Monthly Rentals in St. George's Cay

This is our 2nd visit to Geaux Fish. We love how cozy and quaint this home is. The location is perfect - a couple minutes from the beach; is close to local restaurants. It’s quiet and clean and really feels like home away from home. Josh’s response time to messages is wonderful too. Spanish Wells is heaven on earth and we’re so happy we found Josh’s place to make the visit even better. Thank you for sharing your sweet home with us, Josh and Leigh. So looking forward to 2026!

Our stay at the Tuna Can was nothing short of absolutely amazing! We took a girls weekend trip here, looking for some peace and relaxation and it was exactly that! Suzanne was so helpful with every question I had and so extremely thoughtful! She helped us secure our golf cart rental, taxi/ferry service from the airport and even met us at the dock to bring us to the house! Suzanne has the cutest animal friends ☺️ and her home is truly a retreat in the middle of the most beautiful island I’ve ever experienced! We will be back soon!

What an incredible experience at Turtle Shell Cottage! The house is beautiful, cozy, and well-equipped. One of the highlights was the included golf cart, which made it easy to explore the island. The grounds were impeccably maintained, adding to the sense of tranquility and relaxation. The beachfront, just down the path, less than 100 yards, was spectacular—crystal-clear water and white sand. Every morning, the beach was cleaned and raked, and umbrellas were set up at the picnic tables. Adirondack chairs and lounging chaises were available, making our beach days even more comfortable! Kayaks were available as well!! It's the perfect place to unplug and completely unwind. We highly recommend Turtle Shell Cottage and are already looking forward to returning.

We have returned to Deborah’s place three times and it is exceptional. All of our needs and expectations were met and Deborah communicated with us regularly. She was very responsive and has a local couple who are also helpful. We will return.