Cottage vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Kelly's cottage was perfect for me and my boys to get away! The stream behind the house was lovely and just a short paddle to Chautauqua Lake. My kids loved the hot tub! The cottage was fully stocked with dishes to cook with and coffee and snacks (my boys loved the mini popcorn!), as well as, plenty of fresh linens and towels. We had such a great time and are looking forward to making this a yearly tradition already!

The home is so beautiful, I took pictures because I really want to build a home and it’s what I’m going to base it off of!!! Kathlene was so helpful. Anything we needed she was right on it.!! we will plan on coming again in the future! You will not be disappointed in this location or the home itself!!

This place is amazing, beautiful home with a great view. i couldnt have asked for a better place to stay in erie. would recommend tonys home to anyone.

This was our third stay in a year and we all had a great time again. We saw lots of animals and enjoyed watching the eagle catch his breakfast every morning. The house has everything you could possibly need and Jane, as always, was an incredible host.

House was clean and cozy. The backyard was beautiful with nice grassy area for dog. I stayed M-Th so the bar next door was not busy or noisy. Internet is fast. I had to work a couple days with no issues. Friendly people and good food for small town. Had oysters from Noosa Bistro and coffee from Julbeans. Walked to the Fairport Harbor Lakefront Park everyday. Walked my dog to Veterans Memorial Park. Visited Headland Dunes State Nature Preserve.

Parkside cottages are a great place to stay with easy access to the lake. Everything is always clean, peaceful and quiet! Since our last stay we were surprised to see some updates in the kitchen that were simple and nice. If you’re looking for a quick get away in a quiet little cabin environment, this is the spot!

Sunny's place was great. I loved the hot tub and all the game options. it was serene when it wasn't raining. I can't wait to book again.

This was a very peaceful place to stay right outside Geneva-On-The-Lake. Close to everything, and it was amazing to come back home at night to end the day with a gorgeous lake view and hot tub. The house was very clean, great beds and sheets and plenty of parking. It was just the two of us but it would also work perfectly for a few kids or another couple as well. The pak man game was hit for my husband and I. Overall it was a very relaxing and a great time and place for us to relax. Thank you, Michael for allowing us to stay at your place.

The Cove was a delightful stay for my husband and I. I especially appreciated that this location was pet friendly and a great place to bring our dog. Lots of space, quiet, and cozy. We also appreciated her responsiveness to the front porch lights being burnt out- this was taken care of immediately the next day and we extremely grateful for the care shown by our host. Would absolutely book again!

Great cottage! Roomy, comfortable, great location close to I-79. Great communication! Nice big yard either lots lots of chirping birds and bunnies. Plenty of towels, washer and dryer was a real, plus a nice hot water. I would definitely stay again if in this area.

A great place to stay! We enjoyed the space and found that we were never overcrowded with 9 people and a dog. The cottage was even more beautiful than the pictures show and the A/C was a great amenity! The host was amazing, welcoming and accommodating! It was so close to the little town with shops and restaurants! We will for sure be back! Totally worth the price!

Jan’s place is by far the best Airbnb I’ve ever stayed in. Such a cozy home with everything we could ever need and beautiful lake views. Jan made it so easy for us to just roll in and immediately relax. Only wish we could have stayed longer!

We stayed at Anthony’s property for a couple days and it was great. House was clean and cozy and we would definitely recommend this property to anyone that is visiting the area. Thank you Anthony for a great stay!

We love Molly’s little cottage on their wonderful farm. It is so peaceful and the surrounding area is so beautiful and private. I don’t think we’ve ever stayed in a more well equipped kitchen….anything you could possibly need is provided! The hosts are so friendly and responsive, while also completely respecting your privacy. We definitely hope to stay again in the future. Truly one of our favorite airbnbs! =)

Perfect location. Very clean. Had everything we needed!!!

We always enjoy our stay at Maria’s!

Matt’s place was perfect for my family and I we enjoyed the privacy while being close to everything we were there to do! Very responsive and made us feel at home will definitely stay again in the future.

We had a wonderful stay at this beautiful lakefront home! The views of Lake Erie were absolutely stunning—sunsets from the porch were a highlight of our trip. The house was spotless, thoughtfully furnished, and had everything we needed for a relaxing getaway. There was plenty of space for our group of six adults and one child, and we especially appreciated the cozy common areas where we could all gather. Janelle was a responsive and gracious host, making check-in and communication seamless. We would absolutely love to return—this home is a true gem in Erie!

Kurt has a cute house! He was also very responsive. Would recommend!

Valerie was fantastic ! Everything about this place was wonderful and we had great communication ! I will be back very soon because my stay was not long enough !

Perfect getaway! The house was great! Had everything we needed. Beautiful scenery. The dock was our favorite thing! House was super clean and comfortable. Amy was a perfect host. Generous, kind and helpful! Would definitely come back!

This cottage was a fantastic place to stay! It is actually bigger than the photos look (which is the opposite of what usually happens!). There is plenty of space. We booked both the top and bottom units (they can be separated), and it was really nice that the upper level has its own sitting room and kitchen area. Earlier risers could have their own space in the morning without disturbing the later sleepers. There were a ton of amenities provided by the hosts -- cleaning supplies, extra linens, games, beach towels, toys, bikes, a fire pit...the list goes on. It was super helpful to not have had to pack these things. It's walkable to the lake and a Tiki Bar and super close to Hotel Conneaut, which is being renovated and lovely to look at. It was perfect for a long weekend away, and the next time I travel to Conneaut Lake, I would love to book this place again!

Perfect place to stay while attending a bird dog event in Harrisville, PA

Very cute , well decorated, clean, simple decor and relaxing. There really wasn’t a beach. The waters edge was hard to get to. The view was to die for. Saw a ship and a couple of beautiful sunsets. Wish the weather had been warmer to sit out and wash the water and the waves. I felt the price was a little high. To me that was a beach accessible price. Not dissatisfied with the house itself just the water access. I would book again.