Cottage vacation rentals in City Island

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in City Island

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
The exterior of the cottage is illuminated by warm lights, showcasing a welcoming entrance framed by lush greenery and flowering plants. The architecture features a peaked roof with large windows that allow for natural light. A paved path leads towards the front door.
Cottage in Norwalk
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Seaside Serenity: 2B 1B, Patio,Near Beach

Nestled behind the main house, this cozy rustic cottage offers a unique blend of comfort and charm, overlooking the picturesque golf course. Just a short 10-minute walk from the beach, it provides breathtaking views of both the course and the Long Island Sound. Upstairs, two inviting bedrooms and a full bathroom await, while downstairs, a cozy living room beckons, perfect for unwinding after a day of adventure. Equipped with a well-appointed kitchenette featuring an island, microwave, hot plate

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a newly renovated cottage is showcased, with a sloped roof and a light-colored façade. Neatly trimmed shrubs and grass create a welcoming entrance, complemented by a stone pathway leading to the front door. A few trees provide greenery against a bright blue sky.
Cottage in Westport
5 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Wild Rose Cottage (Westport, CT)

Luxurious newly-renovated Cottage in prime location in Westport's historic district. Studio with queen-sized bed, kitchen (w/fridge, dishwasher, stove, oven, toaster, Keurig), full bathroom, A/C, fireplace, W&D, TV, WiFi (w/Amazon Fire Stick). Parking for one car. Back-up generator. Within stone's throw of Hudson Malone, Outpost Pizza, Merritt Country Store, Coffee An' Donut Shop and Grapevine liquor store. Just a short stroll on the sidewalk to downtown Main Street's shops and restaurants.

Guest favorite
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed adorned with decorative pillows and a plush throw. A bedside lamp and a dresser complete the room, which is enhanced by patterned curtains that frame a window, allowing soft light to enter.
Cottage in Englewood
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Cambridge Cottage - Your own "Private Oasis"

Cambridge Cottage: "Private Oasis" with a modern design 20 mins from NYC, in Bergen County's desirable town of Englewood. The Cottage has 1 bedroom with Queen size bed, 1 full bathroom with rain head shower, and a living room with a Queen size pullout bed. Fully stocked kitchen w/dining set. Minutes to restaurants, shops, Supermarket, Bergen Performing Arts Center, and houses of worship are also walkable. Easy commute to New York City by bus or car. Located near New Jersey shopping malls/parks.

Top guest favorite
An open living area features a comfortable gray couch adorned with a layered throw and decorative pillows. A coffee table with a rustic design sits in front, and natural light floods in through a skylight. Nearby, a dining space and kitchen are visible with wood cabinetry.
Cottage in Long Beach
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Cheerful 3BRcottage-patio, kingbed-steps to beach

This lovely beachside home located in the heart of the trendy west end is the perfect spot for a family vacation. Steps to ocean, boardwalk, bars, shops & restaurants. The space is open with lots of natural light. Comes w/highspeed internet, 50" smart TV, washer/dryer, dishwasher. Private backyard has cozy seating, grill, firepit & shower. Master BR has king, 2nd BR has queen, 3rd has twin. Inc. 4 beach passes, beach wagon, 2 bikes, 5 beach chairs, umbrella. Parking available on side streets.

Superhost
A charming two-story cottage features red brick and light siding, accentuated by green shutters. The inviting entryway is framed by large windows, surrounded by neatly arranged landscaping. A sign displays the address, '821 Hope Cottage,' beside a well-maintained front yard.
Cottage in Plainfield
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 246 reviews

Hope Cottage - A Home Away From Home

This beautifully renovated space by local architect Reginald L. Thomas is nestled in the Broadway Historic District of Plainfield, NJ and features 3 large bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Perfect for families and corporate travelers. The cottage can sleep up to 8 guests comfortably. Short walk to train into the heart of NYC and 20 mins from Newark Airport. QUIET NEIGHBORHOOD. NOT FOR PARTIES. SUITABLE FOR FAMILIES/ BUSINESS TRAVELERS *REGRETTABLY NO PETS ALLOWED PLEASE SEE HOUSE RULES BELOW

Guest favorite
A cozy studio space is presented, featuring a spacious bed with dark cushions, a small dining table and chairs, and a comfortable couch. Light walls are complemented by decorative artwork and accents. A kitchenette area is visible, along with shelving and a TV, creating a functional living space.
Cottage in Centerport
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

NYC/Long Island - cozy garden cottage!

