Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Indian Lake Ohio

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Home in Huntsville

Beautiful, Cozy, Island Waterfront!

Welcome to the Minnewauken Minnow! Relax and create some long-lasting memories with the whole family at Indian Lake! Located on Minnewauken Island, our water-front home has everything you need to make your vacation one to remember! The home is under new ownership and has been undergoing significant remodeling (from Oct. 2024 through March 2025). Updated pictures will be continuously added as various areas of the property have had upgrades completed. We'd love to have you as our guests!

5 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

A bright, two-story lakeside home is illuminated by warm yellow light, showcasing large arched windows. The inviting interior is visible, featuring an open layout with a spacious living area and staircase leading to the upper level.

Home in Belle Center

LakeFront/Indian Lake Fire-pit-6 Kayaks-Game Room

😎SUNSET HAVEN🌅 lives up to its name—BREATHTAKING sunsets from the upper boathouse deck await!🤗 This FULLY stocked lakeside retreat offers high-speed WiFi, 6 kayaks, 2 stand-up boards & pedal boat, swimming off the sea-wall & a fire pit🔥to share memories of the day. Inside: TVs w/Spectrum & Sports Package plus Foosball, Arcade & more! Located on IL’s top fishing🎣spot plus dining, bars, trails & beaches are nearby😊—Sunset Haven is truly the ultimate getaway for fun, relaxation & sunsets!🌅

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Waterfront Retreat w/King Bed, Boat Docks & Kayaks

Newly renovated and waterfront! Super cute and charming 2 bedroom cottage, boasts a king in the master, 2 full baths and its own laundry! Just steps away from the water with free dock space with rental. Enjoy your family getaway with your boat or rent one from nearby marinas! Features: Huge deck, king in master, natural light, granite counters, stainless appliances, microwave, dishwasher, gas fire place, grill, gas stove, heat/AC, firepit, near open water private boat docks, kayaks & SUP!

Two individuals relax in comfortable adirondack chairs on a pebbled terrace, facing serene waterfront views. The scene captures a sunny day with scattered clouds and lush greenery lining the shore in the background, creating a peaceful atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Lakefront-Heart of Indian Lake-Memories Start Here

Perfect for making family memories, a retreat with friends, or a romantic getaway. Lakefront with expansive views, outdoor relaxing, indoor coziness, boat tie up at the seawall & nearby restaurants and shops. In addition to all the lake activities, enjoy Mad River Mountain, Marmon Valley Farm, golfing & more. Waterfront home on quiet street near Fox Island Beach/Park. Indoor electric fireplace, outdoor firepit, central heat/ac, full kitchen & coffee bar and W/D onsite. Four seasons of fun!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

A relaxing hot tub is situated on a wooden deck, offering views of the water and sunset. Soft lighting from string lights provides a warm ambiance. Nearby, wooden seating areas and docks are visible, creating an inviting space for outdoor enjoyment.

Cottage in Huntsville

Cozy Cabin on the Lake

Escape to your perfect seasonal getaway—ideal for couples, small families, or anyone craving a cozy retreat by the water. This cabin features two bedrooms plus a loft, sleeping 6 comfortably. Relax in the Hot Tub just steps from the master bedroom, or enjoy movie nights with Wi-Fi, Apple TV, and a DVD player. You’ll also have plenty of firewood for the indoor fireplace and the outdoor firepit. Whether you want to unwind or explore, this cabin has everything you need for a memorable stay.

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

A spacious living area featuring a grey sectional sofa and a round coffee table placed on a textured rug. Large glass doors reveal views of the water, while the walls are accentuated by two tall mirrors. A stylish chair adds to the modern decor.

