Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island

Find and book unique fire pit rentals on Airbnb

Quick stats about vacation rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 30 vacation rentals in Shelter Island

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Shelter Island vacation rentals start at G$43,927 GYD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 900 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly vacation rentals

    30 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities

  • Pet-friendly vacation rentals

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Vacation rentals with a pool

    10 properties feature pools

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    10 properties have a dedicated workspace

  • Wi-Fi availability

    30 of Shelter Island vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Shelter Island rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Shelter Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

Top-rated fire pit rentals in Shelter Island

Guests agree: these fire pit rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
Home in Hampton Bays
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

Hamptons Oceanfront Oasis

Escape the hustle & bustle of city life and unwind at this stunning home in the Hamptons. The oceanfront oasis is the perfect way to wake up to ocean views, beaches and nearby restaurants. Relax on our spacious deck - perfect for morning coffees & sunset cocktails. It is just a short drive to the train station & only 15 minutes from the airport for quick getaways. For your safety, the home is equipped with Ring cameras and one-use key codes. Book now and experience the ultimate Hamptons escape!

Guest favorite
Home in Shelter Island Heights
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Mid-Century Gem with Pool. Steps to Private Beach.

Escape to our stylish mid-century modern retreat on Shelter Island. A 1 minute walk to stunning Crab Creek and a private neighborhood association beach, our home boasts 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths and an outdoor shower, and sits on nearly an acre of secluded land. The backyard is a private oasis with towering trees, a bamboo forest and a large pool surrounded by beautiful landscaping. Enjoy an indoor fireplace in winter, an outdoor fireplace and grill in summer, or a beach bonfire under the stars.

Top guest favorite
A serene landscape features a heated saltwater pool bordered by lush greenery. Sun loungers are positioned around the pool under umbrellas, while a wooden fence with trees creates a peaceful backdrop, enhancing the outdoor relaxation space.
Home in Mattituck
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Modern farmhouse w/ pool, beach, horses and winery

A new, modernized farmhouse with a heated saltwater pool in the heart of North Fork. Nestled on an acre of lush, fully fenced yard, the home can easily accommodate up to 8 guests and all pets! Minutes away from Love Lane (Mattituck's charming downtown), Breakwater Beach (one of best beaches in North Fork), Mattituck train station and surrounding the award winning Bridge Lane Vineyards and picturesque Seabrook Horse Farm, this bucolic home offers the perfect setting for a North Fork getaway.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area is presented with a cozy blue sofa and an accent chair, complemented by a decorative rug. A dining table for four is positioned nearby, and a large TV center is visible. The room is well-lit with natural light streaming through skylights.
Guest suite in East Hampton
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Hamptons Dream Suite

Hampton's Dream Suite- Is a guest suite in East Hampton, NY. From relaxing by the pool, to taking a day trip to Montauk, or visiting some of the best beaches in the Hamptons, the opportunities here are endless! It offers a bedroom with a Queen size Select Comfort bed, living room has two queen sofa beds and a full bathroom. It has a Kitchenette, Central AC/Heat with a 65" smart TV with surround sound and DVD, Blue ray and Xbox Games . There is also a TV and blue Ray player in the bedroom.

Top guest favorite
A spacious backyard is framed by mature trees, featuring a fire pit surrounded by white Adirondack chairs. A children’s playground with swing set is visible nearby, while the home, illuminated by warm lights, stands invitingly in the background.
Villa in Southampton
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Hamptons WaterLiving-Dock, Kayak, Beach, EV charge

[FOLLOW US on INSTA @29watersedge] 1-mile from the beach, this child-friendly waterfront Southampton home is a perfect family getaway. Ready for watersports: kayak, paddleboard, boat, or jet ski. Walk down to the beach for a swim in the bay. At home, the backyard has it all: large dock, fire pit, swing/playset, hammock, grill, & oversized deck to take in the views. Surrounded by nature and water, you are just minutes from restaurants and shopping in Southampton Village &Sag Harbor.

Top guest favorite
A serene beach scene is depicted, showcasing soft white sand bordered by gentle waves. Tall grasses sway in the foreground, framing the clear blue water that extends to the horizon, providing a sense of calm and natural beauty.
Guest suite in North Fork
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Enjoy a relaxing getaway to the North Fork

One bedroom suite, with separate entrance in quiet Nassau Point; a peninsula, surrounded by beaches. Nassau Point is a great place to bike, walk and enjoy nature. Fully functioning WiFI for guests looking to extend their stay, while working from home. Fishermen's beach is a 5 minute walk Causeway beach is a 10 minute walk with parking. Point beach, 1.5 mile walk, a Southold Parking Permit required. You will find 20 wineries within 5 miles, just a short Uber ride away.

