Vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

A wooden dock extends over clear blue water, leading to a small white boat. Sandy beach chairs are positioned on the shore, surrounded by lush palm trees and tropical vegetation. The tranquil scene is complemented by gentle waves lapping against the rocks.

Home in George Town

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Aqua Sound - Luxury Villa w/ Private Pool, Beach and Dock

Aqua Sound is situated on the clear waters of Master Harbour, directly on the beach. Twenty-two feet of glass doors and windows across the open concept living and dining rooms frame the stunning view of the bay. Our spectacular terrace, which has ceiling fans and is also shaded by a traditional Bahamian roof, creates the perfect spot for watching the boats sail en route to George Town or just relaxing in the breeze with a good book. The garden has palm trees, oleander, hibiscus and other wonderful tropical plants which are illuminated at night, as is the heated pool. The entire house is air conditioned and has ceiling fans throughout. It has an open plan living room and dining room which have wonderful views of the bay. There is a very comfortable living room set as well as a TV, stereo, games, puzzles and books. The Dining Room seats 6 people comfortably and has a convenient hatch through to the kitchen. The kitchen is fully equipped with a large fridge freezer, oven, microwave, wine cooler, electric kettle, toaster, ice cream maker, and mixer. There is a washer and dryer in the 'wash house' next door. The house consists of 4 ensuite bedrooms.The master suite at the west end of the house is furnished with a king bed, closet, large shower and bath, WC and hairdryer. This room boasts a spectacular view of the bay and Crab Cay and has direct access to the terrace and swimming pool. The guest bedrooms each have two separate twin beds, shower and bath, WC and hairdryer. They both have large closets for storage. The terrace runs the full length of the ocean side of the house. You can enjoy a meal at the large outdoor dining table in the evening or lounge on the deck chairs. The private garden has an abundance of tropical plants (hibiscus, palms, oleander etc.)and also a large paved area for sitting around the pool. The garden and pool can both be lit up at night.The heated pool is a fabulous luxury! It is perfect for jumping into first thing in the morning, refreshing during the day and wonderful for cooling off in the evening while it's lit up!

Guest favorite

Underwater scene showcases a sandy ocean floor adorned with various seashells, including conch and scallop shells. A starfish with pronounced arms lies prominently, while a small fish is visible swimming nearby, creating a serene aquatic tableau.

Apartment in Great Exuma

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Luxury Streetview Apartment #4, Georgetown Exuma

In the heart of downtown Georgetown, Exuma ♥️ Our bright & beautiful luxury apartment on a budget!! Streetview 2nd floor apartment. A super affordable & well appointed luxury vacation home!! Includes A/C, wifi, living room tv, full kitchen, bathroom & streetview outdoor area looking out over Georgetown. Everything you need to have an amazing budget vacation in one of the most beautiful places on Earth! Upon booking we send you a great welcome package that includes tons of Island recommendations ☺️

Top guest favorite

A modern beach cottage is positioned on a ridge overlooking a secluded beach. The structure features large windows and a wrap-around deck, surrounded by lush greenery and distinctive rocky outcrops, with gentle waves lapping against the sandy shoreline in the foreground.

Cottage in Little Exuma Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Modern Beach Cottage

Modern Beach Cottage Located on Little Exuma, Thatch Bay Cottage is on a secluded beach offering incredible privacy. The perfect spot for a quiet, stress-free getaway. The cottage is set on a ridge to capture the ocean breeze and unparalleled views of the clear turquoise water. Sitting on the wrap-around deck you can enjoy coffee at sunrise, sun during the day, sunsets at dinner, and stargazing at night. *** Holiday weeks (US Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's) require a 7-night stay ***

Guest favorite

A modern beachfront home is positioned in a secluded area, with vibrant turquoise waters visible in the background. Lush greenery and sandy beach surround the property, creating a peaceful atmosphere. The home features a light exterior with yellow accents, blending harmoniously with the natural landscape.

Home in Great Exuma Island

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews

Beachfront Bliss For Your Ultimate Vacation

This beach house is a secluded + modern beachfront vacation rental property w/awesome views of the most beautiful waters in the world! *Listed rate is for access to TWO BEDROOMS ONLY. (King & Queen bdrm) 3rd Bdrm w/ the 2 twin beds is addl $100 per night. Select more than 4 guests for rate. Airbnb will not allow us to list separately* Disconnect from the world on a quiet beach. Check out the reviews Located across from pig beach.Local restaurant is short beach walk for buffet & rent kayaks.

Superhost

A dining area is set with blue and yellow tableware, featuring a wooden table and chairs. Natural light enters through a window, illuminating the kitchenette with white cabinetry. An open door reveals a scenic view of turquoise waters and boats, enhancing the coastal ambiance.

Cottage in Black Point

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Cool Cozy Cottage Book Your Winter Getaway Now!

Our Cool Cozy and comfortable one bedroom cottage .It has a true island coastal feeling ,it is situated on the water and has a dock at your front door it is walking distance to resturants, food stores, night life etc. It is 20 mins from Pig Island where the Famous Swimming Pigs resides. Getting here one would have to fly into Nassau Bahamas then take Flamingo Air or Titanair from Nassau into Black Point Exuma Cays. Please bring some cash along. There is no atm or bank here on the island.

