Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Chautauqua

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Chautauqua

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features natural wood paneling and high ceilings, complemented by large windows allowing ample natural light. Red outdoor chairs sit around a wooden coffee table, while a cozy sofa invites relaxation. Views of the lake can be seen through the glass doors.

Chalet in Brocton

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 210 reviews

The Sunset Hideaway

Great year round, natural wood, high beamed contemporary lake house. You’ll think you’re in Napa Valley. Natural beautiful wood throughout entire chalet style lake house. Open floor plan. Separate bunk house with heat/ac that has a queen trundle that sleeps 2 and two twin bunks. 100 feet exclusive Lake Erie frontage. Wood burning stove inside with large floor to ceiling windows for breathtaking views. Private lake and beach shared access next to property. Reliable high speed internet/Roku.

Guest favorite

A renovated kitchen is highlighted by modern appliances and natural wood accents. A spacious dining table is set for a meal against a backdrop of large windows that provide views of the outdoor space. Ample counter space and cabinetry enhance functionality.

Home in Salamanca

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Perfect location

Fully renovated 2 story, 4 bed, 2 full bath. Lots of parking, washer/dryer, boot/glove dryer, 3 porches, Weber grill, slow cooker, fire pit, rec room, private fenced in yard with doggie door and deck. 11 golf courses within 20 miles Mtn biking mecca 2 ski resorts with in 12 minutes 14 minutes from Allegany State Park 8 minutes from Village of Ellicottville 10 minutes from Seneca Allegany Casino Lots of legit breweries and bars Hunting and fishing Views of sunrise/sunset in the valley

Guest favorite

A bright and airy bedroom is furnished with a spacious bed draped in neutral linens and a cozy gray throw. Nearby, a seating area is created with a wooden bench and decorative pillows, leading to sliding glass doors that open to a view of the surrounding green space.

Home in Erie

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

RARE FIND: Tonight! cozy, king bed, fireplace

Kick back in this newly renovated, clean, & stylish space. Just 1/2 mile south of I-90 and conveniently located near Presque Isle Downs & Casino. The home is nestled in a prime location, with easy access to Erie's most popular attractions, such as Presque Isle beaches, & many golf courses. A few minutes drive away from well-known Peach Street, which offers a variety of restaurants, entertainment destinations, & Millcreek Mall. A great place to retreat while exploring all that Erie has to offer.

Guest favorite

A wooden pathway leads to a dark-colored house surrounded by tall green plants and vibrant orange flowers. Large windows bring natural light into the structure, while trees in the background provide shade and privacy.

Chalet in Little Valley

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Ellicottville Privacy Mountain

High in the hills of Ellicottville is 62 acres of secluded bliss. Mountain bike, hike or cross country ski through the private wooded groomed trails. Swim in the sparkling spring-fed pond. Enjoy the splendid view across the valley or the sparkling night stars from the hot tub then kick back with friends at a bonfire. Forget the stress of traditional vacationing, restaurant reviews, & tourist traps. Recharge your battery & enjoy the freedom to reconnect with what and who makes you the happiest.

Guest favorite

A tranquil outdoor space is depicted with several gray Adirondack chairs arranged around a stone fire pit. The dark wooden A-frame home is visible in the background, flanked by tall trees and a grassy area, suggesting a peaceful retreat.

Chalet in Findley Lake

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

Lakeside Lodge—Secluded Family Getaway Sleeps 10

This charming a-frame alongside Findley Lake has a private backyard & is close to Peek'n Peak, Lake Erie Wineries, Presque Isle Casino & Lake Erie Speedway. With a 1st floor master suite, three upstairs bedrooms and a bonus loft -the whole family can relax together. Our gas fireplace let’s you warm up with the touch of a button! The kitchen is spacious and well stocked for you. Guests who want lake access may use the public dock in town or rent space at nearby Paradise Bay Campground.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Little Valley

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Cozy log cabin

Looking for the perfect getaway? Our cozy cabin tucked in the woods offers the ideal balance of privacy and proximity. You'll be 4 miles from downtown Ellicottville where you can spend a day walking through the shops, restaurants, brewery and winery. Want outdoor adventure? Holiday Valley is 5 miles away, where you'll find the best skiing, tubing, mountain biking and golfing in the area. We're also just a short drive to Salamanca and Allegany state park where more thrills await!

