Boutique hotel vacation rentals in Tompkins County

Find and book unique boutique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotel rentals in Tompkins County

Guests agree: these boutique hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

A fire pit table is positioned on a spacious outdoor patio, surrounded by comfortable seating. The flames flicker above decorative glass stones. Scenic views of a lush landscape and water can be seen in the background, with soft clouds overhead reflecting warm light.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Hillside Terrace Room, Inn at Taughannock Hotel

This cozy 215 square foot queen bedded room is located in the Hillside House on the first floor. It features a pillowtop mattress with plush bedding, Carrera marble floor bathroom with walk-in shower, Beekman 1802 bath product line made fresh in upstate NY, flat-screen television, Keurig, hairdryer, telephone, complimentary Wi-Fi, and access to a complimentary self-service laundry facility in Edgewood. There is not a view of the lake or pond. Non-pet-friendly accommodation.

Top guest favorite

A well-maintained sign for 16 Elm Heritage Hotel stands amidst lush greenery, with a grand historic mansion visible in the background. The white building features dark shutters and a red roof, surrounded by garden landscaping, creating a welcoming entrance to the property.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Adorable Double Twin @ 16 Elm, Historic Mansion

Enjoy the glamour of this historic mansion redone with modern amenities and upscale styling. This Double Twin guestroom is adorable, eminently comfortable and perfect for 2 travel companions on an adventure. You can also enjoy the other spaces: living room, library, sunroom, tour the gardens and grounds and enjoy the patio.We are moments from the Wine Trail, Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls.

Superhost

The image showcases the exterior of the Grayhaven Motel, featuring two distinct buildings amid well-maintained grassy areas. Brightly colored doors lead to individual rooms, surrounded by manicured bushes and trees. Parking spaces are visible nearby, indicating convenient access for guests.

Hotel room in Ithaca

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Mid-Century Simplicity (Grayhaven Motel - King)

Our lovingly restored vintage motor lodge has been hosting Finger Lakes vacationers & travelers for more than 100 years. Rooms have been thoughtfully restored with period fixtures & modern amenities. Please read on about the space and review all of the information in this listing to ensure the Grayhaven Motel is the right fit for you and your group. We look forward to hosting you!

Superhost

A serene outdoor view showcases vintage-style cottages and a larger building in a natural setting. Lush green grass surrounds the structures, and vibrant shrubbery complements the blue and red accents on the cottages. Mature trees provide shade, enhancing the tranquil ambiance.

Hotel room in Ithaca

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Treman Lodge Double Queen (Grayhaven Motel)

Guest favorite

The image captures a view of a well-maintained property featuring several blue cottages with red doors, surrounded by lush green grass and landscaped gardens. A larger building is visible in the background, with ample parking space. Tall trees frame the scene, adding to the serene ambiance.

Hotel room in Ithaca

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Mid-Century Simplicity (Grayhaven Motel - Queen)

Superhost

A spacious queen bedroom features a wooden bed adorned with white linens, complemented by a colorful area rug. A well-lit sitting area includes a small dining table and chairs. A private bathroom is visible through an open doorway, and a window allows natural light to fill the room.

Hotel room in Ithaca

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Carriage House Queen (Grayhaven Motel - Rm #8)

Superhost

Two mid-century modern chairs with teal upholstery are positioned beside a small wooden table. Below, a geometric patterned area rug features warm tones of orange and brown, adding a contemporary touch to the space.

Hotel room in Ithaca

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Carriage House Double (Grayhaven Motel - Rm #4)

Superhost

The exterior of a traditional cottage is showcased, featuring a blue wooden facade with white trim and black shutters. Lush green landscaping surrounds the cottage, including various shrubs and plants along the stone walkway leading to the entrance.

Hotel room in Ithaca

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Four Seasons Cottage (Grayhaven Motel)

Top guest favorite

A charming entrance features a white door with a glass panel, flanked by two hanging planters filled with red flowers. A white seating area, including wicker chairs and a small table, is accentuated by potted plants and a decorative rug at the door.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Junior Suite @ 16 Elm an Historic Mansion

Enjoy the glamour of this historic mansion redone with modern amenities and upscale styling. Your guestroom is not only eminently comfortable but you can also enjoy the other spaces, living room, library and take your breakfast in the sun room. Tour the gardens and grounds, enjoy the patio. We are moments from the Wine Trail, Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls.

A jetted tub is nestled in a tiled alcove, featuring a curtain for privacy. A toilet is positioned nearby, and a framed artwork enhances the serene atmosphere. Warm lighting creates a comforting ambiance in this spacious bathroom.

Hotel room in Groton

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Smith Corona Room

Groton was once known as the “Typewriter Capital of the World.” This typewriter manufacturing company became Smith Corona Marchant in later years and closed manufacturing in Groton in the 1980s. This second floor 350 sq foot room features a king size bed, 32” flatscreen tv, gas fireplace, a large balcony overlooking the beautiful grounds and a jetted tub.

