Cottage vacation rentals in City Island

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in City Island

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is nestled among lush greenery, providing a serene entrance pathway. The driveway leads to the front door, surrounded by vibrant shrubs and trees that create a natural privacy barrier. The inviting exterior displays a warm welcome through its distinctive front door.

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Cozy home in the Village of Greenwood Lake

Adorable country retreat under an hour from NYC - perfect for a romantic couples getaway or a family of 4. Located in the village, our quaint cottage is walkable to everything; Restaurants, bars, grocer, cvs, bagels, bus stop and even the public beach!! Minutes away from TONS of local attractions; drive-in, skiing, renaissance fair, wineries, shopping, lake activities, orchards, creameries, parks, Appalachian trail, spa, rafting, golf, water park, & so much more. Pets welcome! Permit #21-07603

Superhost

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 206 reviews

Cozy Cottage | HotTub & Family Rm | 1H fr NYC

Just a little more than an hour away from NYC and a 4-min drive to the lake, this pet-friendly private retreat offers a hot tub, family room, spacious yard with fire pit, and a deck with a grill and comfy seating. The renovated interior has all the comforts of home including a full kitchen & streaming capabilities. Incredible perks include complimentary lake access at nearby beach, family board games, children's books, toys & a mini game table for ping-pong, air hockey, football & billiards!

Top guest favorite

A picturesque winter scene captures a cascading waterfall enveloped in freshly fallen snow. The surrounding trees are dusted white, creating a serene backdrop. The dark rocks contrast with the snowy landscape, and a gentle flow of water can be seen cascading over the falls.

Cottage in Warwick

5 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Cottage at Millpond Falls - Romantic Luxury Escape

Looking for a romantic getaway? Relax in this cozy cottage overlooking a waterfall in a private setting. We offer a 5-star premium experience! Super-clean and luxurious. One hour from NYC. Our most frequent review: "We can't wait to come back!" Nearby wineries, craft breweries. Minutes from Warwick village, restaurants, bars, antiques, shopping, Appalachian Trail, and Greenwood Lake. Apple picking, skiing and water park nearby. Close to LegoLand and Jehovah's Witness Headquarters.

Guest favorite

A private backyard is depicted, showcasing an expanse of green grass bordered by various trees. Pink flowering branches gently frame the scene, adding color against the soft evening light. The side of the cottage is partially visible, blending harmoniously with the natural surroundings.

Cottage in Middletown

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Cozy Cottage Retreat on North Jersey Shore

Come and relax in our shore retreat cottage with private driveway and backyard a block from the sea. We are a retreat away from the hurly-burly of connected life, but we do have WiFi Internet. We are located in a safe quiet neighborhood 5-10 minutes walk from Leonardo state marina and beach, 2 miles from Atlantic Highlands with it's bustling main street and delightful harbor where you can take the Seastreak ferry to Manhattan; 15 minutes drive to Sandy Hook and the Atlantic Shore Beaches.

Top guest favorite

A cozy seating area features a gray couch adorned with a decorative pillow, positioned near large windows that offer views of the surrounding nature. A unique, dark wood table rests on a textured area rug, enhancing the space's rustic charm.

Cottage in South Salem

5 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Oscaleta Guest House: Lakefront Cabin

Escapology-A spectacular lakeside destination, designed as a luxury suite with its own dock. Close to NYC and ideal for a quick trip, remote work or an extended retreat. Glamping-A cabin in the woods on a lake surrounded by nature, but tech-enabled with all the modern perks. Artfully Designed Space-Modern retrofit thoughtfully curated with custom artwork throughout this historic 1920's cottage. Purpose built for your outdoor routine- from grill to canoe…. We recommend 3+nights if you can.

Guest favorite

A fire pit surrounded by stone is illuminated by a warm glow, set within a wooded area as dusk approaches. Tall trees frame the scene, and silhouettes of rustic seating can be seen, with glimpses of the lake visible through the foliage.

Cottage in Vernon Township

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Rustic Chic Lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC

Cozy lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC. Nestled in nature with swimming, fishing , hiking and biking with beautiful lake views. 5 beaches to choose from. Lovely walking or jogging around the lake, Appalachian trail nearby. Highland Lakes is a very scenic, peaceful area easily accessible. 3 of the best golf courses in the US , Mountain Creek water park and resort minutes away.Apple and pumpkin picking comes fall. Beautiful village of Warwick NY is nearby with restaurants and shopping .

