Vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Underwater scene showcases a sandy ocean floor adorned with various seashells, including conch and scallop shells. A starfish with pronounced arms lies prominently, while a small fish is visible swimming nearby, creating a serene aquatic tableau.

Apartment in Great Exuma

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Luxury Streetview Apartment #4, Georgetown Exuma

In the heart of downtown Georgetown, Exuma ♥️ Our bright & beautiful luxury apartment on a budget!! Streetview 2nd floor apartment. A super affordable & well appointed luxury vacation home!! Includes A/C, wifi, living room tv, full kitchen, bathroom & streetview outdoor area looking out over Georgetown. Everything you need to have an amazing budget vacation in one of the most beautiful places on Earth! Upon booking we send you a great welcome package that includes tons of Island recommendations ☺️

Guest favorite

A modern beachfront home is positioned in a secluded area, with vibrant turquoise waters visible in the background. Lush greenery and sandy beach surround the property, creating a peaceful atmosphere. The home features a light exterior with yellow accents, blending harmoniously with the natural landscape.

Home in Great Exuma Island

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Beachfront Bliss For Your Ultimate Vacation

This beach house is a secluded + modern beachfront vacation rental property w/awesome views of the most beautiful waters in the world! *Listed rate is for access to TWO BEDROOMS ONLY. (King & Queen bdrm) 3rd Bdrm w/ the 2 twin beds is addl $100 per night. Select more than 4 guests for rate. Airbnb will not allow us to list separately* Disconnect from the world on a quiet beach. Check out the reviews Located across from pig beach.Local restaurant is short beach walk for buffet & rent kayaks.

Guest favorite

The elevated cottage features a vibrant blue exterior with white railings and a spacious staircase leading to the entrance. Surrounded by natural landscaping, the structure overlooks tranquil waters, providing a peaceful setting in a coastal environment.

Cottage in George Town

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

Blue Hole Lodge

This new construction waterfront cottage has a 100ft Blue Hole in the backyard and overlooks a world class bonefish flat where you can watch them tail from the balcony. Built up on stilts, enjoy the countless shades of Exuma blues from every room and keep an eye out for the turtles in the lagoon! With 1 Bedroom and 1 Bathroom, you can comfortably sleep 4 people utilizing the pullout couch in the living room. Launch the kayak or paddleboard right from the backyard and enjoy the Exuma waters.

Superhost

A dining area is set with blue and yellow tableware, featuring a wooden table and chairs. Natural light enters through a window, illuminating the kitchenette with white cabinetry. An open door reveals a scenic view of turquoise waters and boats, enhancing the coastal ambiance.

Cottage in Black Point

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Cool Cozy Cottage Book Your Winter Getaway Now!

Our Cool Cozy and comfortable one bedroom cottage .It has a true island coastal feeling ,it is situated on the water and has a dock at your front door it is walking distance to resturants, food stores, night life etc. It is 20 mins from Pig Island where the Famous Swimming Pigs resides. Getting here one would have to fly into Nassau Bahamas then take Flamingo Air or Titanair from Nassau into Black Point Exuma Cays. Please bring some cash along. There is no atm or bank here on the island.

Top guest favorite

A patio area is shown overlooking the turquoise ocean, with a dining table and chairs set for four. Two lounge chairs are positioned next to a small, vibrant area rug. Tropical palm trees frame the scene of a private beach in the background.

Home in Rokers Point Settlement

5 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Paradise Point Ocean Front Home-Close to Airport

Welcome to Paradise! The islands of Exuma is like no other in the Bahamas. Paradise Point is a 2Bedroom/2Bath Oceanfront home w/beautiful private beach located just 2 miles from the airport & close to Georgetown. The house has a main bedroom&bathroom, and has a 2nd bedroom & bathroom in the lower level accessed from a separate entrance. The island of Exuma is the Bahamas most beautiful, friendly&safest. There is endless possibilities of how to spend your days in paradise making memories.

Top guest favorite

An overwater bungalow is situated atop crystal-clear turquoise waters, connected to the shore by a wooden walkway. Surrounding coral reefs are visible, showcasing a vibrant marine environment. The bungalow features a simple white exterior, blending harmoniously with the idyllic coastal scenery.

Tiny home in George Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Overwater Bungalow at Georgetown

Step into our bungalow and prepare to be enchanted by the spacious living area, decked out in tropical flair that screams "I'm on vacation!" glass doors frame views, you'll forget what dry land looks like. The deck, with loungers, offers views that'll make your followers jealous. Who needs a pool when you've got the ocean? Inside, a kitchenette awaits for your culinary adventures, and high-speed Wi-Fi ensures you can upload those envy-inducing pics ASAP. Book your stay and live the dream!

