Vacation rentals in Keystone Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Keystone Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
An aerial view captures the spacious property set against a backdrop of mature trees and open landscape. The newly remodeled home features a large, dark roof, a garage, and a beautifully constructed outdoor space that includes a regulation-size pickleball court with a blue enclosure.
Home in Cleveland
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Skyline Paradise | Pickleball & Bball |Keystone Lk

Luxury Retreat with Tournament-Grade Pickleball Court Experience this stunning hilltop oasis near Keystone Lake, featuring a brand-new (2025) regulation-size pickleball court with pro lighting, a basketball area, & endless entertainment —cornhole, jumbo Jenga, arcade games, air hockey, foosball & more! • 3,200 sq. ft. on 3.5 acres • Stocked kitchen • 30 min to downtown Tulsa • Three-level deck with breathtaking views • Dog-friendly (3 under 80 lbs, $125 fee) Book now for the ultimate retreat!

Top guest favorite
A winding path leads through an eclectic garden filled with various plants and artistic decorations. Distinctive garden pots, sculptures, and colorful ornaments can be seen throughout the area, creating a unique, inviting atmosphere surrounding the log cabin.
Cabin in Tulsa
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 302 reviews

An Artist's Cozy Log Cabin Minutes From Downtown.

Spend the night in a very Private, Cozy, Eclectic and Historically Imfamous Log Cabin, surrounded by an artist couple's one acre garden. Right by Downtown Tulsa! Located in Historic Owen Park Neighborhood. One of the oldest neighborhoods in Tulsa. Very close to The B.O.K. Arena, Tulsa Ball Park, Cain's Ballroom, Tulsa's Arts District, many restaurants, and the Tulsa Gathering Place. This Cozy cabin is perfect for a couple wanting a relaxing weekend and also a wonderful writer's retreat!

Top guest favorite
A serene lake scene captures a vibrant sunset reflecting on the water, with silhouettes of trees along the shore. Gentle ripples create a shimmering effect, while varied cloud formations enhance the expansive sky filled with warm hues of orange, pink, and blue.
Place to stay in Cleveland
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

The Overlook @ Keystone Lake

Great getaway location! You are entirely to yourself. Overlook is "attached to main house...but not "in" main house. Private entrance, no shared spaces. Very private & tranquil space! Relax in a country setting with "to die for" panoramic views from 90 feet above the water. Wildlife galore, including Bald Eagles. A perfect couples escape, girl’s weekend or some individual solitude ! Covered/enclosed hot tub room with great views. Adults Only! (18+) Check out our “extra amenities!”

Top guest favorite
A scenic aerial view showcases lush green fields and dense wooded areas surrounding a winding river. The landscape displays varied textures and tones, with a light blue sky above, hinting at the peaceful rural setting close to the modern cabin.
Cabin in Pawhuska
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Bridgewater Cabin (Modern/private/in city limits!)

A modern cabin in town! Whether you are looking to relax on the 320sf deck by the house, or walk just a few steps down a wooded path to the platform overlooking Bird Creek, lots of wildlife can be seen. This is the only residence on 4.2 wooded acres, and feels like you’re miles from town. Located 3 minutes drive from downtown Pawhuska. Perfect for a couples weekend, or a quiet getaway. Queen bed in the loft and a queen Murphy bed in the main room. A wilderness retreat within the city limits!

Top guest favorite
A wooden sign displaying 'Prairie's End' is mounted on two sturdy posts, surrounded by lush greenery. The natural wood finish complements the outdoor setting, inviting guests to enter the 40-acre property.
Home in Osage
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Prairie's End

Discover your personal haven at "Prairie's End", a 40-acre property offering unparalleled serenity. Imagine waking up surrounded by nature and enjoying peaceful walks through the trails, watch the deer and multitude of wildlife. The open space provides a queen bed, a couch that converts to a bed, a double air mattress on frame found in the bathroom closet and a single roll-away bed. There is also an event center at the same location that is a communal space for guests or booked separately.

Top guest favorite
A tranquil view of a cottage situated beside a small private lake, surrounded by lush greenery. The calm water reflects the natural scenery, while trees line the shore. The cottage features a wraparound porch, providing a serene and picturesque setting.
Tiny home in Ochelata
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 329 reviews

Private cottage on small lake.

