Vacation rentals with lake access in Pymatuning Reservoir

We had a wonderful stay at Cheryl’s cottage. It was very homey. Immaculately cleaned. Great decoration. Very comfortable. A very peaceful place to be. Cheryl was extremely responsive and helpful. Excellent host.

Awesome place! Clean, well stocked, comfortable and great location. And Karla and her team were incredibly responsive. The Keurig wouldn’t turn on so we sent her a message, and she had a new one delivered to the house within a half hour early on a Saturday morning. Great for a small family. Would definitely stay again!

Wendy's Lakehouse was exactly what my husband and I needed for our mini-retreat after our daughter's wedding. We were mentally, physically, and emotionally exhausted when we arrived; but after a couple of days of complete quiet and privacy in the house, walking and laying on the private beach, listening to the water, watching the sunsets, and basking in the fresh Lake Erie breezes: we felt restored and refreshed. The only thing that disappointed us was that we couldn't stay longer... life rolls on! 😅 Within hours of our arrival we were making plans to return- next time with our 4 sons- as soon as possible! We even were dreaming about bringing future grandkids in years to come! 🥰 Thank you, Wendy, for providing this peaceful retreat!

We had a great time! Jason is a great communicator and does a great job of making sure that your questions are answered and that you feel at home. We took our own boat with us and the boat dock was nicely set up and easy to use.

We've been staying at Patty's place for years and have never been disappointed. Couldn't ask for anything more. We'll be back again next year.

LOVED this house! Someone with a degree in interior design must’ve been involved in the decorating bc it looked like something out of a magazine. And the view was absolutely stunning. Also, as a mom with small children, I loved how we were right on the water but high enough up from it that I didn’t have to worry about my kids walking into it while playing outside. I also loved the location of this house. We were right in between Ashtabula and Geneva on the Lake so it was a little more peaceful than being right in the middle of GOTL. My family preferred Ashtabula anyways as it had more of that quaint old town charm. The house also had great storage which may sound funny, but I love to unpack and really settle into the home. It seems like so many places don’t provide that anymore. Anyways, I would totally stay here again!

Great value and beautiful home. Photos don't do it justice

Natalia & Benny were very responsive. They immediately responded to all our questions. Great communication. Clean. Would definitely stay here again.

As soon as we walked in the door, we felt immediately at home! This was one of the best Air B&B stays that we have ever encountered! My wife was so impressed with how thoughtful the decor was and the welcome basket was yet another detail that we did not expect. The lake view was beautiful and even though the weather wasn't the best, it was the type of place that you could just relax and spend the day right there. Maripat and Tim were truly "Super Hosts" and it was evident with their home and their great communication. They literally thought of everything that you could possibly need and anything else was pretty close by. We had the most relaxing and stress free getaway that we've had in awhile. If our travels take us back to western NY again, I can guarantee that we will be trying to stay at this beautiful place on the lake. If we could give this 12 stars...we would!

Casey was a fantastical host. I was able to get as much information as needed. the place was stunning and easy to move around

Great location, extremely clean. Perfect for one or two people. Sheetz a short walk away. Breakfast and lunch place right next door. The lake is right behind the building. Responsive and helpful host. We will use it again as we go to Conneaut twice a year.

We were very happy with our stay! The view of the lake is gorgeous so make sure to take advantage of the porch and deck. The porch is private but the deck is communal but we had it all to ourselves. The bathroom is beautifully remodeled and the shower has great water pressure. The bed was comfy and the space was very clean. There were two of us and it was the perfect amount of space. Location wise, it's not far from Geneva On The Lake and a bunch of local wineries. Be prepared to drive though as there aren't any Ubers around. Overall we had an amazing time and would stay here again!

Leanne was very friendly and helpful! She provided eggs, bread, coffee and coffee creamer which made our trip easier! If we had needed supplies, there was a Dollar General close to the rental. The location was beautiful! Thank you!

Great place. Clean. Privacy. Had nearly everything we needed. Will defiantly consider staying there again. Bryan and Jean were very accommodating.

This is the second time I’ve stayed here, very good location. Quiet but not far from essential things! Love it there

Great experience! Great Views! Had everything we needed!

This was our 2nd stay with Brian, we liked it so much. A couple retired hippies who love to fish. There's a great dock and places for your boat, but we chose sitting in the Adirondack chairs at the end of the dock, casting in the sun with a cold brew. Caught bluegill, perch & one bass from those chairs. Tossed em back but we could have shared a nice meal. Saw a muskie ascend (maybe...it was huge!). We saw Eagles, mockingbirds The cottage is well kept, perfectly appointed and original. Actual 2x4 beams, heavy pine doors. Great new flooring, cozy and perfect for 2 with fine linens on the bed and spotless. I love Chautauqua Lake. I needed to get away from the news real life and I thanked my bf profusely for bringing me. Brian's place faces full east and starting your day with this sunrise 🌅 is pure magic. We will be back!

Great cottage! Roomy, comfortable, great location close to I-79. Great communication! Nice big yard either lots lots of chirping birds and bunnies. Plenty of towels, washer and dryer was a real, plus a nice hot water. I would definitely stay again if in this area.

Everything was exactly what we hoped for! Very nice stay, great location, easy access to the lake. Would certainly stay again.

Jan’s place is by far the best Airbnb I’ve ever stayed in. Such a cozy home with everything we could ever need and beautiful lake views. Jan made it so easy for us to just roll in and immediately relax. Only wish we could have stayed longer!

Very cute place to stay and enjoy the view through the dining area window. My friends and I enjoyed playing board games, grilling, and having fires. Lake is swimmable and looks clean but we did not swim with the weather being very cold. Overall a very quaint place to stay with lots of nature (and birds) to take in and enjoy.

House was clean and cozy. The backyard was beautiful with nice grassy area for dog. I stayed M-Th so the bar next door was not busy or noisy. Internet is fast. I had to work a couple days with no issues. Friendly people and good food for small town. Had oysters from Noosa Bistro and coffee from Julbeans. Walked to the Fairport Harbor Lakefront Park everyday. Walked my dog to Veterans Memorial Park. Visited Headland Dunes State Nature Preserve.

We came into town for a wedding at the Lodge, which was SO close to this Airbnb. The Airbnb inside was beautiful and perfectly cozy for what we needed. The outside was a bit confusing, but once I read the directions William sent a few times, I figured it out. The neighbor was very nice and chatty when we arrived, and even put out a candle for us so there would be less bugs when we got back from the rehearsal dinner. Overall, it's a very cute little place to stay, super close to the heart of Geneva, easy to find lots to do from there! I would 100% stay there again.

Perfect location. Very clean. Had everything we needed!!!