Guest favorite

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 338 reviews

Luxury Cottage with Spectacular Lake Views

Ultra Chic Cottage set high above Greenwood Lake with Private beach and lake front community access. Minutes away from Mountain Creek Ski Resort, Spa & Water park, Mt. Peter Ski & Tubing, Warwick creameries, breweries & vineyards & apple picking. 1 BR, 1 Bath, play/office/common room. Huge wrap around fenced in deck with Mid century modern fireplace allows for scenic dining, lounging and around the fire gatherings. #LakeViewCottage_GWL Town of Warwick Short Term Rental Permit #33593

Guest favorite

A deck with four blue chairs overlooks the calm lake, flanked by tall trees and vibrant fall foliage. The natural stone wall in the foreground adds texture to the tranquil scene, enhancing the serene setting by the water.

Cottage in South Salem

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Serene lake front cottage 1 hour from NYC

Serene minimalist cottage directly on Lake Oscaleta with spectacular waterfront and Mountain Lakes Park behind. Quiet, isolated and lost in the trees, you feel you are in Vermont or the Adirondacks. Yet it's only 1 hour from Manhattan, 10 minutes from restaurants. Kayak, canoe, fish, paddleboard. Cottage is elegant, cozy and winterized warm and the lake is effectively empty in the fall/winter/spring. Please note: because of an asthmatic child, we cannot accept any animals.

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Fairfield

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Charming Fairfield Beach 3BR Cottage By The Sea

Charming Beach Cottage – Steps from Private Beach! Welcome to our newly renovated seaside retreat—a perfect getaway for families, couples, or anyone looking to relax by the shore. Nestled just steps from a private beach (right across the street!), our charming cottage offers the ideal balance of coastal tranquility and convenient access to town. Whether you enjoy walking, biking, swimming, fishing, kayaking, or simply napping in a shady hammock, this is the place for you.

Top guest favorite

A scenic view of the river, showcasing lush green hills in the background and a collection of boats docked along the shore. A wooden deck is visible in the foreground, framed by a fence and greenery, inviting relaxation by the water.

Cottage in Sea Bright

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Pineapple Cottage 1 Block to beach sleeps 6!

RARE Off Street Parking for 4 compact cars or 3 SUVs This 3 bedroom beach cottage is a perfect, cost effective alternative to a hotel stay. Wifi, N64, HBO, Cable & board games for those rainy days. Fully furnished bedrooms, one bedroom has home office desk set up, living area, and kitchen, to our comfortable lounge area, BBQ, and outdoor shower. Perfect way to relax after a fun day at a beach, event, or exploring the beautiful town of SeaBright!

Top guest favorite

A quaint cottage is nestled among vibrant trees, showcasing rich foliage in shades of green and burgundy. A well-kept lawn surrounds the cottage, with a white door framed by flower beds. The serene setting invites relaxation in a natural environment.

Cottage in South Salem

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Private cottage in horse country &1 hour from NYC!

Private cozy cottage located in horse country on the the NY/CT borders ( New Canaan, Ridgfield, Wilton ) It is a perfect quiet getaway for couples or a friends night out , a great pit stop for travelers /skiers , fine dining , shopping /antiquing , Ridgefield Playhouse , hiking ,and a short ride to Grace Farms . 1 hour train ride to NYC . We provide organic fruit,breakfast snacks, coffee and tea . It is your home away from home and more :)

Superhost

A small deck is featured with two light-colored Adirondack chairs positioned for outdoor relaxation. Tall greenery and trees provide a natural backdrop, creating a serene setting. The wooden deck is made of planks and is clear of any items, emphasizing the inviting space.

Cottage in Kings Park

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Cozy Riverside Cottage

This is a private cottage on its own lot with its own driveway and yard located in a quiet residential neighborhood. Several grocery stores and restaurants for delivery/pick up in the area. 400 MBPS Internet connection for those who need a reliable internet connection for work/movie streaming! Please note guest maximum is 4. There are no additional guests or visitors allowed.