Vacation rentals in Picnic Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Picnic Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
The image captures a tranquil hot tub filled with clear water, positioned on a deck overlooking Georgian Bay. A soft sunset casts a warm glow across the sky, and the silhouettes of a gazebo and dock are visible in the background.
Home in Meaford
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 492 reviews

Beach House Hideaway by The Post Office Motel

This beach house was designed with relaxation and the enjoyment of togetherness in mind. Let your worries melt away as you slip into the warmth of this water side hot tub featuring stunning view across Georgian Bay and up the mountain side, as fresh snow falls around you. The open concept design makes this the perfect place to gather with family and friends w/ walkout waterfront patio and dock access for swimming. 2 min to downtown Meaford, 20 min to Blue Mtn, 1.5 hrs to Tobermory. Hiking Trails

Top guest favorite
The historic Beck House, a striking Victorian structure, stands with a distinctive red faรงade and slate roof. A spacious porch with white railings invites guests, while the well-kept lawn adds to its charm. A wooden sign identifies the property, blending history with a warm welcome.
Apartment in Penetanguishene
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 524 reviews

The Haunted House Apt 302

As you pull into the driveway this 1885 Victorian towers above you, your mouth drops in awe of the size. Up the porch to enter a small front door, a dimly lit winding staircase creaks as you ascend to 3rd floor. Original architecture painted many times over oozes with history. 70 years ago the house was turned into apartments, unloved for many of those years, time has definately taken its tole, yet to the spirits within, their big old house still stands proud and distinguished in all its glory.

Top guest favorite
A modern cottage features a stone exterior with a sloped roof, harmoniously blending into the surrounding forest. A cozy propane fireplace is visible on the patio, which overlooks a gently flowing stream bordered by smooth stones and lush greenery.
Cottage in Southgate
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Luxurious Creek Retreat With Hot Tub

Welcome to this luxury cottage on the water. The perfect place to relax and unwind while listening to the waterfall and babbling brook flowing past only a few feet away. If you're looking for privacy and tranquility along with all the pleasures of a luxury stay then look no further. This property boasts a propane fireplace inside as well as one outside, in-floor heat and A/C. Fully equipped kitchen, two bedrooms with hotel quality mattresses and a bathroom that exudes high-end style and decor.

Guest favorite
Cottage in Tiny
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Ultimate Georgian Bay Vacation Getaway

Come and stay at our beautifully renovated *all-season* beachfront cottage and enjoy a breathtaking panoramic view of Georgian Bay! You'll discover the cottage sitting atop a sand dune, right on one of the most stunning freshwater beaches in the world. This rare location hosts a private covered deck hovering over the white sand, in a beach house closer to the bay than anywhere else around! Summer guests also enjoy use of a heated salt water pool and large resort deck created by Paul Lafrance.

Top guest favorite
A cozy cottage displays vibrant blue siding with a cheerful yellow door. Two yellow chairs are positioned on the welcoming front porch, surrounded by a blanket of fresh snow. Trees provide a natural backdrop, while clouds float gently in the sky above.
Tiny home in Waubaushene
5 out of 5 average rating, 240 reviews

Saltbox by the Bay + Snowshoes/Ski/Snowboard/Vetta

JANUARY AVAILS + Snowshoes + Skiing Welcome to Saltbox by the Bay, your 4-season escape. Perfect for couples, a small family/friends getaway or solo retreat. This vintage cottage is upcycled with luxe amenities. Made for slow living, play boardgames & classic albums & watch sunsets over the bay. Explore winter in cottage country: borrow our snowshoes for a trek, visit Quayle's Brewery, pamper yourself at Vetta Nordic Spa, ski/snowboard Mount St. Louis or head into town for dinner & bowling.

Top guest favorite
A modern two-story house is framed by tall trees, set against a backdrop of warm sunset hues. A stone driveway leads to the entrance, which is adorned with welcoming plants and porch lighting, creating an inviting entryway into the home.
Cabin in Huntsville
5 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Cozy Cabin with hot tub, Sauna, hot yoga studio.

Welcome to Dโ€™oro Point overlooking Mary lake. We invite you to come relax, restore, and reconnect with nature on our 7.5 acres of wooded bliss. With only an approx 3 minute walk to our quaint neighbourhood beach, we are close enough to enjoy the lively lake life, yet maintain a private retreat feel. Stay on property and reap the health benefits of our private spa like amenities, which include the sauna, infrared hot yoga studio, and hot tub. Or, go out and explore all Muskoka has to offer.

