Kid-friendly vacation rentals in New Shoreham

This house is a gem! The inside is exactly as pictured and is very comfortable. The views from the deck are stunning, especially during sunrise. Pam has equipped the house with all the essentials and we were even pleasantly surprised with welcome treats at check in. Highly recommend this home for families. Some activities we enjoyed were kayaking across the pond to the beach (not easy- but highlight of the trip!), crabbing and fishing off the dock, wine on the deck, walking less than a mile to ice cream and coffee shops and biking around the quiet neighborhood. I really can’t recommend this home and host more! Fabulous stay.

Super clean, quiet and comfortable with lots of great touches. We didn’t get the best weather for lake life but the house made up for it nicely. Look forward to staying again someday!

We had an amazing time at the lakehouse! Tim and Marissa are super communicative and left many helpful directions! The property is beautiful and the house felt like home away from home! I can't wait to go back! 10/10 recommended 😊

Great location, everything was as advertised in the pictures. Definitely would recommend.

We had an amazing Memorial Day weekend at Heather’s place! The house was perfect. It was clean, comfortable, and stocked with everything we needed for a relaxing getaway. Heather was a fantastic host, super responsive and thoughtful, making sure we had everything we needed for a stress-free stay. You can tell she really puts care into every detail. We couldn’t have asked for a better spot and can’t wait to come back!

Joanne's waterfront home is an incredible oasis. Even the pictures do not do it justice. Our family had a wonderful week-long stay in her beautifully appointed home. Joanne's home is meticulously clean and decorated with wonderful touches. We had plenty of room and loved soaking up the sun every day on the fabulous wraparound porch (with built-in umbrellas) and jumping right into the water mere steps from the house. We cannot wait to return next year!

This house was exactly how it was described. As soon as you pull into the drive way you see a gorgeous house. Checking in was a breeze. Gary gave us the pin and we were all set to access the house. The pictures do not do this house justice. Everything was spotless. We felt like we were home. Our host Gary was so sweet and responsive. He created this welcome booklet which helped so much. We couldn’t have asked for a better weekend away. We cannot wait to come back and stay at Gary’s house. Thanks Gary for everything!

George is the best he is very kind and has great stories

If I could give 100 stars I would!! Out of all the airbnbs I have stayed at Jennifer’s listing has outdone them all!! First of all, Jennifer was the most amazing host and treated us like family! Secondly, the house was spotless, not a speck could be found (and I am usually picky about cleanliness) — it was absolutely exceptional!!! I will definitely be coming back multiple times. Thank you Jennifer for hosting us!

We had a great stay in Newport at this beautiful Victorian. The place was super clean and had everything we needed. The owner did an amazing job making it feel comfortable and welcoming. We really appreciated the breakfast options too which was a nice touch. It’s in a perfect location only about a 10 minute walk from the Viking Hotel and close to everything we wanted to check out. I’d definitely stay here again.

Lynda was very friendly and accommodating. We booked the same day late morning and though she has a 24 hour in advance booking rule she was so very kind to prepare the place and welcomed us the same afternoon. It’s a quiet and peaceful place, clean and in easy reach for nice beaches and restaurants.

Beautiful and well-maintained place. We had a minor issue, but Jonas was very proactive in resolving it. Felt right at home.

We had such a great stay! The hosts were super accommodating and really attentive to anything we needed. The place was spotless, cozy, and fully stocked with all the essentials (and then some). They went out of their way to make us feel at home, and it honestly made the whole experience so relaxing and enjoyable. We loved everything about our stay and are already looking forward to making this an annual tradition! Tracy Thomas and Drenary Gwynn Baltimore Maryland

Overall very satisfied with this stay. Owner was extremely kind and communicative, stay was cozy and inviting. The stay was described well and the location is terrific. Within walking distance to many places in town.

This was our second stay and there's a reason we came back! The space is cozy and comfortable - We especially appreciated the easy flexible check in and snacky snacks and coffee. Thank you Norm!

Kelly and Rick’s place is absolutely beautiful and a perfect retreat for couples or anyone looking for a relaxing, scenic experience in Montauk. We’ve lived on LI our whole lives but never got to explore the east end until now, and Kelly’s place is the PERFECT location! It’s near town with great restaurants, coffee shops and grocery stores nearby, near hiking trails where we got to see seals and beautiful views of the ocean, near the lighthouse, near great fishing spots, etc., not to mention the gorgeous view of Lake Montauk right on their property. We used their fire pit and had a fire the last night of our stay as well! We had a BLAST and had such a relaxing weekend. The apartment was very clean and has everything you could need for your stay, and Kelly was super attentive and responsive when it came to answering our questions and inquiries. Thank you again for giving us such a beautiful place to stay! 10/10 recommend! We’ll definitely be back🌊❤️☀️

Pelham Court was a great stay. Great communication for checking in and checking out as well as during our stay. Very clean! The bed and pillows were extremely comfortable. It was great to be able to walk to all the restaurants and the shops. Would definitely recommend staying here.

The Villa was exactly as described! Easy communication with owner. A perfect getaway weekend, every amenity we could want or need! Look forward to visiting again in the near future!

Really great stay. Apartment was perfect for us. Less than 5 mins walk to the beautiful beaches and small town. Would stay again!

We loved Montauk - low key, wild and upmarket at the same time. This apartment was perfect, super quiet yet near everything and loved seeing wild deer from the terrace

We had a great time and the property was immaculate! The hosts came by with extra towels quickly upon request and it was a holiday. Recommended!

This is a wonderful property that is close to everything we like to do! Krista is a wonderful host and I’m always excited if her place is available.

We had a great stay! Instructions were clear and the home had everything we needed.

Just had a wonderful stay at Robert’s place! The place was impeccably clean, and Robert was incredibly responsive and friendly throughout our visit. While the manor has a charmingly vintage vibe and could use a bit of modernization, we truly enjoyed our time there. The warmth of the atmosphere made it feel like a home away from home. We recommend for anyone looking for a cozy getaway!