Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Orleans County

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Orleans County

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Waterport

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Oak Orchard Bliss: Angler’s Haven & Family Oasis

Welcome to Crooked Creek Property! There is so much to love about this cozy cottage right on Oak Orchard River. Let yourself in with the high-tech Nest keypad and get to enjoying the huge wrap-around deck that overlooks the Oak Orchard River. The property provides privacy and offers direct access to the River via a private walking path down the river bank. Enjoy your time on the creek fishing, kayaking, canoeing, swimming, or just enjoying the beauty of nature. We have Kayaks available to rent!

Superhost

Home in Kendall

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

LIC'D N.Y. LakeHouse HotTub-Gameroom-Pets-Lake Ont

WINTER & SUMMER - LIC'D DREAM LAKEHOUSE - PET FRIENDLY - HOT TUB - 3+ BEDROOMS with 100ft WATERFRONT, WATER ACCESS NATURAL STONE STAIRS. 2 mainfloor KING BDRMS & 3RD LOFT BDRM with 2 QUEEN BEDS & BUNKBED. WALKOUT GAMEROOM, LAUNDRY, FIRE PLACE & 3 futon COUCHES. FREE WiFi-TEL. bring screaming devices. 15 MIN DRIVE S/E TO TOWN OF BROCKPORT.. FIND GROCERY, WALMART, RESTAURANTS, BARS, AND LIQUOR STORES. 75 MINS FROM NIAGARA FALLS 5 MINS EAST TO HAMLIN PUBLIC BEACH 30 MINS EAST TO ROCHESTER

Superhost

Home in Waterport

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Beautiful Home Minutes From Lake Ontario fishing

Freshly remodeled, fully furnished, four bedroom home in a country setting close to Lake Ontario's famed fishing locations. Two story, open floor plan. First floor Kitchen, living room, dining room, bathroom, three bedrooms. One bedroom upstairs. Private large country yard. Only minutes away from Lake Ontario, Lake Alice, and the Oak Orchard River. Great for fishing, boating, kayaking, leisure. Ring video security sys. We are located half way between Rochester and Buffalo/Niagara Falls.

Superhost

Cottage in Lyndonville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

Peaceful cottage on Lake Ontario.

Cottage on Lake Ontario on the waterfront. Firepit and a small pavilion. Enclosed porch with large picnic table. Recliner chair. Enters into kitchen with counter height dining area. Dishwasher new. Living room with propane fireplace, new carpet. Sofa and futon provides extra sleeping space. Master bedroom has queen bed, dresser and closets. Second bedroom with double bed, dresser and closet. Third bedroom has bunk twin beds, new carpeting. Bathroom w/shower. Small capacity washer/dryer.

Guest favorite

Home in Medina

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Modern, Amish-Built Farmhouse, 3 bedrooms sleeps 6

Experience rural living in this exquisite 3-bedroom Amish-built home, with custom craftmanship, beautiful woodwork and Amish-built furniture. Perfect for a quiet getaway with gorgeous views of woods, meadows, & farmland, a few miles from restaurants & local attractions. Outdoor enthusiasts: minutes from kayak launches, fishing, apple picking, nature trails, & more. Cozy fireplaces, 3 bedrooms w/ walkout basement for easy access + room to stretch out. Porch + deck to enjoy sunrise + sunset!

Top guest favorite

Home in Albion

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Lakefront property

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. This place is a gem you don't want to miss! Very spacious, comfortable and peaceful. You have your own dock to fish off of, go kayaking or pedal boating. at night relax on a very large porch or roast some marshmallows by the firepit. Close by there are farms you can pick your own fruits/veggies and can shop at local and Amish markets. Only 15 min away is Medina, a charming town with unique attractions to visit. This is the place you want to be!

Home in Waterport

New place to stay

Cottage On The Lake

The perfect peaceful getaway. This newly remodeled Lakefront cottage is an ideal setting to escape the hustle and bustle of life. Rest & recharge while enjoying the beautiful scenery of Lake Ontario with all the indoor comforts you expect. Just an hour drive from both Niagara Falls & Buffalo and less than 45 minutes from Rochester. Enjoy fresh produce & Amish made goods from local farm stands. Food truck & Ice Cream 3 minutes away. Just minutes away from award winning salmon fishing charters.

Superhost

Home in Lyndonville

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

North Star Cottage

Immerse yourself in nature at this tranquil getaway just steps from Lake Ontario. Centrally located between Buffalo, NF, and Rochester, this beautiful cottage offers panoramic views of sunrises and sunsets! Enjoy the spectacular night skies with no light pollution and breathtaking views of Lake Ontario’s stunning blue waters! Gourmet kitchen, newly renovated bathroom, and open floor plan! Master bedroom has panoramic views of the lake! Cottage was featured in Buffalo Spree Magazine Nov. 2023

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Albion

5 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Meli's Home Suite - 1st floor Victorian & Pool!

You and your family will love this peaceful 1880's Victorian Manor, mixed with luxuries of the modern day. The pool is open May - October for paid guests & includes access to the patio and yard as well! Nestled in the rural Lake Ontario Community, featuring Farmers Markets, the Erie Canal, and Unique Local Shops, take a trip back into the 19th Century! You'll enjoy your own private floor with private entrance, and many amenities to offer you a fun and pleasant stay! Contact us today!

Home in Kent

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Beautiful Waterfront Retreat

Welcome to your dream escape on Lake Ontario. This spacious 1,800 sq. ft. lakefront home offers a perfect blend of comfort, charm, and natural beauty. With 3 cozy bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, there’s plenty of room for families, couples, or small groups to relax and reconnect. Enjoy spectacular sunsets on a clear day or the sound of waves crashing against the shore. A short two mile drive from Point Breeze which hosts great restaurants and some of the best salmon fishing in the world.

Guest favorite

Home in Lyndonville

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Lake Ontario waterfront summer home Lyndonville NY

Minimum stay is only 3 nights! Sleeps up to 12 guests. The perfect affordable waterfront getaway, this house sits directly on Lake Ontario, in Orleans County, New York, with a private yard and firepit. We fully sanitize the property in accordance with recommended disinfecting practices before your arrival so you can be safe and worry-free during your stay. We also provide freshly washed linens and towels, so you don’t have to bring your own.

Top guest favorite

Farm stay in Kendall

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Lake View 3 Bedroom Barn

This property is the original barn that was a part of a farm built in the mid 1800's. The 3 bedroom facility is half of the barn, but renters have use of the immediate property surrounding the barn. There are two horses on the property, which is why we cannot accept pets. This is a modern farmhouse where we repurposed many traditional architectural pieces and antiques to maintain the authenticity of the original barn.