Cabin vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake

Kate & Jess were great hosts! I loved staying at the Bear Camp for several nights. The lake front dock area is gorgeous and the cabin uses natural light to wonderful effect. The mornings drinking coffee by the sunlit windows were some of the most relaxing I’ve had recently. 10/10 would stay here again.

Couldn’t recommend Craig or his locations more! Everything felt as comfortable as home while being in one of the most peaceful areas imaginable, I had sent Craig a few messages during my stay and he was always very helpful, extremely polite and puts his guests before himself. I will be saving his properties in a bookmark for my next travels and wouldn’t hesitate to book with him again.

Lynda’s place looked just like the photos. Very clean and nicely decorated with great amenities. I loved the personal touches with the fresh flowers and welcome basket. It was very peaceful with beautiful view of the lake. Even though it was a little chilly and rainy during our visit we still got to sit outside on the dock and enjoy the views. We would definitely book again!

Nancy’s cottage was perfect for our little family of 4. We enjoyed card games on the back porch, meals al fresco w a beautiful lake view, and of course roasting marshmallows in the fire pit at sunset. The cottage was intimate and cozy and we hope to return on a regular basis. Thank you Nancy for being inviting and more than accommodating.

The cabin was perfect. Just the right balance of vintage charm and modern amenity. Perfect for a couple. We took advantage of the kayaks and fireplace. I can't think of a better place to have stayed to enjoy all that the Finger Lakes has to offer.

I was in for a long stay with work. This place was very peaceful and relaxing. Enjoyed the scenery of the lake and nature surrounding the house. House was very clean and up kept nicely as well. Thank you for the stay and absolutely recommend!

The cabin in the woods was just like described. A simply beautiful setting and very clean cabin. Georgia was very responsive and had answers anytime we asked. Would stay again!

Jeanne’s place was so sweet. We were surrounded by the lake from all angles. It was such a beautiful view. The home was very homey and had everything we needed to feel at home. It was close enough to the town of Skaneateles and beautiful parks. We really enjoyed our time at her amazing lake house.

We loved our stay! The ponds were just beautiful and we enjoyed them with our morning coffee. The site is a little hidden oasis. The house was spotless and very comfortable for our family of five adults. Addison was a pleasure and could not have been more helpful and accommodating with any questions or requests. I only hope this home is available the next time we are in the Rochester area.

Our stay here was wonderful. The accommodation for the dogs was outstanding! I highly recommend to read through the house book. There are a few things we needed guidance on and the book helped us. The host is very responsive if you need anything. We left our custom leashes there. Fortunately, they found them and offered to mail the leashes back to us. Highly recommend!

Jonna was so welcoming and her house had a beautiful view. We pulled up and saw horses that she owns they were a great surprise to our trip. She welcomed us with some wine and flower along with a Birthday sign for us. She had lots of amenities + more. Everything you could think of "or forgot" she had extra for you. Jonna made sure we checked in alright and enjoyed our time with wonderful recommendation. The hot tub was the cleanest hot tub we have ever been in. We will for sure be coming back next year!

We loved our stay here! The stay was so peaceful and private. We absolute LOVED the hottub! Great for a weekend getaway for two in the finger lakes!

We had a great stay at James’s place. The cabin was comfortable, private and had a beautiful view. We really enjoyed walking around the lake and sitting out on the covered porch as it rained. Would definitely stay there again.

Great stay, a very cozy place!

This place is beautiful looks even nicer in person than on the pictures . It’s very peaceful and fairly easy to find they left little notes around the house to find extra linens toilet paper etc which was a very cute touch . has a lot of stuff to do outside and inside it is the perfect little get together cabin the host is very nice helpful and attentive with any questions you may have through the stay definitely recommend

We stayed for our 10 year wedding anniversary and it was perfect. Alyson's home was absolutely beautiful. Everything was just as described in the listing. The lot was beautiful and private. The house was beautifully decorated and very clean. Alyson was very responsive with clear communication and instructions from check in to check out. It's clear that Alyson puts a lot of care and thought into every detail of her listing. From the cozy touches to the thoughtful amenities, everything felt welcoming and well-planned. It exceeded our expectations. We would definitely stay here again.

Great spot for a family looking to take a break from the city! My kids loved the animals and the space to run around. The cabin made the cold wet weather much more enjoyable than we would have had with a tenting experience. Looking forward to coming back on a warmer weekend!

The cabin and property are so beautiful and filled with well-thought out details. The views are idyllic and the location is perfect to get to town, waterfalls, and wineries. Ilona is so welcoming as a host. The shower was warm and powerful, there is recycling available, access to fire wood, and the cabin has everything you need in an efficient space. Thank you for a wonderful stay. We will be back!

Had a great time! Our 2nd time there for a quick getaway. Love the location! Has all the amenities you would need. Thanks again.

We wanted a quiet weekend for our 10th Anniversary, and this cabin and location was perfect. Very warm and cozy, and sitting by the pond just taking it all in was just what we needed. Communication was great, with clear information about the cabin.

What a beautiful and peaceful location! If you're looking for an off-the-grid experience, this is a great option. We really enjoyed learning about this history of the property and seeing what Joe is building. The sauna was really special and the outdoor kitchen and shower both worked well. We would definitely stay here again.

Was such a peaceful place. Also had read all the reviews and noted that some things have been upgraded from those. Little but important touches - for instance there was lots of real forks, knives etc in drawer not just plastic ones as one reviewer had said. There's also a microwave and small fridge, coffee pot. We were just there overnight and used the gas grill to cook dinner as we didn't want to mess with the wood stove; I believe one reviewer had said it was charcoal grill but it was not. Things are well labeled how to use and what's in each drawer - no cat appeared. The temp dropped into low 40's overnight but we were fine with the two small heaters. Google maps took us right to the dirt/gravel driveway; although I do save maps in case signal isn't strong but I think we were in 4G the whole time even at the cabin. I walked around a bit with my pup and spotted rabbits and deer. Also could hear the frogs in the pond.

Hosts were very helpful and the cabin was immaculate!!

This cabin was better than it looked in the pictures. It was so adorable and cozy! We absolutely loved it and will be back!