Only 35-40 minutes away from Pawhuska & 15 from Woolaroc, this cottage sits on a small private lake in a gated 65 acre private estate. There are more friendly animals than people at this estate; 29 goats, 8 mini donkeys, 4 horses and more! With a queen sized bed & a small bunk room w/ twin bunks it will comfortably sleep 2 adults & 2 small people. The cottage has a small kitchen w/ a refrigerator, 2 burner stove, microwave, toaster oven, toaster, dishes, etc. A firepit and grill outside.

Top guest favorite
A comfortable living area features a tan leather sofa with orange accent pillows and a matching chaise lounge. A wooden dining table with four chairs is visible. Light wood paneling and flooring contribute to a cozy, natural ambiance. A ceiling fan above offers airflow.
Cabin in Sperry
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 227 reviews

Gunker Ranch / Log Home

Beautiful, genuine true Log Home in the Osage Oklahoma Hills. Quiet, peaceful area with gorgeous sunrises and sunsets! Surrounded by horses, cattle, goats, and many other type farm animals. Excellent roads to cycle on and take leisurely, relaxing drives. Friendly people who enjoy life in the country - just like you will when you arrive! It is a destination of peace and relaxation. Only 15 minutes north of Downtown Tulsa. Easy drive to any part of Tulsa or Osage County.

Top guest favorite
Home in Sand Springs
5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

The Splendid Sanctuary

Your Splendid Sanctuary awaits in this magical escape to the lake! Enjoy 3 acres of spacious land that ends directly at the shore’s edge. The Sanctuary is perfect for any type of getaway or adventure - laugher, rest & relaxation are yours. Large enough for a big family or just a couples getaway. Direct access to the lake provides for kayaking and camp fires at night. Grab some coffee and walk outside the back door and drop in your fishing pole.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a newly remodeled guest house is shown, featuring a rustic red wooden facade with white trim. A welcoming white door is positioned at the front, and a small wooden deck is visible. The surrounding landscape includes open fields and a bright sky.
Guesthouse in Pawhuska
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 262 reviews

Lemmons Lemman - A Charming Country Getaway

Our recently remodeled guest house is nestled in the heart of Osage County countryside, all while being located less than 10 minutes from downtown Pawhuska. Artfully decorated, it features locally handmade furniture along with beautiful woodwork. Guests can enjoy a relaxing evening by the fire pit, receive a peaceful night's rest, and wake up, enjoying a cup of coffee while overlooking the landscape.

Guest favorite
A charming cottage with a light green exterior features a welcoming covered porch, accented by two wooden chairs and vibrant flowers in a planter. A stone walkway leads to the entrance, surrounded by lush grass and trees, offering a spacious outdoor setting.
Cottage in Pawhuska
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 294 reviews

The Cottage at The Lodge at Taylor Ranch

This cozy little cottage used to be our Grandmothers art studio! We upcycled the little building into a place for guests to come relax on the ranch! The cottage is nestled in our tiny RV Park and near our horse and chickens! It has the best view for sunsets over our hay meadow! We have over 200 acres to explore! Bring your fishing gear or ask to borrow ours! We also have 2 Disc Golf Courses as well!

Guest favorite
A geodesic dome is situated on a wooden deck among trees, showcasing its unique triangular windows. A wooden ladder leads up to the entry, and a small outdoor seating area is visible on the deck. Natural surroundings include leaves and shrubs.
Dome in Sand Springs
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

Geodesic Sunset Dome

This cozy geodesic dome has its own private nook overlooking our second pond. Heating and air are a must in Oklahoma and we got you covered so you are comfortable all year long. You also get access to our beautiful outdoor shower and our unique compost toilet for a truly memorable experience. Included in the dome is a mini fridge, microwave, Kuerig coffee, along with bowls, utensils, and towels.

Top guest favorite
A modern farmhouse is set against a backdrop of lush greenery, featuring a covered porch and large windows. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, framed by trees that provide shade, with an open field visible in the distance.
Home in Tulsa
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 228 reviews

The Scissortail Farmhouse - LAND, HOT TUB, horses!

Looking for a serene escape in a convenient location? The Scissortail Farmhouse is a new guest home nestled on the edge of a working regenerative farm that supplies produce to many of our best local restaurants. It is minutes from the airport, downtown, and popular Tulsa attractions. We hope you enjoy our little slice of country that is about as close as you can get to the big city!

Popular amenities for Keystone Lake vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Oklahoma
  4. Keystone Lake