Lake Shelbyville fishing places to stay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Mattoon

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Brickway Retreat

Newly Remodeled 2 Bed, 1.5 Bath home in quiet neighborhood. This modernized house features a large fully furnished kitchen that is open to the dining area. The large living room with 10 ft ceilings has a pull-out sofa. Big screen TVs equipped with Roku streaming service in the master bedroom and living room. Wi Fi throughout the house is included. Enjoy your mornings on the cozy front porch featuring cedar pillars and stamped concrete and enjoy your evenings on the back patio around the fire pit

Aug 13 – 20

G$22,499 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Effingham

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Quiet Lake House By the Beach

Welcome! Quiet Lake House by the Beach is just as it describes! The property shares a driveway with the cabin I also host. The Lake House is newly remodeled. The outside is still being worked on at this time. Please excuse any unsightly renovations as they are completed. The Lake House is located just a short walk to Beach, Pinky’s (seasonal, Opens May 1, 2022!), The Rusty Reel Bar (below Pinky’s) and The Marina. The beach offers a beautiful playground, pavilions and a frisbee golf course!

Nov 21 – 28

G$26,557 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Arcola

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Tiny home

Welcome to our suite! Whether you are looking for an anniversary getaway or if you are traveling through the area and looking for a relaxing spot to rest, you will thoroughly enjoy your stay here. Relax and take a soak in the hot tub, while the soothing jets work the tension out of your muscles. Then watch the sheep and chickens graze in the pasture. Less than 2 miles east of Arcola and just off Interstate 57 on Rt. 133, 30 minutes to Champaign airport and right outside of Amish country.

Jun 17 – 24

G$26,270 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Teutopolis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 447 reviews

The Shoe Inn, a modern apt in downtown Teutopolis

Welcome to The Shoe Inn! You'll be at the center of town within walking distance to all the places you need to be: banquet halls, five bars, restaurants, Wessel's grocery store, ice cream shop, church, hardware store, post office, and community parks. Smart lock, contactless entry is available for a convenient & safe stay. Enjoy the full size washer & dryer, fireplace, kitchenette (no stove), free parking, Samsung 50" smart TV w/ 100's of cable channels, Alexa device, & free fast WiFi.

Aug 26 – Sep 2

G$15,310 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Brownstown

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

House By The Woods 2-bedroom house with fireplace

House with propane fireplace, 1 bathroom, 2 bedrooms, & futon in living room that can sleep up to 6 total. It is surrounded by woods that has a side outdoor porch with a seating area & table with chairs to eat/drink your favorite drink/coffee anytime of the day or night. Firepit area for roasting hotdogs or marshmallows. Firewood & picnic table on premises. Propane grill near back patio. Small kids play area in front where parents can still sit relaxing on side patio and watch the kids.

Feb 10 – 17

G$22,861 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Brownstown

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Shagbark Landing

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Drive down the lane to a secluded 3 bedroom home newly furnished. Enjoy yourself in an open concept floor plan where there is lots of room to spread out. Spend your evenings in the living room or the family room that has a fireplace. From the family room you can step out on a deck and enjoy the view of the pond. We are located 8.5 miles from Vandalia where there are historical landmarks, great restaurants, and quaint shops.

Feb 3 – 10

G$29,151 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Sullivan

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Prairieview Cottage OASIS - Hot Tub Sunsets

REST, RELAX, RETREAT... Are you longing to get away from the grind and unwind in the quiet countryside? You will enjoy this beautiful, pet-friendly cottage retreat in its peaceful setting where you can watch sunsets from the hot tub, enjoy sitting around the firepit on the patio or simply relax inside. You will be in close proximity to 11,000 acre Lake Shelbyville, the heart of IL Amish country and the Little Theater, the only professional theater between Chicago and St. Louis.

Feb 28 – Mar 7

G$36,007 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Sullivan

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Lakewood Cottage #1 @ Lake Shelbyville

A completely renovated cottage, nestled in the country of Sullivan, just minutes from boating, camping, golf, theatre style shows, and more. If you are looking for peaceful nights, this place is for you! Surrounded by trees and nature where many days you will catch deer roaming the yard. Plenty of yard space for games, a fire table to converse around, and chairs on the porch to sit back, relax, and take in the tranquil sounds that surround you here at Lakewood Cottage.

Jan 31 – Feb 7

G$31,677 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Teutopolis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Wooden Shoe Factory, Historic, w/ Bar & Breakfast

Historic 1880 Wooden Shoe Factory by Wooden Shoe Maker Gerhard Deymann. A great getaway Tiny House from the past with a Bar & Books. Please take some & leave some :-) Fully furnished. Tons of charm. It has a loft, luggage lift, exposed brick/beams, fireplace, bikes, antiques, front sitting area, swing, grill, back patio, yard, private parking, appliances, vaulted ceilings. 6 minutes to I57, I70, Effingham, & dozens of restaurants. 1 block to 7 Teutopolis Bars, & diners.

Jan 28 – Feb 4

G$13,942 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Ashmore

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Sweet Dreams Cabin. Peaceful & Relaxing

Get some quality family time at this newly remodeled cabin near the beautiful Embarrass river. You are surrounded by beautiful woods and a small creek. Lush wildlife is all around you so you can be one with nature. The cabin has all the luxury's to allow for a long term stay as well. Beautiful Lake Charleston is not far away. The large circle drive offers plenty of parking for your boat and guest. The large deck on the rear gives a beautiful view to be enjoyed by all.

Nov 13 – 20

G$30,954 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Arthur

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Sisters Cottage

A recently renovated Cottage, nestled in the heart of the small, quaint town of Arthur. Located next to the Arthur Park. Enjoy the clip clop of the horse & buggies going by as you relax out front on a swing, or enjoy the back porch with table & seating as you enjoy the perennial garden out back. Plenty of back yard for playing games. A fire pit is located close to porch for roasting marshmallows at night. Arthur is a very innovative town with lots of shops to explore.

Mar 18 – 25

G$23,705 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Effingham

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Country cottage tiny home.

This 240sq ft cottage offers big living in a tiny space. The cottage is on our 2 acre property that is used for a hobby farm and primary residence. The cottage features luxury vinyl flooring, granite counter tops and an updated farm house feel. The queen size bed is sure to provide the right amount of comfort. When you wake up, walk on over and grab a cup of coffee from the keurig. Enjoy a walk around to see the goats and chickens before heading off for the day.

Jul 7 – 14

G$11,893 GYD per night