Top guest favorite

A beachfront bungalow is surrounded by palm trees, with lounge chairs set on a stone terrace overlooking clear water. The light blue exterior features multiple windows and doors, enhancing the connection with the picturesque environment.

Bungalow in George Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Beach Bungalow 1: Beach Front & Totally Updated!

Beachfront with incredible views! Relax on the private patio or sunbathe on Exuma Bungalow's private beach-deck (exclusive to our 3 villas). Fully remodeled & sleeps 2 adults (King bed) + 1 child (Queen sofa bed). Our villa next door sleeps 4 adults. As a part of Hideaways you'll enjoy all the comforts of staying at a resort including free use of the pool, paddleboards, kayaks, shuttle into George Town, fitness room & concierge services. Enjoy NO Check-in or Check-out time restriction!

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is nestled on a rocky rise, framed by lush green shrubbery. The house features a covered porch supported by decorative columns, offering a welcoming entryway. The surrounding area displays a mix of sandy ground and stone pathways, providing a tropical coastal ambiance.

Home in Staniel Cay

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Heidi's Retreat

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Heidi's Retreat offers a serene escape on Staniel Cay, Exuma. Enjoy well-appointed bedrooms adorned with island-themed paintings. Relax on the porch after a day of swimming with the pigs or exploring the island’s beautiful beaches. Nestled among lush coco plum and seagrape trees, each stay includes a delightful welcome box filled with Bahamian treats. Experience the perfect blend of comfort and adventure for unforgettable memories.

Superhost

A private home is set on stilts, with a vibrant red exterior and multiple large windows. A wraparound deck is supported by wooden railings, offering views of the surrounding landscape. Tropical plants add a natural element to the entrance.

Villa in Staniel Cay

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Ruby - Ocean view with privacy

Relax with the whole family at a private home that is within steps of secluded beaches. Amazing location and a great place to unwind or enjoy the gorgeous beach and blue water in privacy. This home boasts (2) ensuite bedrooms and bathrooms plus a 360 degree viewing loft which can be used as a 3rd bedroom. Situated on almost 3 acres. A boat + golf cart referral can be provided if you are interested. The land, sea & sky are nothing short of intoxicating in this island paradise.

Top guest favorite

A blue exterior of the villa is highlighted by a covered porch area. A white door with sidelights is framed by two windows. A single chair is positioned on the spacious deck, with ambient light softly illuminating the entrance.

Home in Staniel Cay

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

The Good Life: Private Elevated Villa

Come enjoy the peace and tranquility of Staniel Cay, Exuma! After visiting the swimming pigs, relax in the comfort of this fully air conditioned villa. This 2 bed / 2 bath offers a fully equipped kitchen feathering stainless steel appliances with granite counter tops. Other amenities include Satellite television, internet, and washer. At the end of the day, enjoy the sunset from the wrap around deck or take an evening stroll on the beautiful beaches that are in walking distance!

Guest favorite

A modern entertainment unit features a wide television displaying a serene beach scene with stacked stones and tropical flowers. Below, a decorative blue vase adds a pop of color, while the unit includes open shelving for storage.

Villa in George Town

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Ocean Mist Villa - George Town, Exuma

Enjoy sitting on the patio over looking the ocean, having a few drinks and enjoying the nice fresh calming air blowing on your skin and blowing through your hair. (At night times are even better.) Grab a free Kayak and go exploring over the beautiful turquoise waters. Family time got even better. There's marina located on the property with a boat that you can rent and its discounted for guest. Once you stay at Ocean Mist Villa you'll not want to leave. Book Today!

Guest favorite

A beachfront cottage is positioned above clear turquoise waters, surrounded by tropical vegetation. A wraparound deck provides a panoramic view of the cays and sandbars. Sun loungers are visible on the sandy beach, accessible via a gentle slope from the cottage.

Home in George Town

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

The Best Views are the ones we share with you.

SOUTHSIDE COTTAGE Close to Everything - Far from Everyone! $400/Night No Cleaning Fee 2 Guests Maximum Occupancy Overlooking the crystal clear water and surrounding cays, centrally located on the south side of Great Exuma, this contemporary beachfront cottage is a lovely island retreat. The cottage is located a short 4 mile drive to George Town where you will find grocers, restaurants, shops, marinas and healthcare facilities.