The exterior of a white, two-story home is framed by lush greenery and well-maintained landscaping. A gravel pathway leads to the entrance, featuring a covered porch adorned with white railings and decorative shutters. Soft light emanates from the windows, suggesting a welcoming ambiance.

Hotel room in Groton

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Thatcher David. Queen Suite garden view w/ spa tub

The Thatcher David is our most eclectic queen room. Complete with a Mackenzie-Childs canopy rooster bed and all of these other wonderful features; see-through gas fireplace, swing arm 43" flat screen Smart TV , Jacuzzi bath tub, private bath, and air-conditioning. Spend a soothing night soaking away the day’s worries with a warm fireplace at your feet!

Top guest favorite

A spacious foyer is highlighted by a large dark wooden table adorned with floral arrangements and decorative bottles. A vibrant area rug covers the hardwood flooring, creating a cozy feel. A staircase leads to the upper level, and elegant seating is positioned against the wall.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Boutique Room @16 Elm an Historic Mansion

Enjoy the glamour of this historic mansion redone with modern amenities and upscale styling. Your guestroom is not only eminently comfortable you can also enjoy the other spaces, living room, library, sunroom, tour the gardens and grounds and enjoy the patio. We are moments from the Wine Trail, Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Apartments

Convenient locations with everyday essentials

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Cabins

Kick off your hiking boots at these rustic lodgings

Popular amenities for Tompkins County boutique hotel rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Family-friendly boutique hotels rentals

Superhost

The room features two spacious queen beds with crisp white linens. A large window allows natural light to brighten the space, and a seating area with two armchairs complements the wood accents. A flat-screen television is mounted on the wall, opposite a desk and chair.

Hotel room in Ithaca

Treman Lodge Double Suite (Grayhaven Motel)

NicoleRating, 5 stars61 months ago

A cute motel in a great location...a few minutes from Buttermilk Falls and Ithaca Beer Co, and a great outdoor space with a fire pit. Would definitely come back!

Superhost

A spacious bedroom features a large bed with crisp white linens and several pillows. Soft lighting is provided by two bedside lamps, and natural light pours in through a large window, offering views of the outside.

Hotel room in Ithaca

Carriage House Suite (Grayhaven Motel - Rm #7)

AnnaRating, 5 stars57 months ago

This is such a nice little motel and very conveniently located for hiking and wine tasting, which is why we came! Really nice to have the kitchenette and the furnishing was contemporary and clean :) despite covid we felt very comfortable staying here knowing the rooms were well cleaned and guidelines were being followed to limit contact. The host was very quick to respond and friendly! They provided a book in the room of places to eat and things to do which was great. Would come again!

A spacious room is featured with a king-size four-poster bed covered in dark bedding. Two blue armchairs are positioned beside a window with natural light filtering in. A wooden bench sits at the foot of the bed, and a large area rug adds texture to the hardwood floor.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

Hillside Lakewatch Room, Inn at Taughannock Hotel

CarrieRating, 5 stars45 months ago

Had a really great weekend stay! The property is beautiful, clean, well maintained, and has nice views of the lake. Staff were friendly and helpful and other guests were respectful and social. Hanging down around the fire pits at night with a glass of wine was the best part. Location is great too if the Taughannock Falls are on your agenda since it’s just a couple steps away and less than 15 mins to downtown Ithaca.

A welcoming entryway features hardwood flooring that leads toward a spacious living area. A staircase with wooden treads and a floral wallpaper accent wall creates an inviting atmosphere. The great room is visible in the background, showcasing a cozy seating arrangement and dining space.

Hotel room in Trumansburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Hillside Le Grand Residence-1725 s.f. luxury home

RebeccaRating, 5 stars37 months ago

Great location and wonderful place to stay. It was spacious and really enjoyed the pool table. Sat on the enclosed patio every day. Very clean and comfortable. Quick walk to Taughannock Falls state park. Hiked back to the falls several times.

Show all

Boutique hotels rentals with a patio

A spacious room features a king-sized bed with a tufted headboard, complemented by elegant bedding. Two windows allow natural light to fill the space, while a sitting area includes a cozy couch and a small table with chairs. A flat-screen TV is mounted above a decorative fireplace.

Hotel room in Groton

Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth · Channing Elizabeth. King suite sunset view spa tub

KendraRating, 5 stars5 months ago

It is a very spacious room with all the accommodations we wanted. Loved the fireplace and jacuzzi.

A cozy suite features a king size bed with a patterned blanket, a gas fireplace, and a sitting area with a sofa. Large glass doors provide access to the double patio porch overlooking the grounds, while warm light fills the room from lamps and windows.

Hotel room in Groton

Dempsey Suite

JeremiahRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Super quiet and relaxing place to stay!Drew was an accommodating host and Shelly was nothing short of amazing. Upon arrival she took the time to give us a tour of the property and cooked us a great breakfast in the morning. She really made us and our husky feel welcomed!! Very clean room with a nice sized bathroom. 100 percent would recommend!