Guest favorite

An inviting seating area is positioned alongside the water, with two chairs and a small table visible. Natural light streams through an open doorway, enhancing the serene lakefront view. Wooden walls and a striped rug provide a cozy and rustic ambiance.

Cottage in Findley Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Hidden Cove

Beautiful lakefront cottage on Findley Lake. Completely remodeled cozy one-bedroom cottage with two docks, 150 ft. of lake frontage, and boathouse. Tucked away on a quaint woodsy lot, you can enjoy breathtaking sunsets while relaxing around the firepit. Hidden Cove offers a one bedroom with a queen mattress and pull-out sofa bed. The kitchen is fully stocked. Just a few miles from Peak n' Peek resort where you can enjoy skiing, cycling, ziplining, segway tours, and restaurants.

Top guest favorite

Home in Ellicottville

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Windsor Castle - Cozy Farmhouse Ellicottville

Windsor Castle - Your Cozy Ski & Golf Retreat Escape to serenity at Windsor Castle, a charming 2,300 sq ft farmhouse nestled on four rolling acres in Ellicottville. This beautifully restored 1900s home perfectly blends rustic charm with modern comfort, featuring a tranquil 3/4-acre pond that mirrors the changing seasons. Minutes from Western New York's premier ski destinations and golf courses, this private retreat offers the perfect balance of seclusion and accessibility.

Guest favorite

Two glasses sit on the edge of a hot tub, sparkling cider visible inside. A serene view of a flowing creek and wooded landscape is framed by trees, with soft light illuminating the peaceful outdoor setting.

Cabin in Sinclairville

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

The A Frame-Cozy cabin, HOT TUB! Nature lovers!

Cabin with great amenities in the forest. There’s a creek flowing and a lovely pond. 4 seat Hot tub! Satellite Tv, WiFi, full size fridge, microwave, apartment size oven/stove, wood stove (primary heat in colder months) and electric baseboard heat 2 double beds, bunk beds. wood stove in garage. Easy access to NY State Land Snowmobile trails! Great location for hunters,Snowmobilers, cross country skiers, hikers, kayakers and all outdoor enthusiasts! Near Cassadaga Lake.

Top guest favorite

Cottage in North East

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Quaint North East Cottage Near the Water

North East Cottage is a quaint, two level cottage nestled between 16 mile creek and Lake Erie. It offers two bedrooms, one pull-out couch with a queen mattress, two full baths and two large decks overlooking Lake Erie. The kitchen is fully stocked and newly remodeled! The living room provides warmth and coziness with a gas fireplace for cool evenings on the lake. A short walk down the road is a private beach for relaxing and spending the day on Lake Erie.

Guest favorite

A modern rustic cabin is presented, featuring a wooden exterior and large windows. A stone pathway leads to the entrance, flanked by snow-covered ground and trees. The sky above is bright with scattered clouds, contributing to a serene winter atmosphere.

Cabin in Cattaraugus

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

⭐ Cabin ⭐ Glamping ⭐ Chef's Kitchen ⭐ New Build

Experience a modern cabin getaway at Breezy Hill Cabin in Cattaraugus, NY. Nestled on 10 wooded acres, this newly built, Amish-crafted retreat features rustic charm with luxury finishes, including black stainless steel appliances and open-concept living. Perfect for couples, families, and outdoor lovers—just minutes from Ellicottville, hiking, skiing, and nature trails. Book your peaceful escape in upstate New York today!

Top guest favorite

Home in Warren

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Lush Newly Renovated Home - Downtown Warren Pa

Sleeps: Up to 8, W/Hypo Allergenic Luxury Bedding 4 Bedrooms - 5 Beds: (1) Queen, (1) Full, (1) Twin W/ (1) Twin Trundle, (1) Queen w/2nd Recreation Area (Seating, Gaming, Work Space) Living Room w/Electric Fireplace, Dinning Area with Large Table, 1-Bathroom w/Double Sinks and Large Vanity Hair Dryer, Straightener and Toiletries Provided (Soap, Shampoo, Condition, Lotion), TV’s in all Sleeping and Living Areas