Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Ithaca

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 228 reviews

2 BR/2B Lake house Minutes from Town and Campus!

-Beautiful lake views -Amazing location -Cozy -Modern -Comfortable -Peaceful & Private These are the most common remarks from our guests. The perfect lake living on the water while still minutes from town! Treat yourself to coffee/tea every day while watching the sunrise over the lake from dual balconies/the dock. This is a two-story home w/ 2 bedrooms & 2 full baths. Accessible to Ithaca's finest restaurants, Cornell University & Ithaca College, wineries & all the Finger Lakes have to offer.

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen features light wood walls and a wood-paneled ceiling. Stainless steel appliances are present, including a gas stove and microwave. Open shelves display dinnerware, and a dining table with stools is positioned nearby, creating a cozy space for meals and gatherings.

Cottage in Interlaken

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

🍷CLOUD WINE COTTAGE FLX🍷secluded w/HOT TUB!!!

Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. Located on the Cayuga Wine Trail, with the Seneca Wine Trail 8 miles away. Travel down a long gravel driveway to a modern cottage hidden back in the trees. Enjoy peaceful campfires, relax in the hot tub, watch Netflix or Disney plus on our smart tv, or bring your favorite blue rays/dvds with you to watch. The cottage has a beautiful open floor plan with a fully equipped kitchen for all your cooking needs and fully stocked coffee bar.

Top guest favorite

A newly constructed barn home is positioned beside a serene pond, surrounded by lush green grass and colorful flower beds. The expansive outdoor area offers scenic views of rolling hills and vibrant autumn foliage under a partly cloudy sky.

Barn in Burdett

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Private EcoBarn Home with Sensational Sunset View

Eco-green,Recently Constructed Barn Home. Built with mostly locally grown organic, acquired and reused materials with a focus on health, comfort and energy efficiency. Connect with nature, every room features glass doors. Our home is a choice location for privacy, sunsets and exploration of the Finger Lakes and the famous wine trail. Our home features a large screen room, pavilion, fire pit and pond. Sample the bounty of our organic garden, berry bushes and fruit trees. Sample the best of FLX.

Guest favorite

A wooden deck sits by the water, featuring two Adirondack chairs positioned for relaxation. A set of stairs leads up to the property, surrounded by lush greenery. The shoreline is lined with smooth rocks, and a kayak is visible nearby, ready for use.

Cottage in Geneva

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

cottage home: wine trail, sunset view, lake view.

Located on a peaceful private road, this stunning vacation cottage is a perfect place to relax and unwind both outside and indoors in All Season. Ideal getaway retreat with modern amenities, including full bath and stunning views. Spacious and bright open floor plan with large windows and cozy furnishings perfect for family gatherings. and sunset view lake house. Dock/ swimming/water activities included. Enjoy your own private beach access. Entire property offers a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Top guest favorite

A hot tub is softly illuminated by blue lights, positioned on a wooden deck. Nearby, a window offers a glimpse of the surrounding trees in a dimly lit outdoor setting.

Home in Ithaca

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Rustic Modern Retreat- Hiking,waterfalls,wineries

Enjoy your next Finger Lakes vacation at the Rustic Red Retreat! Located just outside of Ithaca, and a short drive to Cornell, this home is nestled next to a peaceful pond and provides modern amenities with rustic charm. The beautiful hand-hewn beams, reclaimed materials, and fireplace offer a warm, cozy stay after a busy day exploring the area. Enjoy numerous state parks, incredible waterfalls, wineries, breweries, restaurants, and all the seasonal events that the Finger Lakes have to offer!

Guest favorite

A cozy sleeping area features a queen-sized bed topped with white bedding, next to a wooden bedside table holding a lamp. Natural light enters through a window, illuminating the rustic wood paneling and blue-green walls, creating a serene environment.

Apartment in Ovid

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 548 reviews

Cozy Apt. Very Quiet & Private

The Apt. is a quiet, clean & cozy 400 sq. ft. with a full kitchen. The bathroom is furnished with a shower/tub. The toilet is a SELF CONTAINED COMPOSTING unit. The sleeping area has a very comfortable queen sized bed. This is a working farm. I have machinery & farm related equipment in the vicinity of the Apt. You may expect sometimes to hear & see the machinery moving during the day The Apt. has 2 entrances, it's own w/deck & one through the attached barn where I store some small equipment.

