Cottage vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Sunset Bay

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Conewango Valley

5 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Private Cottage/Cabin- Romantic/AlleganySt.Park

Comfy, cozy, romantic; Modern country cottage/cabin. 1 acre of lawn and wooded area. Seasonal outdoor deck/dinning, fire pit. Nestled amongst a quaint Old Order Amish community. Private secluded driveway. Allegany State park, Amish Shops, Jamestown's National Comedy Center, Lucy Desi Museum, Seneca/Allegany Casino, State land hiking trails, Ellicottville-30min. Public creeks, Lake Erie-Wineries, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua Lake. No city lights to obscure night skies. Seasonally decorated.

Top guest favorite

A hot tub is situated under a covered porch, surrounded by wooden decking. Green chairs are positioned nearby, with a picnic table visible on the lawn. The yard features green grass, and a partial view of the house is seen in the background.

Cottage in Derby

5 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Charming Cottage - Hot Tub/Fire-Pit/Lakeview

The Wellington Modern- a fresh take on simple travels. An intimate home with the amenities of a five-star hotel. Room for all the toys in the garage with oversized driveway, fully fenced in yard perfect for the pups, steamy hot tub off the back porch & all the modern necessities of today. Robes, white linens, plush memory foam beds equates to relaxation at The Wellington! Venture out to local beaches, ski resorts, restaurants, wineries & Buffalo within 30 minutes travel time. Welcome all!

Guest favorite

The image captures a serene view of Lake Erie through large glass windows. Two individuals can be seen paddling on calm waters beneath a clear blue sky. A chair is positioned nearby, providing a spot to enjoy the tranquil scenery.

Cottage in Dunnville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Niagara Dreamhouse on the Lake|Private Sandy Beach

STR-004-2025 Enjoy the 180-degree view of Sunrise and Sunset of Lake Erie from the living room. Great place to stay when you visit Niagara Region Close to Long beach area. Our Clean and lovely 2-bedroom house with a fully equipped kitchen, large indoor living area, high-speed internet. Perfect Weekend getaway from the city life with family and friends. Watch your children build sandcastle, paddle a kaya on the blue water, create memories, funs and relax on the clean private sandy beach.

Guest favorite

A macramé hanging chair is nestled in the shade of a sturdy tree, surrounded by lush green grass and foliage. Clear blue skies and distant trees are visible in the background, creating a serene outdoor setting perfect for relaxation.

Cottage in Dunkirk

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

50 FT FROM BEACH, Hot Tub, Quiet & Relaxing.

"Time wasted at the lake, is time well spent" This cozy lake cottage is the perfect place to unwind & reset. Come relax and enjoy the beautiful views of Lake Erie right from the living room or hot tub! Steps away from a big family friendly beach. Rent a bike & ride through Point Gratiot park. The entrance of the park is steps from our lakehouse, inside are beautiful grounds with pavilions, grills, playgrounds, volleyball & more! Decor & furniture are subject to change due to upgrading

Guest favorite

The image showcases a serene sunset over Cassadaga Lake, with soft hues of orange and yellow reflecting on the water. A dock is visible in the foreground, along with a boat secured at the shore, enhancing the tranquil lakefront setting.

Cottage in Cassadaga

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Lakefront Sunset Getaway on Cassadaga Lake

Welcome to the Cottage! This cottage sits directly on Cassadaga Lake where you can enjoy beautiful sunsets every night from the concrete patio or from the couch. Feel free to go kayaking, fishing, or swimming directly from the dock or shoreline. Perfect for anyone who wants to enjoy lake life for the weekend, week, or month! *NEW* 2 kayaks are available for free use during your stay. No gatherings, events, and/or parties larger than your reservation. Free parking up to 2 cars.

Top guest favorite

A circular arrangement of vibrant red Adirondack chairs surrounds a stone fire pit, providing a cozy gathering space. In the background, a wooden deck extends over Black Creek, lined with outdoor seating and partially illuminated by string lights.

Cottage in Fort Erie

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Fabulous Rustic Waterfront Cottage in Black Creek

Celebrate the holidays, winter, spring, summer or fall with family or friends at this peaceful year round 4 season retreat on Black Creek. Minutes from Niagara Falls, wineries, bike paths, golf courses, boat launch and Niagara River. Spend the days kayaking, paddle boarding, fishing or skating the Creek in the winter . Guests will love the large private property for outdoor games and night time campfires. The perfect adventure vacation awaits you at the Country Cottage on the Creek

Top guest favorite

A cozy stone cottage is set amid lush greenery by the lakeshore. Outdoor furniture, including a dining table with an umbrella, is positioned on a patio. The area is adorned with natural stone landscaping along the water's edge, creating a serene outdoor space.