Top guest favorite

A patio area is shown overlooking the turquoise ocean, with a dining table and chairs set for four. Two lounge chairs are positioned next to a small, vibrant area rug. Tropical palm trees frame the scene of a private beach in the background.

Home in Rokers Point Settlement

5 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Paradise Point Ocean Front Home-Close to Airport

Welcome to Paradise! The islands of Exuma is like no other in the Bahamas. Paradise Point is a 2Bedroom/2Bath Oceanfront home w/beautiful private beach located just 2 miles from the airport & close to Georgetown. The house has a main bedroom&bathroom, and has a 2nd bedroom & bathroom in the lower level accessed from a separate entrance. The island of Exuma is the Bahamas most beautiful, friendly&safest. There is endless possibilities of how to spend your days in paradise making memories.

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is nestled on a rocky rise, framed by lush green shrubbery. The house features a covered porch supported by decorative columns, offering a welcoming entryway. The surrounding area displays a mix of sandy ground and stone pathways, providing a tropical coastal ambiance.

Home in Staniel Cay

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Heidi's Retreat

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Heidi's Retreat offers a serene escape on Staniel Cay, Exuma. Enjoy well-appointed bedrooms adorned with island-themed paintings. Relax on the porch after a day of swimming with the pigs or exploring the island’s beautiful beaches. Nestled among lush coco plum and seagrape trees, each stay includes a delightful welcome box filled with Bahamian treats. Experience the perfect blend of comfort and adventure for unforgettable memories.

Superhost

A private home is set on stilts, with a vibrant red exterior and multiple large windows. A wraparound deck is supported by wooden railings, offering views of the surrounding landscape. Tropical plants add a natural element to the entrance.

Villa in Staniel Cay

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Ruby - Ocean view with privacy

Relax with the whole family at a private home that is within steps of secluded beaches. Amazing location and a great place to unwind or enjoy the gorgeous beach and blue water in privacy. This home boasts (2) ensuite bedrooms and bathrooms plus a 360 degree viewing loft which can be used as a 3rd bedroom. Situated on almost 3 acres. A boat + golf cart referral can be provided if you are interested. The land, sea & sky are nothing short of intoxicating in this island paradise.

Guest favorite

A waterfront home is positioned on a sandy beach, surrounded by lush greenery. The two-story building features a spacious deck and large windows, allowing ample natural light. Outdoor seating areas are visible, providing inviting spots to relax and enjoy the beautiful shoreline.

Home in George Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Shoreline Flats

Shoreline Flats: A Waterfront Escape on Bonefish Flats Your dream escape in Great Exuma! This newly renovated 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home is perched right on the pristine bonefish flats. Our beachside escape offers breathtaking views of turquoise waters and powdery white sand just steps from your door. Our outdoor seating area invites you to sip morning coffee as the sun rises or enjoy a starlit evening after watching the sunset over the water with the gentle sounds of the waves.

Top guest favorite

A blue exterior of the villa is highlighted by a covered porch area. A white door with sidelights is framed by two windows. A single chair is positioned on the spacious deck, with ambient light softly illuminating the entrance.

Home in Staniel Cay

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

The Good Life: Private Elevated Villa

Come enjoy the peace and tranquility of Staniel Cay, Exuma! After visiting the swimming pigs, relax in the comfort of this fully air conditioned villa. This 2 bed / 2 bath offers a fully equipped kitchen feathering stainless steel appliances with granite counter tops. Other amenities include Satellite television, internet, and washer. At the end of the day, enjoy the sunset from the wrap around deck or take an evening stroll on the beautiful beaches that are in walking distance!

Guest favorite

A modern entertainment unit features a wide television displaying a serene beach scene with stacked stones and tropical flowers. Below, a decorative blue vase adds a pop of color, while the unit includes open shelving for storage.

Villa in George Town

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Ocean Mist Villa - George Town, Exuma

Enjoy sitting on the patio over looking the ocean, having a few drinks and enjoying the nice fresh calming air blowing on your skin and blowing through your hair. (At night times are even better.) Grab a free Kayak and go exploring over the beautiful turquoise waters. Family time got even better. There's marina located on the property with a boat that you can rent and its discounted for guest. Once you stay at Ocean Mist Villa you'll not want to leave. Book Today!

Guest favorite

A beachfront cottage is positioned above clear turquoise waters, surrounded by tropical vegetation. A wraparound deck provides a panoramic view of the cays and sandbars. Sun loungers are visible on the sandy beach, accessible via a gentle slope from the cottage.

Home in George Town

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

The Best Views are the ones we share with you.

SOUTHSIDE COTTAGE Close to Everything - Far from Everyone! $400/Night No Cleaning Fee 2 Guests Maximum Occupancy Overlooking the crystal clear water and surrounding cays, centrally located on the south side of Great Exuma, this contemporary beachfront cottage is a lovely island retreat. The cottage is located a short 4 mile drive to George Town where you will find grocers, restaurants, shops, marinas and healthcare facilities.