Sweet garden cottage - enjoy beautiful fall colors or spring blossoms away from the City! Sunny, bright, quiet, nicely decorated, completely private. Quiet, green neighborhood, a short walk or drive from several Long Island Sound beaches*. Private entrance and parking, private bathroom with shower; kitchenette, fridge, microwave, A/C, heat. Minutes from the train station to New York City; 30 minutes drive to Robert Moses State Park/Fire Island Nat'l Seashore. *Some beaches charge a fee.

Guest favorite
A bright dining area features a long green table surrounded by tall wooden stools with patterned cushions. Large windows provide ample natural light and showcase the lush greenery outside. Decorative elements are displayed on nearby shelves, adding a charming touch to the space.
Cottage in Centerport
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Waterfront beach house 1 hr from Brooklyn and NYC

Escape to a rare waterfront beach house, just an hour from Brooklyn and NYC! Immerse yourself in the stunning natural surroundings and enjoy breathtaking 180-degree water views from every room. With 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, our lovingly restored mid-century modern beach house offers an open flow and airy feel thats perfect for relaxing and reconnecting. Comfortable for 2-7 people. Not ideal for small children or guests with limited mobility as there are steep stairs inside and outside.

Guest favorite
A cozy living space is highlighted by a black leather sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A vibrant area rug featuring a bold design lies beneath. Natural light enters through large windows, dressed with sheer curtains, while kitchen cabinetry and appliances provide a modern touch.
Cottage in West Milford
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

No big problems at this little house!

Peaceful 1 Bedroom/1 Bath + office with front patio, deck, fenced-in backyard. Beautiful view of Upper Greenwood Lake. Our lake association does not allow renters to swim, boat, kayak or fish in the private lake unless accompanied by the property owner. These are available in nearby public lakes and parks. Waywanda SP, Greenwood Lake and Monksville Reservoir are ~13 minutes away with swimming, fishing, hiking, boating, biking… A raised single air mattress can be provided if requested.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of the cottage features a simple entryway with a grey mat, alongside a blue chair positioned on a small patio. Bright greenery is present in a planter, and a flag is displayed on the side of the house.
Cottage in Rye
5 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Rye Cottage - Walk to Beach & Playland

Our cozy cottage is walking distance to shops, beaches, boardwalk, waterfront restaurants, Tiki bar and bier garden, park, pool and historic Rye Playland amusement park. Enjoy easy access to everything from this perfectly located home base. It's a short drive to our quaint town with boutiques for shopping and a wide variety of restaurants to choose from or jump on Metronorth for a train ride to the city. Finish the day with a barbeque or relax by the fire table in our cozy outdoor space.

Top guest favorite
A lakefront view depicts a charming house surrounded by lush greenery, with a stone terrace leading to the water's edge. Fall foliage adds splashes of color to the scenery, while the lake reflects the trees and sky.
Cottage in West Milford
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Happy Day Chalet, a lakefront stay to relax & play

Upper Greenwood Lake is a small, quiet and private lake community just over an hour from New York City. Easy to get to! A serene getaway to recharge your soul, see sunrises, and be in nature. Hikes, state parks, farms, a drive-in theater, cute towns are all within 15 minutes. Or just chill on the porch swing.

Top guest favorite
A bright living area features a comfortable sofa set against a white wall, paired with a wooden coffee table. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, while a patterned area rug adds warmth beneath. A modern chair and a small storage unit are also visible.
Cottage in Valhalla
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 325 reviews

Charming private 1BR apt. Easy access to NYC

Location, location, location! Private 1 bedroom unit that is part of a two-unit property. It has its own entrance, kitchen, bath, and off street parking. Walkable to Valhalla Metro North train station. (Has steps and stairs. No children under 12 years old.)

Top guest favorite
A charming cottage is set against a backdrop of lush green trees and an expansive sky. The structure features a covered porch with white railings, providing a welcoming entrance. Stone steps lead to the yard, which is surrounded by well-maintained grass.
Cottage in New Canaan
5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Peaceful New Canaan 2-BdRm Cottage - Pet Friendly!

Relax and recharge at this unique and tranquil cottage, situated on 2.5 acres of land with two ponds. Pets welcome! Property is fully fenced in. Cottage is next door to the main house, with separate driveway and entrance. Parking for up to 4 vehicles.

Popular amenities for City Island cottage rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Bronx County
  5. Bronx
  6. City Island
  7. Cottage rentals