Home in Russells Point

Roxie's Modern Lakefront House

Stay at our most freshly updated property! Sister to Frankie's Waterfront House and Phoebe's Waterfront Lake House with over (155) VRBO 5-star reviews. Home totally remodel and designed by Columbus parade of homes winner. A high, vaulted ceiling with an open floor plan makes this home feel very spacious. Enjoy the brand new black steel appliances. Watch our 65" flat screen tv and large fireplace. 4 panels, glass-sliding Windor to make the home open to the water. Custom Queen Bunks and Queen

A rustic house is shown on the water's edge, featuring a spacious deck that extends over the water. Various fishing equipment is visible on the deck, and small boats are moored at the dock below. Lush greenery surrounds the structure, enhancing the natural setting.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Water-Front/canal Key West Style Boathouse w/bikes

Great house on north side of Indian Lake. Fish from the patio on ground level and an 800 sq ft deck on the second floor. Stream tv and an antenna. 2 bedrooms 1.5 baths and a full kitchen. Moose and Eagle clubs close by. THIS HOUSE IS ON A WELL AND WATER SMELLS LIKE SULFUR SOMETIMES. IF THIS BOTHERS YOU DO NOT RESERVE. Kayaks and canoes are okay. There is no space for anything larger. Boat ramp 1 block from house. Boats connected to vehicles can be left there overnight. It's never busy.

5 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

A modern cottage is showcased with a turquoise roof, surrounded by greenery. A spacious deck features a seating area with comfortable chairs and a table, while lounge chairs are placed nearby. The setting includes a man-made water channel, enhancing the outdoor appeal.

Cottage in Lakeview

Welcome to No Egrets - Waterfront on Indian Lake

Welcome to your fabulous vacation getaway! Completely renovated with 4 theme rooms created for your enjoyment - Lodge, Disco, Speakeasy, and Bar. Plus a 3 seasons room off the back deck that has a twin day bed and trundle if you want relax near the water. The kitchen is fully equipped with all the luxuries of home. In home laundry, tons of games and so much more. To learn even more about your new fav spot visit NoEgretsOhio dot com. About a mile walk to Froggy's and the Tilton Hilton.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Cottage in Huntsville

Relax Inn - Waterfront Luxury Island Cottage

OPEN YEAR ROUND! Quiet & Cozy Lake House Cottage on Tecumseh Island Channel! Dock included! Perfect get away for groups of all sizes! Best Location on the Lake, Great Views all around! Beautiful remodel, stylish decor. 3 Bedrooms, comfortably sleeps 10! Quartz Counters, Recessed Lighting, Electric Fireplace. Amenities include Sleeper Sectional, 4K HD TVs w ROKU. High-Speed Internet, Keurig Coffee Maker w/ Complimentary K-Cups, Microwave, Refrigerator, Oven/Stove, Fully Furnished Kitchen.

The exterior of the cottage showcases a well-maintained façade with a red roof and light-colored siding. A concrete walkway leads to the front door, framed by landscaped areas featuring green grass and decorative plants. A white Adirondack chair is positioned invitingly in the front yard.

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Sandhill Cottage: Kayaks, Pets, Fenced in yard!

Walk to Fox Island for the beach sunrise, fishing, swimming, kayaking > This cottage is perfect for your Indian Lake getaway! Close to breweries, hiking trails, The Donut Shop, coffee, and restaurants. Fox Island has a wonderful all inclusive playground for kids. Located in quiet residential neighborhood for walks, includes large outdoor space for campfires & fully fenced in yard for pets. We have WIFI, firepit, grill, outdoor seating, and two adult kayaks.

An aerial view captures a lakefront house with a red metal roof and stone accents. A spacious deck is visible, furnished with seating and a table. The property features a private dock extending into the water, surrounded by well-kept grass and nearby residential homes.

5 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

3-Bedroom Lakefront Home with Dock, Kayaks, & SUP!

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally-located Indian Lake house! This is the perfect stay for fun on the water with our kayaks and SUP (stand up paddleboard) ready for use. Be sure to check out Spend-A-Day Marina right across the street for a boat rental that you can pull right up to the dock! Whether you want fun on the water or relaxation indoors, our lakefront home on Willow Isle will be sure to please. :)

A modern cabin exterior is shown, featuring large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. An outdoor patio area includes a dining set and lounge chairs, surrounded by well-maintained grass and a fence. Clear skies enhance the inviting outdoor ambiance.