Cottage vacation rentals in Fish Creek

Absolutely loved our stay at this beautiful Airbnb in Sturgeon Bay! The place was impeccably clean, easy to find, and offered gorgeous facilities that made our stay feel special. The space felt incredibly welcoming and comfortable, with friendly touches throughout that made us feel right at home. The highlight, however, was the unbelievable sunrises—truly breathtaking and worth waking up early for. Highly recommend this gem for anyone visiting Door County

This was such a beautiful cottage to stay in while visiting Door County. I would recommend this stay to anyone! It was so cozy, beautifully decorated and in a very convenient location.

I thought the location and the home were awesome. It was easy to check in and the place was excellent. I would definitely recommend to a friend and stay again.

The cottage was exactly as described and was super comfortable. We had everything we needed to make meals and also having 2 showers was wonderful. Plenty of hot water for all 5 of us to shower after getting home from adventuring. Would recommend this place for a quiet and peaceful stay.

Beautiful home with beautiful views of the lake. We were also treated to incredible views of pelicans! Dozens and dozens of them in the bay just feet from the house—they hung around during our entire stay, and we spent lots of time watching them and kayaking with them. The kayaks and hot tubs were perfect—we also appreciated the fireplace on a chilly night and made breakfast and dinner for our multi-generational family of 6. Beds were comfortable, rooms spacious, decor up to date and the space is very nice. Location is very peaceful, and in the quieter north end of the peninsula. If you are hoping for more of the cute, busier towns with more restaurants and shopping, you’ll want to stay further south—with that said, they aren’t far with a car and I would stay in this area again purely for the beauty of the area. We hope to visit again!

nice place! staff was friendly and the room was cozy. we tried to use the Jacuzzi tub and it was a little dirty but other than that it was a great place to stay.

This place has an unbeatable water view and is very cozy! I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a long weekend getaway in northern Door County that’s close to plenty of things to do!

We absolutely enjoyed our stay at Cottage And Bay. Nestled in the woods, quiet and peaceful was exactly what we wanted and needed for a peaceful getaway. The place was really clean. Loved the games room. Would love to return sometime, maybe in the winter. Would absolutely recommend!

The perfect cottage for a weekend in Fish Creek. One mile drive away from Downtown. The kitchen was stocked with everything you would need. Ceiling fans and extra fans kept the cottage nice and cool. Comfortable beds, cozy space overall. And the privacy of being in the woods was wonderful. We would love to come back again!

Our family had an amazing time here. The location was private and picturesque. The house was perfect in every way and truly gave us the chance to experience the beauty of the location. It was super clean and the hosts were very welcoming and responsive. We will definitely make plans to come back and stay at this house again😁

Great stay, the place was in a perfect location. It was away from the hustle and bustle of near by towns but wasn’t to far where things were not easily assessable. The place was a perfect north woods retreat

Peaceful, cozy cottage with a great view of the lake and gorgeous sunsets. Outdoor space to relax and connect while enjoying a fire and the view. Warm and welcoming indoor spaces. Cottage was clean and well equipped with everything we needed for our stay. Easy to walk to shops and restaurants and convenient by car to great hiking as well as to all the Door County sights! Andrea was very helpful as we prepared for our trip and stayed in touch throughout to make sure we had what we needed and knew how to find local hot spots. Overall fantastic place to stay and we will be back!

For a quick weekend getaway- this is the place! Super easy to get to right from the ferry and still private. The yard is spacious and right off the shore. The dogs loved swimming and all of us loved sitting along the fire to watch the sunset. The place was clean and Shelly was great! Can’t recommend enough

My partner Joey and I loved this air bnb. Hosts were responsive and friendly. We would stay here again. The lake front views with egret birds were amazing! Sunrise/Sunsets beyond spectaculor. Todd xoxo

The Village Cottage fit our needs perfectly for our girls getaway weekend! We loved how walkable the area was and how centrally located the cottage was to everything. A week before our stay, one of our group members unfortunately broke her femur and had to use a walker to get into the cottage. Fortunately, the cottage was very accessible with the exception of the gravel path up to the back door (the only entrance she, due to stairs, could use to get in and out). We had an absolute wonderful time!

We had a great weekend get away in this hidden cottage. We were actually upgraded to the main house for a very reasonable rate. The house was clean, spacious and very comfortable. We will definitely be looking at this property for our next trip to Door County.

My husband, toddler, dog, and I loved our stay here. The sunsets here were so beautiful! The cottage felt like home & all the antique decor added so much charm. Check in was easy & Alexandra provided a lot of information on what to do in Door County.

April’s place was exactly as described! So peaceful and tranquil. Very clean and extremely comfortable bed! It was nice to “disconnect” while there. Would definitely recommend!!! 5⭐️’s

First off -- this place already goes beyond expectations on the things you would expect from your airbnb stay: it's clean, it's easy to get inside, host communicates well, comfortable beds, etc. etc. But for the unexpected... it's the charm of this little cottage that had us totally smitten. It was the first time in a really long time that I stayed in an airbnb that didn't feel like some cold-sterile-side-hustle from some rando. This place is the real deal... the pictures are too understated. It looks like an old place, but you know that Pam has put in the work to make this place feel comfortable for her guests. Wifi is spotty, but man, it got us off our phones and connected with nature, and each other. If you're looking to connect with your friends and/or fam and have an outstanding green bay view to wake up to every morning and sunsets to mesmerize you every evening, you can't go wrong wit this place. Thanks Pam -- you're a star!!

This little cabin is my idea of heaven. Right on a small lake near the end of a road so there's no traffic noise. I spent a perfect May afternoon outside with a book and the company of SO many birds. Among others, I heard and saw my first Sandhill cranes- so interesting and loud! Heather was responsive to any inquiries I had and provided a nice snack basket and a stack of maps and brochures for local attractions. There is everything you need for an extended stay, and I would have stayed much much longer if I could have! There are kayaks available and exploring the lakes would have been a real treat if I'd had more time. I will go back someday.

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Gwen’s place. We were just steps away from the beautiful, peaceful lake, a brand new pier, and the pretty fire pit. The house is full of games, books, and puzzles. The shared shed is full of life vests, kayaks, etc. We brought our dog and there was a very thoughtful welcome basket for him! He also loved his stay. The lake is shallow in front of the cabin so it was not good for fishing off the pier, but our boys still loved trying. Ellison bay is a short, 7 min drive away. We went to the Mink River Basin for dinner. The kids loved the arcade games. Newport State Park Beach is also very close and gorgeous! Lots of trails to hike. We would definitely stay here again.

This cottage is cozy and comfortable. Somehow you feel completely surrounded by woods while simultaneously in walking distance to coffee. Meg is a delightful host.