Top guest favorite
A modern cottage is set against a backdrop of tall trees, featuring a large wraparound deck illuminated by warm lights. A fire pit sits on a granite outcrop, surrounded by outdoor chairs. The peaceful evening sky casts a calm ambiance over the scene.
Cottage in Bracebridge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Tiny Luxury Cottage with Hot Tub

This tiny luxury 2 bedroom cottage with loft is perfect for a romantic couple or small family getaway. Nestled on 1.5 acres among majestic trees and granite outcrops, creates beautiful views from the deck with BBQ, fire pit, hot tub or massive windows throughout the cottage. Water dam and river across the road create relaxing waterfall sounds that are heard from deck or enjoy it close up from the private shoreline deck and dock. Explore the Muskoka River on the kayak, SUP or river tubes.

Top guest favorite
A handcrafted timber frame cabin is set among trees, featuring natural wood siding and large windows that invite the outdoors in. A welcoming porch is accessed by a wooden staircase, while a covered area to the side provides shelter. The surrounding forest complements the rustic design.
Cabin in Bracebridge
5 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews

Secluded Lakeside Retreat - Atkins Hideaway

Tucked in the heart of Muskoka, this handcrafted timber frame cabin rests alongside a scenic spring-fed lake, surrounded by 8 acres of private forest. Only 10 minutes from Bracebridge, enjoy serene lake life and natural beauty while remaining close to town amenities, local shops, and eateries. Enjoy private dock relaxation, cozy cabin comforts, and outdoor fires. A Provincial Park Day Pass is included (*security deposit required) for added adventure. Come relax, recharge and reconnect.

Guest favorite
An aerial view showcases the geodesic dome nestled within a vibrant forest. Surrounding greenery creates a serene natural setting, while warm outdoor lights illuminate the deck area. The dome is positioned near relaxation spots, including seating and a hot tub, highlighting the private and tranquil escape.
Dome in Port Perry
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 722 reviews

South Geodome - Birchwood Luxury Camping

Located one hour from Toronto, Birchwood is a luxury camping experience for two. Immersed in a private forest on Scugog Island, our geodesic dome allows for a cozy and relaxing getaway. Enjoy the surrounding landscape and check out local shops and restaurants on Port Perry main street. Our geodome is designed for 2 guests however, a group 3 adults are welcome. Additional guests must be 12+ and added to your reservation at the time of booking. We do not allow pets.

Guest favorite
Tiny home in Reaboro
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

The Pond House - A Cozy Getaway

Sitting on a beautiful spring fed pond, The Pond House is the perfect peaceful getaway in nature during all seasons! Experience the private wood fired sauna, beautiful sunsets, sit beneath the glistening stars, have a bonfire as the water trickles by, cuddle up and watch awesome movies, swing in the outdoor hammock, make a memorable meal, enjoy the private screened in log cabin pavilion, and much more! Book now and make some memories with a loved one or friend!

Top guest favorite
Two wooden Adirondack chairs are positioned on a lush green lawn facing the water, framed by overhanging tree branches. The sunset creates a colorful display on the horizon, reflecting on the calm surface of the lake, while a small table holds a wine bottle and glasses.
Guesthouse in Victoria Harbour
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 284 reviews

Sunset Beach Cottage

Part log treehouse, part beach house and 100% of what you need to enjoy a peaceful getaway only 1.5 hours from Toronto! Walk up the private staircase and pause to enjoy the spectacular treetop and waterfront views from your own wraparound deck before entering your 900 sq. ft. oasis. Enjoy access to your own lawn, picnic table and beach* area and all that Georgian Bay and the area has to offer. *water levels fluctuate Insta: sunset_beach_cottage_canada

Top guest favorite
A stone patio leads to a sandy beach, featuring a seating area with red chairs overlooking Georgian Bay. The calm water is visible in the background, framed by trees and large rocks, with yellow kayaks positioned along the shore.
Cottage in Tiny
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Beautiful Beachfront Cottage.

Township of Tiny License Number: STRTT-2026-110 Enjoy our all-season paradise only 1.5 hours north of Toronto! In summer, enjoy the sandy beach waterfront with incredible views of Georgian Bay with the Town of Penetanguishene, and all its historic charm, only 20 minutes away! In winter, enjoy all the area has to offer with incredible OFSC groomed snowmobile trails and amazing ski resorts less than an hour away! *Contract to be sent and signed prior to stay.

Popular amenities for Picnic Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. Canada
  3. Ontario
  4. Muskoka
  5. Picnic Island