Vacation rentals with a patio in Sugarloaf Key

We loved our stay at Judy’s. I have special needs and this place was perfect. I highly recommend staying here.

Condo was great. Exactly as described. 2 minute walk to the large heated swimming pool and beautiful ocean view. Shuffle board and ping pong available to play near the pool area. Safe, quiet, gated condo community. Within short driving distance to many great restaurants and activities. Frank responded within hours and answered my questions. We would recommend this rental and would gladly stay here again!

When I say that this is the most perfect Airbnb I’ve ever stayed in, I am not joking. Tina’s place is a gem in the upper Keys. Super close to John Pennekamp State park, good restaurants, and even better bars. I was able to show family who had never been to the Keys just how beautiful it truly is. Tina’s place drove that point home! I can’t wait until I have the chance to stay here again!

Amazing experience with a very attentive host 11/10

The Condo was spacious, beautiful, well furnished, very clean and the location was perfect. Henry was great to work with. We rented a golf cart and traveled almost everywhere in Key West by golf cart.

We (two couples) enjoyed a great week here. Being on the canal was nice, outside sitting spots were great. The house had plenty of cooking supplies needed. Was a tad bit smaller than I expexted, but worked out just fine. Remember to bring your shampoo, body wash etc as it's not provided. Comfortable and bright, was quiet even with boats going by. Would definitely stay here again!

Danielle was a wonderful host, and her place was absolutely beautiful. Great location, and the biggest plus was that they offered convenient items on property for use at the beach, kayaking in the bay, and just clean fun while taking an easy day around the house. We had everything we needed plus more while there. I would certainly consider staying there my next trip to the keys. Marathon Key was my favorite, anyway. 10/10 recommend this property.

Enjoyed our stay. The place was beautiful and matched the description. Just disappointed couldn’t use jacuzzi tub. Otherwise no isssues

Thank you so much for such an amazing stay! We loved the gorgeous property and all the lovely decor inside! Property was extremely clean and Sandy was so kind and helpful! We spent almost every evening in the hot tub! The home had everything we neded for an awesome week and was in a great central location, close to everything we wanted to do! We loved TJs Tiki Bar for dinner and a beautiful sunset! Thank you again Sandy! :)

If I could rate this stay a 20, I would. We came across the listing last June, after wanting to try something different on our annual trip to Marathon. It looked perfect for our family. What I didn’t expect when we arrived on April 16, 2025, was to be blown away. The pictures don’t do it justice. The house is STUNNING. I felt like we were walking in/staying at a brand new house as the very first guests. The colors, the furnishings, the level of coziness brought to this luxury beach house was unmatched. The towels (bath and beach) were plush and soft. Pool speakers. The bar! I mean everything. The kitchen was stocked with what you need - high end gadgets, utensils that actually work, and every pot and pan (organized). Immaculately cleaned. And then the views. Holy guacamole. My dad parked himself on the main floor deck and didn’t move for seven days. Airbnb was right- RARE FIND. Amanda - you are the hostiest host in the world. Your communication was 💯. And we pray to make it back to yo

The place was amazing!! plenty of room for our family of 5. All of the fishing equipment was awesome!! From the rods and tackle, to the deep freezer with bait, the extras made the whole trip more enjoyable. Loved the house. It was perfect!!! Will definately be back in the future!! 10 out of 10 would recommend!!

This was better than I expected. A very spacious 2 bedroom with large kitchen, family room. The screened in porch was huge, and a great place to have meals and watch TV and the sunrise. The fully equipped kitchen was awesome for those like us that love to cook. It was a great home away from home. This place was so comfortable and was the best we ever rented.

We recently had the pleasure of staying at this amazing beachfront house, and I can confidently say it exceeded all of my expectations! The location is simply perfect—just steps away from the water ideal for morning walks or sunrise views. The property itself is comfortable, with stylish and easy interiors that make it feel like a home away from home. The highlight was the pool—perfectly maintained and surrounded by lush greenery, offering a peaceful oasis to relax in when you want a break from the ocean. Whether you’re lounging by the pool with a book or enjoying a refreshing swim, it’s a great place to unwind. The host was also incredibly welcoming and provided thoughtful touches, from local recommendations to ensuring we had everything we needed for a great stay. I highly recommend this property for anyone looking to enjoy a relaxing beach getaway with the added luxury of a pool. Can’t wait to return!

This stay was the perfect vacation I was looking forward to, I stayed 7 days at this water front property with a great balcony to enjoy evenings and a boat ramp to launch the boats in the back yard along with the pool to keep us cool. Plenty of room for our trucks and trailers, the inside of the home was comfortable and relaxing. Was truly a great vacation Thank you

Philip's listing described the place perfectly. Zero unexpected surprises and it had absolutely everything to make our vacation super enjoyable. When it comes to location, so much to do in under 30 minutes. Smack dab in the middle when it comes to driving to Marathon or Key West. It was also great to be able to keep a boat right outside and to have a marina as part of the park. Access to great places to fish are 15-30 minutes away.

We had a fantastic stay at Villa Serendipity. Great location right off Duval Street within walking distance to everything. Private and secluded. The pool is small and shared with 12 units, but it was nice. The courtyard is welcoming and peaceful. Bed was very comfortable. Well appointed kitchen; having the ice machine was great! Hosts communicate well. Parking was tight but once we got a spot we didn’t move the car for the rest of the trip. Overall had a great time at this excellent spot in Key West!

Carrie's place was absolutely beautiful! it was so clean, the beds were insanely comfortable, and there were tons of linens and towels for everyone. We very comfortably fit 8 people into the home with no problems. The view from the balcony is absolutely amazing and we were all blown away. Carrie was extremely responsive and friendly. We were here for our wedding and had our wedding party stay here so it was extra magical. The pool and hot tub is super close, elevator to help with our bags, and the resort itself is gorgeous. 10/10 would stay again. We loved it so so much! Don't miss out.

Kate was SUPER responsive and available to us if we needed her. The home was beautiful and the decorating was top notch! I loved the interior of the condo and it was sparkling clean! I would definitely stay here again, or at any of her other properties.

Came down to Key Largo for my beautiful niece’s destination wedding. So nice we could all stay in the same resort. So convenient! Felt totally safe there. It was so clean. Nice to have the back enclosed patio and also the one off the master. Comfortable bed. Slept well. So quiet. Good water pressure in the shower. Just minutes to anything we needed. Would definitely recommend.

Edward's place was incredibly inviting and has so much to offer! It was very well appointed with nice touches like quality kitchen items, plenty of clean towels, and a spacious layout. The beds were very comfy and the location was convenient and was within easy driving access to everything that Key West has to offer while being quiet and peaceful. I would most definitely stay there again!

Enjoyed our time at Chris’s place. Plenty of towels and the kitchen was well furnished. Wonder if an air purifier might help as a few of our allergies kicked in when we were inside. All in all a great vacation

The Kawama area was cozy. Kids especially loved swimming in the lagoon. The nearby restaurant Backyard Cafe was top notch, the food was excellent, and feeding the sharks crowned the experience!

Beautiful condo located in old town. Within walking distance of great restaurants and shopping in Key West. Wendy & French are great hosts. Our plans got changed and they were so helpful to accommodate our needs. Love the beautiful garden oasis in the back. Great place to enjoy a morning coffee. I highly recommend this place

This was an incredible stay. Great location, great attention to detail. Great hosts. The place blew me away. so cool from the outside pool area and outdoor courtyard to the decor. The place fully stocked. Way more than I expected. I can't say it enough.