Cottage vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

50 ft to Beach-Lakeview |Hot Tub| Quiet & Relaxing

“Time wasted at the lake is time well spent.” Welcome to your cozy lakefront cottage. The perfect place to unwind, reset, and soak up the beauty of Lake Erie. You’ll enjoy stunning lake views throughout your stay. Just steps from a large, family-friendly beach. Looking to explore? Point Gratiot Park is just around the corner, literally steps from the front door. Rent bikes & cruise through scenic trails, the park also offers pavilions, playground, volleyball court, BBQ grills, & picnic areas.

Lake-View Cottage for 4 · Wine Tasting Included

Welcome to Fisherman’s Cottage; a cozy retreat with gorgeous lake views from the enclosed front porch and open-air back deck- perfect for catching a breathtaking sunset. Spend some time enjoying a complimentary wine tasting at nearby 21 Brix and return to comfortable furnishings, a fully equipped kitchen, and an efficient bath complete with a spa tub. Rent alone or pair with our newly renovated Mainstay cottage next door for extra space- ideal for families or groups seeking a peaceful getaway.

Luxury Retreat | Hot Tub | Min To Crystal Beach

The Red Lakehouse is a warm, spotless, boutique style home designed for calm winter stays. Guests love the peaceful setting, the cozy interior, and how easy everything feels — especially when traveling with family, pets, or winter gear. Inside, the home is uncluttered, modern, and exceptionally clean, making it easy to relax the moment you arrive. Each of the three bedrooms has its own ensuite bathroom, giving everyone privacy and comfort — a rare and much-loved feature in the winter months.

Charming Cottage by the Lake

This quaint, well-maintained cottage is a perfect getaway to the beach. Located a short walk down a private drive to our community lake access, it has a fully fenced backyard and patio with grill, three bedrooms, well-appointed, updated eat-in kitchen, charming dining room, cozy living room with working fireplace, and a comfortable family room. You are five minutes from Evangola State Park, and close to Sunset Bay, SUNY Fredonia, Brooks Memorial Hospital, and Frank Lloyd Wright's Graycliff.

Quiet Creekside Escape in the Enchanted Mountains

Enjoy our creekside oasis, nestled in the quaint hills of Amish country, 1 hour from Buffalo + 15 minutes to E-Ville! The Getaway Chalet offers 3 bedrooms, stone hearth & wood-burning fireplace to keep you cozy. Outside, you'll find beautiful waterfalls, creek for exploring, two fire areas, a yoga deck & plenty of space to lounge. Unplug, reconnect + fall asleep to the sounds of the brook or bring your laptops, connect to our hi-speed WiFi and make this cozy cabin your office for the week!

Charming Cottage - Hot Tub/Fire-Pit/Lakeview

The Wellington Modern- a fresh take on simple travels. An intimate home with the amenities of a five-star hotel. Room for all the toys in the garage with oversized driveway, fully fenced in yard perfect for the pups, steamy hot tub off the back porch & all the modern necessities of today. Robes, white linens, plush memory foam beds equates to relaxation at The Wellington! Venture out to local beaches, ski resorts, restaurants, wineries & Buffalo within 30 minutes travel time. Welcome all!

Lakefront Sunset Getaway on Cassadaga Lake

Welcome to the Cottage! This cottage sits directly on Cassadaga Lake where you can enjoy beautiful sunsets every night from the concrete patio or from the couch. Feel free to go kayaking, fishing, or swimming directly from the dock or shoreline. Perfect for anyone who wants to enjoy lake life for the weekend, week, or month! *NEW* 2 kayaks are available for free use during your stay. No gatherings, events, and/or parties larger than your reservation. Free parking up to 2 cars.

Beachfront House for Family Fun or Romantic Escape

Perched atop a secluded dune, our stylish 4-season, beachfront home overlooks a stretch of the beautiful Lake Erie shoreline. Take the stairs to a private sandy beach where you can relax, stroll, swim, fish, or marvel at the sunsets. Our home is family friendly featuring a smart TV, free WiFI, fully appointed kitchen, 4 comfortable BR, 3 baths. Need provisions or a night out? You’ll find several restaurants and nightclubs, and the Buffalo Bills Stadium are a short distance away.

Vintage Lakefront Home in Historic Van Buren Point

Year round vintage lakefront home with 6 bedrooms, 1.5 baths. A cozy living room filled with vintage games, books, gas fireplace and movies! In the busy months only two cars allowed in driveway but additional parking is available. Not an issue Nov - Mar. Wood pellet smoker grill and bonfire pit with amazing lake view. Multiple beaches on the point. Please Note: The beach area in front of the house changes every season based on the weather and tide from the winters.

Blue Canoe/Upscale Lake Cottage/Chautauqua

Welcome to Blue Canoe Lake Cottage on Cassadaga Lakes! This small, 2 Queen Bedroom/1 Full Bath, newly renovated, open-concept, light-filled cottage offers 125 ft of private waterfront, a gated covered porch, & thoughtful details throughout. Enjoy 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, a pedal boat, 4 adult cruiser bikes, fire pit, & propane grill. Dog-friendly & perfect for up to 4 adults — luxury on the lake awaits! If booked, check out our sister property, Blue Oar (4BR/3BA, lakefront!

Cedar Beach Cottage on Lake Erie

Cozy cottage with full lake view from back deck! 1 bedroom w double bed, comfortable living room, full eat-in kitchen (gas stove) updated bathroom, Roku tv, wifi and large windows to let in the sunshine! Easy walking distance Point Gratiot Park. Also listed by me is nearby Cedar Beach House , a separate- but -adjacent lot with larger home suitable for 6 guests, so you can book both houses together for larger family gatherings Price includes all state and local taxes.

Charming 2 bedroom cottage on the EA golf course

Welcome to Maplelinks. Relax at this quiet and quaint 100 year old 2 bedroom/1 bathroom guest cottage located right on the East Aurora Country Club less than a mile outside of the village. 15 minutes from Bills games. 20 minutes from downtown Buffalo. 20 minutes from skiing. Private off street parking. Self check-in anytime after 3pm. (Sorry. No pets.)