Cottage vacation rentals in Fair Haven

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Quick stats about cottage rentals in Fair Haven

Nightly prices starting at
Fair Haven vacation rentals start at G$35,544 GYD per night before taxes and fees
Verified guest reviews
Over 200 verified reviews to help you choose
Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Fair Haven rentals
4.8 Average rating
Fair Haven stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!

Top-rated cottage rentals in Fair Haven

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

A single-story cottage in light blue exterior paint is surrounded by lush greenery and trees. A wooden fence is present in the foreground, leading to a grassy yard. The peaceful water is visible in the background, enhancing the serene setting.

Cottage in Wolcott

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Grandma's Cottage, Fair Haven NY

This cozy waterfront cottage is furnished with all the basic necessities including towels, bedding and kitchen utensils. The yard has a nice mix of sun & shade overlooking the water. Picnic table, outdoor chairs, fire pit & gas grill are provided. A large floating dock adds another dimension to the space. It is located on a one lane, private road, that extends to the Blind Sodus Bay peninsula. You will be surrounded by water and wildlife. The neighborhood is peaceful and relaxing. Pet fee $50ea.

Top guest favorite

A charming cottage exterior is depicted, featuring cream-colored siding and a blue front door. A small wooden deck leads to the entrance. Outdoor seating is visible, with a table and umbrella set on a grassy lawn. Trees and a paved driveway complete the serene setting.

Cottage in Sodus Point

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Bayside Getaway

Relax at the Getaway, overlooking Ontario's Great Sodus Bay. Perfect for golfing, fishing, beach-going, boating, apple-picking, hiking, or simply... getting away. Adjacent to Sodus Bay Heights Golf Club. Short drive to Sodus Bay Beach, Beechwood and Chimney Bluff state parks, and many public and private lake access points. (All access requires driving.) Weekly Saturday-to-Saturday bookings only in summer. Additional nearby accommodations are available for larger groups. Message us if interested

Guest favorite

An A-frame cottage is framed by lush greenery, featuring a dark wood exterior with a centrally located white door. An overhanging carport provides coverage for vehicles, while hanging planters add a touch of color to the entrance. A pathway leads to the cozy front yard.

Cottage in Sandy Creek

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 354 reviews

🌙 Olde Salem A-Frame Cottage 🔮 near Lake Ontario

You are steps away from witnessing the greatest sunsets along North Sandy Pond (across from Lake Ontario) when you stay at our relaxing, unique, and cozy A-frame - inspired by all things magical and earthy. Sit by the backyard fire, sip coffee by the electric fireplace, read a book in the bedroom nook, play board games, dance in the kitchen, and enjoy four seasons of nearby activities such as fishing, kayaking, boating, jet skiing, hiking, swimming, ice fishing, snowmobiling, and snowshoeing.

Guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story home is shown, featuring a spacious deck with wooden railings. Seating areas are visible, along with a decorative umbrella. The lake is positioned in the background, showcasing expansive water views and a clear sky with scattered clouds.

Cottage in Seneca Falls

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

FingerLakes Spectacular Cayuga Lake Best Location!

Lake Front on Cayuga Lake with GREAT views, a SUPER Deck, 2 Private Bedrooms, and 2 full bathrooms. The lake views are spectacular. Welcome to the heart of New York State Finger Lakes. Wake up to the gorgeous amazing sunrises. Enjoy the Dock on the water. Walk to the Cayuga State Park with beach, playground, boat launch, more! Enjoy unforgettable full moons or make all the wishes you want by spotting falling stars at night from our unobstructed deck. Up to 4 people No boaters

Superhost

The exterior of a spacious lake cottage is visible, featuring a light green facade and multiple large windows. A small garden area is adorned with blooming flowers and outdoor seating. A sign indicates 'Parking Only' for the lake cottage, emphasizing its dedicated space.

Cottage in Skaneateles

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

Skaneateles Lake Cottage - Private Retreat!

The summertime on Skaneateles Lake awaits our next guests! Reserve a week or a weekend to enjoy Lake Life and Summer in Skaneateles! Looking to book an extended stay or a short romantic getaway? Enjoy all the comforts of home in this remodeled and very spacious lake cottage. Just a short stroll down a private path to your own lake front with spectacular views. Complete with a huge master bedroom with partial lake views and ensuite bathroom! Don’t delay reserve our lake cottage today!

Top guest favorite

A waterfront cottage is visible from the dock, surrounded by trees and a manicured lawn. A paddle boat is secured at the dock, and colorful lounge chairs are arranged along the shore. Two kayaks are also visible, adding to the outdoor recreational space.

Cottage in Jordan

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Rivers' Edge Retreat: A Private Waterfront Cottage

Relax at this charming waterfront retreat on the scenic Seneca River. Nestled in Central New York, this two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage blends comfort with character—featuring nautical décor, a soaring two-story living room, cozy lofted bedroom, and sleeping space for up to five guests. Spend your days by the fire pit, soaking in river views, or adventuring with direct access to Cross Lake. Whether you paddle, fish, or swim, this private getaway is perfect for making lasting memories.

