Vacation rentals in Carl Blackwell Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Carl Blackwell Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The exterior of a charming cottage is showcased, featuring a light-colored façade and a neatly designed wooden deck at the entrance. Surrounding lush greenery and a wooden fence provide privacy, while a gravel pathway leads to the structure, inviting a sense of tranquility.
Tiny home in Stillwater
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Private Luxury Cottage w/ Hot Tub & Fire Pit

Our private cottage getaway invites you to experience romance and tranquility in a quiet country setting. Inspired by the timeless charm of French countryside cottages, this special retreat is perfectly tailored for couples seeking to share unforgettable memories together. The interior boasts an exquisite Carrara marble walk-in shower, large enough for two, adding a touch of opulence to your daily rituals. Adjacent to this, a heated towel rack ensuring warmth and comfort greet you at every turn

Top guest favorite
Home in Stillwater
5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

HUGE Game-Room Style Barndo

Private homestead on 9 acres. Enjoy a peaceful country escape to this fun game-room style barndo which includes PacMan & MK3 arcades, Air Hockey, FoosBall, Ping Pong, Shuffle Board & tons of other games, just 2mins to Lake McMurtry (we have 2 Kayaks available for use!), 8 miles to OSU, restaurants and shopping. Open floor plan is equipped with a stocked full kitchen, a 65” Roku TV in the common room, a 12ft sofa & a futon sofa, king bdrm with a 40” Roku TV. Air mattress available on request.

Top guest favorite
A countertop is displayed, featuring a box of Kelty Farms treats with a natural design. Behind it, a metal container labeled 'Snack Bar' holds various snacks. Subtle lighting enhances the cozy kitchen ambiance.
Barn in Stillwater
5 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Kelty Farms Barndominium/Horse Stalls and Parking

Get away from it all when you stay under the stars. We not only live in the country but we are set back from the road in a gated area so you get to enjoy everything from our horses to the wild turkey or deer right outside your door. The atmosphere is quiet and peaceful which makes it an easy place to relax. We not only have trailer parking, but two horse stalls in case you want to bring your horses for nearby trail rides. We also two lovable Great Pyrenees that are here to roam and protect!

Top guest favorite
A single-story home is presented with a stylish front porch, framed by wooden railings. Large windows offer natural light, while a vibrant orange door serves as a focal point. The surrounding area features landscaping with rocks and bare trees, complemented by a clear blue sky.
Home in Perkins
5 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

The Roadrunner Modern 2 Bed Fully Furnished Home.

Be close to everything - conveniently located 1 block off main street - making it easy to plan your visit. Our smart enabled home features an open floor plan from the dining nook and coffee bar with a Kuerig, through the gally kitchen to the living room featuring roku tvs and comfy queen beds in each room , wifi, washer/dryer, privacy fenced area with gill and fire pit - the Roadrunner is fully eqipped with all the amenities of home for your stay. Private feel in a centrally located home.

Top guest favorite
An inviting open-concept kitchen and dining area displays a rustic wooden dining table surrounded by clear acrylic chairs. A modern chandelier hangs above, complemented by stainless steel appliances and textured glass backsplash. Natural light enters through large windows, adding warmth to the space.
Cabin in Arcadia
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Farmhouse Retreat

Need a break from the busyness? Just driving through? Coming in to town to see family or friends? Want a weekend getaway? Come stay in a relaxing and well furnished farmhouse located on 40 acres in the hills of Arcadia, OK. The property features over a mile of wooded walking trails, a three acre pond, family friendly farm animals including everyone's favorite, Kenny the Clydesdale, a scenic back porch and more. The property and farmhouse is family friendly and accommodates up to six guests.

Top guest favorite
A wooden dining table is set with a light gray tablecloth and features an arrangement of white flowers in a green pitcher. Porcelain tea set items, including a teapot and cup, are positioned neatly on the table, while rustic cabinetry can be seen in the background.
Cabin in Guthrie
5 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Cranberry Cottage near Lazy E

The Cranberry Cottage is a unique romantic getaway nestled on a private wooded 2-acre property close to Lazy-E Arena in Guthrie, Ok. Wake up to the most breathtaking view surrounded by tall oak trees and beautiful bamboo orchard. Lay in the hammock, sip tea or coffee on the deck, read a book, picnic under one of your favorite trees and there is even room for dancing! Just 15 to 30 minutes away from Lake Arcadia, Guthrie downtown area, Edmond, OKC and surrounding areas.

