Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Very nice accommodations. Beautiful and peaceful settings with very nice amenities. We had everything we needed and it was clean and property is situated on a peninsula which is lovely from every view. Highly recommended for a peaceful retreat.

Perfect stay for the 7 of us. Very comfortable and GREAT neighborhood. Met some of the neighbors and one let us park a boat in their drive. We will definitely rent again. Thanks!

The inside of the home was beautiful. The pool and deck was amazing. Kitchen and bathrooms stocked well. We would definitely go back! The only negatives are the landscape is very neglected The dock needs work. Maybe a little more flexibility on checking in earlier than 3pm. Otherwise the home is beautiful and we would stay again!

We had a great stay.

Lovely, peaceful location. Spacious and well furnished home. Comfy beds and bedding, plush bathroom towels. Erin was an accomodating host and replied quickly to our messages. Will definitely stay again.

We were a last minute booking because the previous place we booked was not fit to stay at. We were stressed and the owners immediately put us at ease. They were responsive with our questions. The house was beautiful and clean and looked just like the pictures. This place saved our weekend. Highly recommend this place!!

Amazing location and beautiful home. Todd & Amber were very responsive and flexible with our last minute reservation. Would stay again in a heartbeat

Absolutely the break I needed from caring for a parent with dementia. Got to have amazing time with my daughters and my dogs were in Heaven! Joy has an amazing home, beautiful property and lots to do! Plus, she’s a wonderful host. The kitchen is amazing and we shared lots of laughs around that island. I will be booking again for sure!!

Charles was a great host, friendly and responsive. We enjoyed our stay, especially the deck and backyard, including the fun game room downstairs. The house was spacious enough for our family of 8. We would recommend his place to other guests.

Based on the address provided, it was difficult to locate- but once a local store owner told me where it was, the home exceeded expectations!

Our family was thrilled with this lake house! It was very functional and fit us perfectly—8 adults and 5 kids. Even though it rained every day we were there, the game room kept us entertained and we had all we needed to be comfortable. Easy access to grocery stores. Beautiful view of the lake with plenty of outdoor seating to enjoy it! We will be back!

Lauren's place is exactly as pictured and perfect location!! We had a fluke incident that no one could have predicted and Lauren took care of it immediately and was so sweet to work with! We loved our stay and highly recommend!

Nice place to stay for our construction crew.

The house was beautiful. Fully stocked with towels which is a huge plus when booking a home that sleeps 8 people. The interior of this home is unmatched. It was so clean, so modern, and homey. We also had fun playing the board games they have at the house. We will be back!

Renee was a great host with quick response time and provided added resources for what shelbyville had to offer. The house exceeded our expectations and we appreciated all the amenities that the house had to offer- will be recommending to other organizations to use for retreats!

What a beautiful home! We only stayed one night but I wish we could e stayed a week! The house was spotless, the beds comfortable, and the backyard and dock were a hit with the kids. Blaine was very responsive to questions and was super helpful with everything. We loved it!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Serene Slice of Heaven! This Airbnb was everything I hoped for and more—a truly surprising gem! From the moment I arrived, I felt instantly at peace. Nestled right on the water, the setting was absolutely magical: tranquil, serene, and perfect for unwinding. I’ve stayed at many places over the years, but this was hands down the cleanest property I’ve ever seen. Every detail was spotless, fresh, and clearly cared for with love. One of the biggest highlights for me? My dogs were welcome—and not just tolerated, but truly accommodated! The space felt totally safe for them to roam and relax, which gave me such peace of mind. It’s rare to find a place that combines such high-end comfort with pet-friendly warmth. Whether you’re looking to unplug and recharge, or just enjoy some quality time by the water, this is the perfect spot. I’m already dreaming of my next visit. Thank you for sharing your little piece of paradise!