Cottage in Findley Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Hidden Cove

Beautiful lakefront cottage on Findley Lake. Completely remodeled cozy one-bedroom cottage with two docks, 150 ft. of lake frontage, and boathouse. Tucked away on a quaint woodsy lot, you can enjoy breathtaking sunsets while relaxing around the firepit. Hidden Cove offers a one bedroom with a queen mattress and pull-out sofa bed. The kitchen is fully stocked. Just a few miles from Peak n' Peek resort where you can enjoy skiing, cycling, ziplining, segway tours, and restaurants.

Superhost

A serene aerial view encompasses the tranquil lake, bordered by lush greenery and a sandy shoreline. The calm water reflects the clear sky, while nearby properties are set amidst the natural landscape, inviting exploration and relaxation.

Cottage in Van Buren Point

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Vintage Lakefront Home in Historic Van Buren Point

Year round vintage lakefront home with 6 bedrooms, 1.5 baths. A cozy living room filled with vintage games, books, gas fireplace and movies! In the busy months only two cars allowed in driveway but additional parking is available. Not an issue Nov - Mar. Wood pellet smoker grill and bonfire pit with amazing lake view. Multiple beaches on the point. Please Note: The beach area in front of the house changes every season based on the weather and tide from the winters.

Superhost

A wooden sign with raised white lettering communicates a message about enjoying life at the beach. The background features horizontal grooves, and a small, round potted plant can be seen in the bottom corner, adding a touch of greenery.

Cottage in Fort Erie

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

The Cambridge Cove! Hot tub & Outdoor Gas Firepit

We are steps to beautiful Bay beach, and all of the best shops and restaurants in Town. Our newly renovated cottage, minutes from the beach will have you forgetting all of your worries. The backyard is a private oasis with a brand new hot tub, & fully fenced.There is a gas BBQ for all of your use. Indoors there is a AC system for those hot summer days, a gas fire place for the cozy, cool nights. This home really is a breath of fresh air.

Top guest favorite

The cottage exterior features a red front door framed by large windows. Potted plants are situated on either side, and two red adirondack chairs are positioned on the front porch. A slight step leads up to the entrance, with fresh landscaping visible.

Cottage in Fort Erie

5 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Steps to the Beach! Beach Passes Included!

Be at the beach in seconds! Located across the street from the main beach entrance, this large cottage sleeps 8 people comfortably 6-7 in beds. Features 3 bedrooms + 2 Sofa Beds, 2 kitchens 2 bathrooms, 2 indoor fireplaces, an outdoor fireplace and a BBQ! Huge new deck added. on the beach and enjoy great Lots of games to play and memories to create! Licensed Property. Licensed Property: License Number: 2020STR-0038.

Top guest favorite

A serene lakeside scene features a crackling fire pit surrounded by white Adirondack chairs. Soft lighting illuminates the area, reflecting off the water's surface under a twilight sky. The nearby cottage is visible, enhancing the peaceful atmosphere of the setting.

Cottage in Cassadaga

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Blue Canoe/Upscale Lake Cottage/Chautauqua

Welcome to Blue Canoe Lake Cottage on Cassadaga Lakes! Brand new EVERYTHING!!! This upscale cottage oasis sits right on the waters edge with 125ft of private waterfront and a gated covered deck overlooking the lake. This incredible renovated space is light filled and very bright with lots of high-end details and amenities. Luxury on the Lake! Recommended for 4 Adults MAX. Dog Friendly!

Guest favorite

The kitchen features a classic black-and-white checkered floor, complemented by green tile accents. A round mirror hangs above a small shelf with kitchen items, while two stools are positioned at the counter. Natural light enters through two windows, providing a bright atmosphere.

Cottage in East Aurora

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Charming 2 bedroom cottage on the EA golf course

Welcome to Maplelinks. Relax at this quiet and quaint 100 year old 2 bedroom/1 bathroom guest cottage located right on the East Aurora Country Club less than a mile outside of the village. 15 minutes from Bills games. 20 minutes from downtown Buffalo. 20 minutes from skiing. Private off street parking. Self check-in anytime after 3pm. (Sorry. No pets.)