Top guest favorite
Home in Stillwater
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Private cabin, mins to OSU & Tumbleweeds. Pets yes

Veteran Owned -Patriotic • Private • 35 Acres • 4.8 Miles to OSU Stadium • Hunting Available • 6 mins from Tumbleweed Dance Hall Welcome to the All-American Cabin, your private 900 sq ft patriotic-themed getaway sitting on 35 peaceful acres just minutes from OSU, Lake McMurtry, and Stillwater. Whether you’re coming for game day, a relaxing family escape, hunting season, or a quiet country reset — this cabin delivers comfort, privacy, and that true Oklahoma pride.

Superhost
Home in Stillwater
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 231 reviews

The Taylor Home

This cozy home is the PERFECT place for your next visit to Stillwater! The cabin-esque feel of this home pairs nicely with the modern amenities, making this a stay you will want to book time and time again. You will have all the comforts of home here, a washer/dryer, a comfortable bed, and a fully equipped kitchen. The property’s convenient, centralized location puts you close to all the action! Shops, restaurants, and nightlife are just minutes away!

Top guest favorite
A charming cabin is presented with a vibrant red roof and a covered porch, surrounded by lush green grass. Trees provide shade, while open pasture extends beyond. A gravel driveway leads to the cabin, enhancing accessibility.
Cabin in Perkins
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Wi-Fi, sleeps 6,full kitchen,12 mi to OSU,3bd,1ba

Welcome to the Cabin of Sunset View where it is minutes from OSU, the Fairgrounds, and the many activities of Stillwater. Centrally located, it's an easy drive to Guthrie, Edmond, Oklahoma City, and Tulsa. After a day of exploring Stillwater or surrounding areas, you will relax in the quiet peacefulness of country living. Surrounded with trees and a large meadow gives a balance of seclusion and openness making this a relaxing place to stay!

Top guest favorite
A collection of vintage arcade machines lines a wooden wall in a cozy room. Bright screens display various games, while colorful controls invite interaction. A basketball-themed machine stands prominently, complemented by a classic racing game and pinball machine nearby.
Home in Stillwater
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

The Arcade-BnB - Relax, Sleep, Play!

Why book a room when you can book an ARCADE? If you’re wanting a totally unique AirBnB experience, the Arcade-BnB is the place for you. Perfect for couples, families, business trips, etc. (No parties/events). Location is west of Stillwater near the Karsten Creek Golf Club and Lake Carl Blackwell. The listed price is for two guests ($15 per extra guest). All games (except the Claw Machine) are set to free play. Message ahead if bringing pets!

Top guest favorite
A spacious cottage sits nestled among trees under a clear blue sky. Outdoor seating is provided on a stone patio, featuring a table with chairs and a large umbrella. A grill is positioned nearby, inviting outdoor leisure and gatherings.
Cottage in Stillwater
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 244 reviews

Faye's Cottage

Our place is 15 minutes from Oklahoma State University, Lake McMurtry East is 3.5 miles away. You’ll love our place because of the outdoors space, tranquility and the wildlife. Our place is good for couples, solo adventurers, and business travelers. Enjoy the stars and nights around the fire pit. Taxes are less out here too - you don't have to pay the 4% city or 7% accommodation taxes when you book with us since we're outside city limits.

Top guest favorite
Place to stay in Stillwater
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 651 reviews

Cozy 2BR Private Farmhouse/Full bath/kit/Patio

Welcome to our Cozy Farmhouse on Main St. centrally located less than a mile from Boone Pickens Stadium. Enjoy Free Parking on Game Day and the Cozy Warmth of a 2 bedroom Farmhouse feel with a Large Outdoor Patio. Enjoy Tailgating with family and friends on game day with on our Large Patio, Grill, and Fire Pit. Also included on our Patio, is a Large 40,000 BTU Propane Gas Fire Pit to keep you warm on the cool Fall Football Games.

Popular amenities for Carl Blackwell Lake vacation rentals