Top guest favorite

The open-concept living area features large windows offering views of Lake Ontario. A spacious seating arrangement includes a cozy armchair and a sofa. A dining table is positioned nearby, and a Smart TV is visible against a rustic shelf. Natural light fills the space.

Cottage in Pulaski

5 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Cozy 3-Br Lake Ontario cottage with sunset views

Our 3-bedroom lakefront cottage is the perfect gathering place for fishing groups, friends, and family to relax and make memories. Located right on Lake Ontario, and just 10 minutes from the mouth of the Salmon River, our family camp offers an open concept gathering space and lakefront deck outside, where you'll enjoy picture perfect sunsets. Stocked with linens, towels, full kitchen, WiFi, a Smart TV, washer/dryer and more, we make it easy to unwind after a day of exploring. Welcome!

Guest favorite

A warm, inviting living space features a rustic brick fireplace with a crackling fire, surrounded by a wooden rocking chair and a decorated Christmas tree adorned with twinkling lights. The wooden walls and warm tones create a cozy atmosphere.

Cottage in Lyons

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 501 reviews

Peppermint Cottage

Nestled in peaceful Upstate N.Y., between Finger Lakes Wine Country and Lake Ontario and right in the heart of the Erie Canal is the Peppermint Cottage. The Peppermint Cottage is a unique destination. The Peppermint Cottage is a place for guests to “Step Back in Time” and experience the simple pleasures of life including a warm fire, relaxing under the stars in a hot tub, sauna or strolling our gardens. Family friendly establishment. Birders, bicyclists and outdoor enthusiasts welcome.

Guest favorite

An open-plan living space features a red sofa and a patterned rug, creating a cozy seating area. The kitchen, equipped with modern appliances and a breakfast bar with white stools, is bathed in natural light from large windows. A dining table is set for meals.

Cottage in Sterling

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Lakeview cottage- perfect wedding/fall stay

Enjoy Fair Haven, NY at this sunny and cheerful, family friendly cottage. A spacious, open living space welcomes you when you walk in the door. Three bedrooms and two full bathrooms comfortably accomodate up to seven guests. Backing to woods, across a small lane from the bay, you'll enjoy privacy and nature from every room. Walk to marinas, Colloca Winery, Turtle Cove, and the King Street public boat launch, and enjoy all the recreation and dining options around Little Sodus Bay.

Top guest favorite

A spacious deck with two dark wooden chairs overlooks a serene beach scene. A cup rests on a small table, and beyond, two colorful lounge chairs are positioned on the sandy shore. The calm waters of Lake Ontario reflect a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Sterling

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Wes Anderson Lake Cottage | Beach, Deck & Kayaks

Escape to our Wes Anderson stylish, solar-powered lakefront cottage on Lake Ontario with private beach, stunning sunsets, and room for families or friends to unwind. Just 10 minutes from Fair Haven, this 3-bedroom, 2 bath retreat is perfect for beach days, cozy nights, and peaceful weekend getaways. Wake up to lake views, relax on the private beach, and explore Upstate New York's scenic wonders. Wander bluffs, swim in the lake, stroll along the beach, or unwind on the lakeside deck.

Top guest favorite

A modern cottage exterior is presented, featuring a blue facade with white trim and a peaked roof. The property is surrounded by a well-maintained lawn, with a patio area equipped with outdoor seating. Flower beds add a touch of color near the entrance.

Cottage in Sodus Point

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Jameson Bay Inn on Sodus Bay (Waterfront)

The Jameson Bay Inn is a completely remodeled cottage which sits on Sodus Bay. This upscale cottage has ample parking, all of the amenities your family may need while on vacation, and gorgeous views of Sodus Bay. The large master bedroom even has views of Lake Ontario! The Jameson Bay Inn includes dock space for a boat, jetskis, and/or kayaks - great for fishing! There is also a beautiful patio only steps away from the water where you can enjoy watching boats and wildlife.

Top guest favorite

A pathway lined with greenery leads to a serene lakefront view. On either side, charming white structures are framed by trees, while the blue water sparkles in the background. A gently manicured lawn offers a peaceful setting for relaxation.

Cottage in Skaneateles

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Skaneateles Lakeside Cottage

Quaint & cozy private lakefront cottage on East side of Skaneateles Lake. Gorgeous views! Magnificent sunsets!! key location! Short Boat ride or drive to village (2.9 mi) and all attractions. Cottage is on a 1 acre 185ft lakefront property shared with the owner. Dock for lake access. 2 kayaks and life jackets available to enjoy the lake. Water shoes a must as lake bottom is rocky. No children. No pets. There are 2 Friendly and Fluffy Australian Shepherds on the property.