Top guest favorite

Guest suite in Ithaca

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 618 reviews

The Taughannock Falls Suite

Welcome to your home away from home! A peaceful retreat nestled amidst breathtaking scenery away from the hustle and bustle but still conveniently located between Ithaca and Trumansburg. Easy access to all the Finger Lakes has to offer. Bring your bikes and furry friends as you'll have direct access to The Black Diamond Trail from our yard to launch your adventures. Settle in after a day of exploring, unwind by a campfire under the stars, or enjoy a cozy night in. Let the memories begin!

Guest favorite

Home in Ithaca

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Magical lakefront treehouse, minutes to downtown

A magical treehouse perched over its own gorge on Cayuga Lake. This place is special! There’s a giant porch wrapped around a 300-year oak tree and a lakeside tea house that can serve as an extra bedroom. There’s a dock, fire pit, room for yard games by the water, plenty of outdoor seating on the porch, by the lake, or on the dock. All of this is minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell, and Taughannock Falls state park. It’s also a great base to explore the Finger Lakes wine region.

Guest favorite

The image captures a serene lakeside view at sunset, where the sun casts a shimmering reflection on calm waters. Soft hues of orange and purple fill the sky, framed by silhouettes of distant trees and the shoreline, creating a tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Cayuga

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Cayuga Dacha

Welcome to Cayuga Dacha, our Happy Place. We hope it will be yours too! Situated on the Northeast side of beautiful Cayuga Lake, close to wineries, breweries, the Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Montezuma Wildlife Refuge, marinas, restaurants, golf and more! Enjoy lake views from the house or deck, relax by the water, paddle in the kayaks, create a feast in the fully-equipped gourmet kitchen, or plan your wine country adventure with the help of our carefully curated guide to the FLX.

Top guest favorite

An outdoor patio area features a modern fire pit surrounded by comfortable seating. Potted flowers add a touch of color, and a large umbrella provides shade over the dining table. The backdrop includes neatly trimmed green grass and tall evergreen trees.

Home in Skaneateles

5 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Sunset House- Beautiful Home with Gorgeous Vistas

Experience a home full of windows and light that take in breathtaking views from every angle. You feel like you are on top of the world surrounded by beautiful rural landscaping that is only 1.8 miles from the charming Village of Skaneateles! Lovely interior furnishings with your comfort in mind. You are within close reach to the Skaneateles Polo Fields, a free public boat launch, Skaneateles Country Club, wedding venues and a winery. This newer home is fresh, clean and cozy!

Top guest favorite

A covered outdoor seating area features two cushioned chairs and a small table, situated on a wooden deck. A barbecue grill is partially visible, while tall trees provide a natural backdrop. Dark curtains hang from the shelter, offering shade and privacy.

Cottage in Ithaca

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Carriage house

Have the best of both worlds in this private, fully renovated one bedroom carriage house, with fully stocked kitchen. Located on a low traffic, quiet road for your perfect weekend getaway to Ithaca. Close to restaurants and shopping. Within walking distance to Cayuga Hospital. Five minute drive to the Commons and ten minute drive the Cornell University or Ithaca College. You do have to walk about 50 ft through my grass so if it rains, you might want to bring some old shoes.

Guest favorite

A spacious outdoor deck presents a private table and chairs, accompanied by a barbecue grill. The serene lake view is complemented by surrounding trees and the natural landscape, creating an inviting space for relaxation and meals outdoors.

Guest suite in Ithaca

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 242 reviews

The Lakeview Nook – Midcentury Modern Stay

Enjoy this mid-century modern guest house in a spectacular site, with a lake view, waterfall, and forest all in one place. The house was just fully renovated. This house is just 2 miles from Ithaca downtown and 3 miles from Cornell University. The location is super close to everything Ithaca has to offer—Ithaca falls, hiking, Ithaca Commons, movies and theater, restaurants, the farmer's market, the waterfront trail, wineries-- all within a few minutes drive of your rental.