Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

We had a wonderful stay at Cheryl’s cottage. It was very homey. Immaculately cleaned. Great decoration. Very comfortable. A very peaceful place to be. Cheryl was extremely responsive and helpful. Excellent host.

I live in Conneaut and booked Nathan's place for my daughter and son-in-law, who were visiting from Italy. The location was perfect since they could walk to the grocery store, bank, thrift store, and the Rainbow Cafe! It's such a quick trip to drive or walk to the Lake that I much preferred having them uptown and close to amenities. The house itself was wonderful and allowed the rest of the family to come hang out, cook, eat, and connect. I've stayed in a lot of AirBnb's and would have to rate this as the cleanest. The rooms are both good sized, the bathroom is huge, and the beds very comfortable. There is just nothing to complain about... from booking to adjusting dates to access to check-out... there were no hiccups. Three snaps up for Nathan's place- I highly recommend it:)

The house is so beautiful and spacious, it was absolutely perfect for our group.

We had such a great time and already cannot wait to come back. The house was extremely clean, had everything you need, and offers the most beautiful and private view of the lake. It has the perfect view of the sunset! Jeff and Anne were extremely responsive if we needed to reach out and made the place feel right at home. There are a ton of areas within the house and around the property to relax and see the lake. Also a quick drive to restaurants and grocery stories and the neighborhood is very quiet and safe, perfect for walks. Would definitely recommend!

We enjoyed the house and beautiful backyard. Loved how convenient everything was as far shopping and restaurants!

Great value and beautiful home. Photos don't do it justice

We really enjoyed our stay at Mark and Pam's home. The checkin instructions and commuications were clear and extremely responsive. The house is well appointed, very quaint and matched the photos. The four bedrooms provided plenty of space. We loved the big porch in the back with a table and chairs for enjoying the evening and our dog loved roaming around in the fenced in backyard. We didn't have any small children with us, but the house had plenty of games for the little ones if needed. Overall it was an enjoyable experience and we would definitely stay there again.

Place was clean and as described. Meeghan was very commutative and responsive.

Ashley was wonderful. We truly enjoyed our accommodations. The cabin was clean and easy to get to. Tons of fun things to do. And an easy five dollar taxi cab to wherever you wanna go.

House was cute and in great quiet neighborhood. Would definitely go there again! Had a few hiccups but management was fast to solve. Would recommend.

The Carriage House is one of the most peaceful places that we've ever stayed. The Rustic character and decor felt welcoming and comfy. The view of the pond in the morning while listening to the birds and drinking a cup of coffee - unbelievably Zen. We enjoyed soaking in the jacuzzi and having a good steam in the Sauna. The quietness was particularly stunning as well. We really felt like we had our own personal Spa for 5 days. I'm from the Knox area and will be staying here from now on whenever we're home for a visit. Our black lab Bella also enjoyed chasing the ball in the big field and going for a swim in the pond as well. Perfect place for a dog! Thank you Maria for sharing this delightfully beautiful place with us!

Wonderful place!! Home has all amenities with huge full windows & high ceilings overlooking the lake in a great small community of 50 private homes with lovely & friendly neighbors. Proximity to Jamestown & Chautauqua institutions was great. Use of bike paths in adjoining Camp Chautauqua(100 acre site with 100 mobile trailer homes & 20 small fixed homes ) was great Also private tennis/pickelball court available at no cost on premises & large pool on adjoining camp property available as well as 2 boat docks.Great & safe for young children as community is private with no through streets & most kids & people use golf carts. There is adjoining campsite playground on lakefront which is great for young children. Bring a boat or kayak along & use Chautauqua institutions nearby for nightly entertainment as well as day lectures , art instruction courses sailing school, variety of day courses & lectures with great theater & opera productions. only 3 miles away.

Great house, really quiet near the woods and grocery stores aren’t too far away. The host was very communicative and helpful with our stay

Sunny's place was great. I loved the hot tub and all the game options. it was serene when it wasn't raining. I can't wait to book again.

We had a wonderful stay! The house was beyond the description. It was beautiful and extra roomy. We had a group of bridesmaids stay here for the weekend as we prepared for a friend’s wedding! Having a bathroom in each room was incredibly helpful for couples to get ready for the wedding. The location was extremely private but also close to Chautauqua Institution where the wedding was held. The host was easy to communicate with and helpful when booking. We would absolutely stay here again!

Michelle was very kind! Her empathy came to the forefront when she allowed us to keep one of our cars parked in the driveway for a few days after check out due to an emergency. If you'd like a quiet getaway with family, this is perfect! We also took a 45-minute car ride to Allegheny National Forest and spent several hours hiking. You can walk to the lake, and the public beach access is only a 15-minute drive (it has a very scenic view). Highly recommend!

This place is a gem in northwestern Pennsylvania. It’s perfect for nature lovers who enjoy birding, flora and fauna identification, outdoor activities like hiking, kayaking, and biking, and for those who want a quiet escape. The quirky decor adds a lively and entertaining touch of nostalgia while being accommodating in every way. Lee and Windle are excellent hosts communicating before, during and after our stay. We enjoyed the wood stove, metal roof and porch as it rained most of our stay but we were kept cozy and comfortable while still being a part of the outdoors. Highly recommended and we will return to check it out during different seasons of the year. Thank you for opening the is space for others to enjoy.

this was our second stay here and certainly not our last. Jessica is an awesome host with a magical cabin. This area is so peaceful and private. The cabin has everything you need to make it a home for your stay. The lake is amazing and we caught so many fish !! You will not regret this cozy cabin ❤️

The lake house was just as described. Private, cleaning and cozy! We would love to stay again.

I was very comfortable in Rob’s place. Great location and convenient to many different activities. I was in town for family activities and this place met all my needs.

Me and my fiance had our little elopement ceremony at Kimberly’s Airbnb, and we could not have had a more beautiful and peaceful stay (: we very much hope to be back as soon as possible

for this being pet friendly, it was kept very well. everything was very clean. I liked having the gates on the porches so that my dogs could enjoy the outdoors without being on a rope. host was very responsive when we had a problem with the door lock. would recommend!

Second time staying at this property but first time in this unit. We loved it! Spacious one bedroom apartment. Excellent king-size bed (can be hard to find). Cute balcony — enjoyed sitting outside with a glass of wine. (Conneaut Cellars nearby!) Pets allowed - lots of green areas to walk. Quiet peaceful surroundings. On-site parking. Love the Lakeshore Diner, bakery, and Vacavi coffee shop — just a few miles away in town. Cute boutiques for shopping. Didn’t make it to Silver Shore restaurant but it serves great seafood. Brew Pub in town as well. Close to Meadville, Greenville, Pymatuning. Highly recommend.

We had a wonderful stay! The layout of the house was perfect for us. Large enough kitchen, dining and family room that we could spend time together, but a whole separate area including TV room, bedroom and bath for seperation at need.