air and we visited at a time when the window units were not in place as yet because the weather had been cool up to that point. We arrived on a warmer day so we could have used it and although there was a ceiling fan in the kitchen and upstairs bedroom there is none I. the downstairs bedroom. perhaps supplying a floor fan would be helpful

Truly such a cute place. Clean, spacious, well decorated. would stay again in a heartbeat

This was our second time renting Brian's place for a getaway and this stay was as excellent as the last. We love this house so much and Brian could not be a better host. His communication is stupendous; he was always immediately available to respond to any questions we had.

This is a beautiful farmhouse setting with gorgeous gardens, chickens, a nice screened in private porch, and a very friendly and adorable kitty. Jessica was a great host and provided some delicious homemade yogurt with milk and fruit, and plenty of coffee and tea. We brought our dog and he was comfortable there, we had plenty of space to walk him around.

My husband and I have been staying here for over 10 years, and it’s always fantastic. The house is immaculate, cozy, and consistently well cared for. Judie and Steven are super thoughtful + welcoming, and the atmosphere is perfect for a relaxing weekend. Truly our favorite getaway spot! Can’t wait for the next one!

We had a great weekend at Nicholas’s place. It was very peaceful in the woods, and we enjoyed using the record player and looking through the books spread throughout the studio. Nicholas was very responsive when I texted with questions and we used his provided recommendations to find breakfast and dinner. We’d definitely stay here again!

Claudias place might be my favorite air bnb I have stayed at. She has EVERYTHING you could ever think of! The kitchen is stocked with supplies and coffee, which I really appreciated. It was extremely clean and so cozy and felt like your own little space. It is comfortable, private, and a perfect get away from the city. Great for visiting Hamptons if you have a car! Also love her recommendations. I would come back here again and would recommend it without reserve!

I love this place. Perfect but what we were looking for. Walking distance to access beach. Overlooking the pier. Very clean and check in with.

We were a party of 5 women and we had a wonderful stay. The location was great, the unit was spotless and spacious, the kitchen had all the necessities, the towels and linens provided were very nice quality, and Amanda was a wonderful host and very responsive. We were able to check-in early which is always an added bonus. The only thing we would recommend being disclosed is that the train is right behind the location and came through pretty early in the morning and was quite loud. Also worth mentioning in the description would be the amount of stairs to get up to the living area of the home. This was not an issue for us, but could be difficult if you had large suitcases and heavy items to carry up. We would definitely recommend and would stay again.

Amazing place. Sally and Eric were great. Even gave me pointers on where to catch pickleball in the afternoons after a long beach day. 100% recommend.

It was such a pleasure spending a weekend in Claire’s studio. The studio is very clean and comfortable, and my wife and I particularly appreciated the kitchenette, which allowed us to prepare a dinner one night and make our own pour-over coffee in the morning. We also loved hearing the birds as we woke up in the morning. And the location is terrific—an easy walk to the Southhold town center and a quick drive to other surrounding attractions like Greenport, nearby beaches, and wineries. Highly recommend!

The place was spotless and exactly as described. Clean water, plenty of privacy, and a peaceful atmosphere made the stay very relaxing. It was easy to get to the beach by Uber, and Elyse even provided a beach umbrella, chairs, and towels which was a nice touch. Everything was well maintained and easy to navigate. I’ll definitely come back again!

Great venue. Hope to be back next year!

Mark's place was exactly what I was looking for to ring in the New Year in style, comfort and complete relaxation! I was able to start each day with a quiet cup of coffee and then head directly to the beach for a long morning walk (just a short drive away). Montauk Manor is an absolute hidden gem for a winter break and the indoor pool and hot tub are a rare find in the Hamptons. Check-in/out could not have been any easier and the Manor staff are wonderfully welcoming and friendly. There were still a good number of local shops open, including Left Hand Coffee. 100% recommend for all seasons and will eagerly book again!

We very much enjoyed our stay at the Cliffside for our wedding weekend! Alice was very flexible with us, which we appreciated because getting married is chaotic enough LOL. Would highly recommend staying here. The unit was spotless and had a wonderful view. We could not have asked for a better stay!

Great stay for a quick weekend getaway! Highly recommend as you are right by the beach, Montauk's downtown, and have access to a pool area.

My husband and I had a great stay at Doug’s condo! The unit is in a great location with beautiful views. Parking was super convenient and Doug makes check in a breeze. We enjoyed staying bay side and visited the restaurants nearby which are walking distance! We would definitely return and stay here again.

Great retreat for a long weekend. Enough space for family of four. Easy access to everything in the Greenport area. Mia was very responsive, and the place was great. We would stay here again!

We really enjoyed staying at Lynn’s place! Very clean and had a great view of the ocean from the deck. Lynn was very responsive and made the experience seamless. We would definitely stay with Lynn again.

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

Thank you for the stay. Price, location, communication and apartment were all top notch. We had a great week, definitely recommend, hope to be back.