Guest favorite
Home in Shelter Island Heights
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Hay Beach Family Home: Fire Pit, Playroom, Yard

Two blocks from Hay Beach, this family-and-dog-friendly 3BR sleeps 6 in a quiet Shelter Island neighborhood. Fenced yard, fire pit, playroom, crib, toddler toys, beach gear, and bikes included. The home was built for families: open living area with wood-burning fireplace, full kitchen, 2 full baths, basement playroom, and workout space. Outside: fully fenced yard, fire pit, sun loungers, propane grill, Big Green Egg. Winter stays: $0 cleaning fee Nov–Mar.

Guest favorite
The front exterior of the bungalow is showcased, featuring a wooden fence that provides privacy and a garden filled with hydrangeas. The house displays large windows that invite natural light, set against a backdrop of gravel and greenery.
Home in Greenport
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 294 reviews

The Greenport Bungalow

Sweet Modern Bungalow Walking Distance to Town Located in the historic town of Greenport Village - 8 min walk to the beach, center of town, Shelter Island Ferry and LIRR... A newly built sun filled 3 bedroom house with all the amenities you would need when renting a home. Enjoy the large and fenced in back yard after a fun day in this historic Long Island fishing village. Great restaurants, and even better locally produced wine and beer!

Top guest favorite
A serene saltwater pool is framed by lush greenery and blooming flowers, enhancing the outdoor space. A hot tub is positioned alongside, inviting relaxation. The guest house is visible in the background, surrounded by trees and well-maintained landscaping.
Guesthouse in Shelter Island Heights
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Bayfront 1BR/2BR detached guesthouse with pool

Perfect relaxing getaway for a couple or family. Bayfront 1BR/2BR fully detached guest house with gorgeous morning views. Property has saltwater pool + hot tub (open May -October) and bay access via private dock. Central to both north & south forks (wineries + Hamptons or Montauk just short drive away). Down the road from famous Shelter Island Sunset Beach + golf course. Come explore the beauty of the Hamptons without the stress!

Guest favorite
A welcoming living area is illuminated by natural light from large windows. A comfortable gray sofa is complemented by light-colored armchairs and a coffee table adorned with books and decorative items. The neutral color palette is accentuated by indoor plants and a textured rug.
Home in Sag Harbor
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 321 reviews

Sag Harbor Cottage, Walk to the Beach!

Renovated to perfection, this fully equipped fresh & modern beach cottage has an open-plan living room, dining room & kitchen, all with high ceilings, immaculate finishings, & a sunny lower level TV room. A broad mahogany deck with large outdoor shower & gas BBQ grill runs the full length of the house & overlooks a roomy lawn with great privacy, fire pit and mature landscaping.

Luxe
A charming cottage is surrounded by lush greenery, featuring a spacious lawn edged with neatly arranged flower beds. Large windows invite natural light, and a covered porch adds to the welcoming ambiance of the home.
Home in Amagansett
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 264 reviews

Historic Designer Farmhouse - Saltwater Pool

Tucked away on a private lot, just minutes from East Hampton Village, Amagansett Village, and Indian Wells Beach, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath cottage features a heated saltwater pool & Mahogany outdoor open-sky shower - open May through October, fireside outdoor lounge area, and charming children’s playhouse - creating the perfect setting for relaxing days spent at home.

Top guest favorite
A cozy bedroom featuring a spacious bed dressed in soft linens is positioned against a light-colored wall. Natural light filters through two windows, casting gentle shadows on the warm wooden floor. A ceiling fan hangs overhead, and a mirror and chair add functional elements to the space.
Home in North Fork
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Secluded Farmhouse - Studio Apartment Style Unit

Private studio suite with separate entrance and full bath in a modern North Fork farmhouse on a peaceful farm property. Enjoy a screened porch, fire pit, and outdoor seating. Includes mini fridge, Keurig, tea, homemade granola, and seasonal eggs/produce. Attached to our home, so some light household noise is possible. Private chef + yoga services available.

Popular amenities for Shelter Island fire pit rentals

When is the best time to visit Shelter Island?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Avg. priceG$146,422 GYDG$61,916 GYDG$61,497 GYDG$61,706 GYDG$99,358 GYDG$148,304 GYDG$172,569 GYDG$157,299 GYDG$118,393 GYDG$93,292 GYDG$111,281 GYDG$121,321 GYD
Avg. temp0°C1°C4°C10°C16°C21°C24°C24°C20°C14°C8°C3°C

Destinations to explore