Sugarloaf Key vacation rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Cottage in Cudjoe Key

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

ATLANTIS...Ocean Front Cottage Retreat!

ATLANTIS~An ocean front cottage retreat! Completely remodeled, direct ocean-front cottage offers everything you'll need for the perfect getaway. Boat dock (25ft), HD TVs, washer & dryer, S/S appliances & gas cooking! Complimentary kayaks & bikes plus access to all the Venture Out Residential Condominium Community amenities: heated pool, Jacuzzi, kiddie pool, tennis, basketball & bocce courts, ocean bay swimming area, marina w/fuel, boat ramps & wash station, and a convenience market on-site!

Mar 5 – 12

G$181,903 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Key West

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 272 reviews

Romantic Retreat - 2 person K Suite, Pvt deck/Spa!

Romantic Retreat is an Historic, free standing cottage which, in the 1800's, was the cistern for the Cigar Maker cottages here. It is decorated in a light Caribbean motif, efficiency kitchen (frig, microwave, hot plate) and a very airy bathroom with tub/shower. King memory foam bed and sleeps 2 persons only. 32” Smart TV (bring your Netflix, Amazon UN/PW's). Bose Bluetooth speaker, Amazon Alexa provided. A private adjacent deck with a 2 person Solana spa/seating. Also handicapped accessible.

Sep 3 – 10

G$111,738 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Key West

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 450 reviews

Bella Vita: 1B/1B Condo for 2 Just Steps off Duval

1B/1B condo located in Old Town less than 1/2 block from Duval St. & a couple blocks from the Southernmost Point, Hemingway House & many other Key West attractions. Bella Vita accommodates 2 adults only and features a large porch with chairs & table, living room with leather sofa, galley kitchen with bar seating, king-size bed with Tempurpedic mattress, desk area, bathroom with large walk-in shower, wi-fi, sound machine, 2 Smart TVs, DVD players & BlueTooth stereo system with CD player & radio.

Apr 26 – May 3

G$69,609 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Marathon

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

Casa Mariposa: Easy walk to Sombrero Beach

Book your relaxing getaway now at Casa Mariposa in the heart of the Florida Keys! See why we were rated a top 15 cozy retreat in the Keys, 1 0f 24 amazing AirBNB rentals in the Keys, and, in 2023, 1 of 23 Amazing Airbnbs In Florida Keys. Step out from your private suite to our 50' lap pool surrounded with tropical foliage, large patio, and tropical gardens. Avoid beach parking fees with a short walk from your suite at Casa Mariposa! Contact us if you are interested in other lengths of stay.

Oct 12 – 19

G$45,417 GYD per night

Superhost

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Sunrise Beach Escape

For your next vacation, come stay in this resort home, where you'll enjoy a cocktail at sunset alongside the Cudjoe bay overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. This beautiful and luxurious home is part of the Sunrise Beach Resort, an exclusive 11 home gated community overlooking the Atlantic Ocean & Cudjoe Bay. A community that is only 17 miles north of Key West. Make yourself at home in this tastefully decorated 1200 sq foot living space, which offers countless amenities such as kayaks and bikes.

Jun 23 – 30

G$83,520 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Boat in Key West

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Sailboat in Luxury Marina

You will have an unforgettable experience staying on Allora, a 41 ft. sailboat, docked at the Perry Hotel and Marine - a luxury marina. PLEASE VIEW VIDEO BEFORE BOOKING: search "Allora walk through" on youtube Wake up to a freshly brewed cup of coffee and sit in the cockpit watching the sun rise across the water. Swim in the 2 heated, salt water pools and try out one of the many first class restaurants on site. Be sure to take advantage of the free shuttle to old town Key West.

Jun 1 – 8

G$30,063 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cottage in Little Torch Key

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Waterfront Cozy Cottage with Boat Ramp & Dock!

Welcome to Paradise! Stay in the amazing Keys and beautiful waterfront home with 250 foot dock, ramp, and basin for your boat. It's a must-see rustic outdoor environment and fishery experience, very typical in the Keys! The property lot is almost an acre with a work section and still very spacious. Stunning panoramic water views, sunrise and sunset. Steps away from ocean water. Bring or rent fishing and snorkel gear nearby to fish right off the dock and enjoy the underwater scenery!

Feb 13 – 20

G$113,093 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Key West

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 527 reviews

Old Town - Room Opens to Pool and Garden

Located in the heart of Old Town, we are three blocks from Duval Street, a 10-minute walk to Higgs Beach, and around the corner from the best, least-expensive meal in town--El Siboney Cuban Restaurant. We suggest bicycling around Key West. Rentals from We-Cycle Bike Shop can be delivered to our door. Two blocks away, The Duval Loop offers free air-conditioned bus service 7 a.m. until midnight. We also offer a link with recommendations for excursions, tours, & restaurants.

Jun 22 – 29

G$70,585 GYD per night

Superhost

Villa in Marathon

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

New Aqua Lodge 2Beds 1 Bath with Full Kitchens

This hip spot is the new thing in lodging. Aqua Lodge is all the modern amenities while being on the water. Full kitchens, flat screen tv's, wi-fi , pool, bikes, sunset beach. We have it all right at your finger tips. You can sleep up to 5 people comfortably. We have great air conditioning and big showers. The deck is furnished with a dining table for those romantic outdoor dinners in the moonlight. We also have a sunset beach area for the best sunsets in the Florida keys!

Mar 13 – 20

G$92,136 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Cudjoe Key Home with a View

We are so excited to share our little piece of paradise with you! Our unit is located a short walk away from all the amenities the Venture Out community has to offer such as a pool, hot tub, lagoon, bocce ball, tennis courts, playground and boat marina. On the property we have a 2-person hybrid kayak for your enjoyment. We also provide table games (we love a game night) as well as the equipment to play bocce ball and darts which can be played in the recreation center.

Aug 30 – Sep 6

G$77,062 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Key West

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 1045 reviews

At Mine | Lovely Suite steps from Duval Street

Beautifully renovated boutique hotel suite steps from Duval Street. This property is situated on a quiet street and offers a private pool and peaceful accommodation for vacationers and business travelers. The unit features a comfortable Queen-sized bed, Mini Fridge, a microwave, Iron and iron board, hangers, TV, and AC. Indulge in Key West's warm weather year-round. This special place is close to everything, making it easy to plan your visit.

Jul 28 – Aug 4

G$59,363 GYD per night

Superhost

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

Newly Renovated Oceanside House with Pool

This home is on the Atlantic side of US 1. It is part of Sunrise Beach Resort, a gated community built in 2007 with only 10 other homes. Lounge in your private hammock or enjoy the gorgeous tropical landscaping and cool breezes on one of two balconies, dock or poolside, where you can soak up the sun steps from the house. Breathtaking southwest views of the blue-green ocean and sunsets can be seen from the pool and dock.

Sep 16 – 23

G$72,404 GYD per night