Vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
Two wooden Adirondack chairs are positioned around a circular firepit, with a cozy blanket draped over one. Behind, the geodome is seen beside a tranquil pond, surrounded by lush greenery, reflecting a clear blue sky.
Dome in Port Colborne
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 597 reviews

Luxury Romantic Glamping Dome near Niagara Falls

You'll love this unique and romantic escape for 2, located 30 minutes from Niagara Falls in Port Colborne. Our 400 sq ft geodome offers all the amenities needed for a relaxing, romantic getaway. Panoramic floor to ceiling window over looking a private pond with the opportunity to see wildlife from the comfort of inside the dome. Enjoy a fireplace, hot tub, comfy queen size bed, private deck with a fire table, outdoor shower, firepit on your own island, incinerating indoor toilet, AC, and wifi.

Guest favorite
A spacious loft area features a cozy sleeping space with a large bed, complemented by a decorative light fixture overhead. A television is positioned for viewing, and natural light fills the area through multiple windows. A comfortable seating area and soft textures contribute to the serene environment.
Loft in Niagara-on-the-Lake
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 512 reviews

Luxury In The Heart Of Wine Country

Hidden along the shores of the Niagara River, Grayden Estate is nestled on a quiet dead end street in beautiful Queenston/Niagara on the Lake. A short drive to Old Town and within a few minute walk or bike to world class wineries, art galleries, farmers markets, hiking trails, parks and the waterfront, Grayden Estate is the ideal location for a peaceful quiet getaway for anyone looking to surrender to the simple living quiet life. Complimentary tour bikes are available for use. Lic # 112-2023

Guest favorite
A charming, dark blue cottage is framed by lush greenery and vibrant purple flowers. The cobblestone pathway leads to a bright yellow front door, welcoming guests. Various flowering plants provide color and texture to the well-maintained garden, enhancing the inviting exterior.
Cottage in Niagara Falls
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 345 reviews

Charming Carriage House in Niagara's Wine Country

A converted carriage house and former blacksmith shop with a rich history dating back to the 1800’s - updated with brand new modern amenities. This is a one level plus loft bedroom, ideal for those who have challenges with stairs. Centrally located near the Falls, Niagara Parkway, Niagara-on-the-Lake, casinos, wineries and the largest outlet mall in Canada (car recommended). A great gathering spot in any season with a full kitchen, laundry and outdoor space ready to entertain family and friends.

Guest favorite
A comfortable living room is shown, featuring a gray sofa with patterned cushions and a side table with a warm lamp. The cozy space includes a large area rug and a television, while natural light filters through sheer curtains. An adjacent dining area is visible.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 528 reviews

Red Door - Niagara Falls USA

Welcome to the Red Door of Niagara Falls, NY USA. We offer a private, fully furnished, 3 queen beds/2 full baths home located just minutes from beautiful Niagara Falls USA and Canada. Our home is conveniently located in a nice neighborhood near Factory Outlet shopping, the Seneca Niagara Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. WE ARE PERMITTED BY THE CITY. Please read the rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! -Jim and Colin

Top guest favorite
A modern kitchen area features a granite countertop with stools positioned nearby. A stainless steel refrigerator and oven are visible, alongside a cozy living space with a large window and decorative curtains. Exposed brick accents complement the warm wood flooring.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 372 reviews

Little Niagara Bungalow-Minutes from Niagara Falls

The Little Niagara Bungalow is a newly remodeled home less than ten minutes from the Falls! Groceries and restaurants as well as a large outlet mall even closer! Blackout blinds in the bedrooms as well as TVs with Directv and Netflix on Roku. Comfortable queen beds with a couple pillow choices. Free off street parking for up to 4 cars plus free street parking. Full amenities including a brand new kitchen and on site laundry. Beautiful new bathroom with a large walk in shower. See you soon!

Top guest favorite
Castle in Buffalo
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 302 reviews

King Fireplace Luxury Rooftop Loft Gym Bball EV+

Experience the unique luxury! Perfect for family, business, or romantics. With high end finishes, 16' ceilings, a stunning 6' fireplace, this space exudes comfort & elegance. Unwind in the 5' round tub, or enjoy a movie on the 85' smart tv, while appreciating the building's history. For the active guests, an indoor basketball court and gym. Office area for business travellers. Seasonal rooftop area for sunsets or enjoying the weather. Additional bedrooms can be added for larger groups.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a two-story barnhouse is illuminated in the evening light. A spacious upper balcony is adorned with wooden railings and features a cozy hanging chair. The lush green lawn complements the red siding and white accents of the structure.
Guest suite in Niagara-on-the-Lake
5 out of 5 average rating, 416 reviews

Wine country loft, breakfast included

The Barnhouse Loft offers a very unique opportunity to enjoy Niagara Wine Country in full privacy and great comfort. You will be treated to a delicious full hot breakfast every morning and have exclusive use of the entire apartment. We are located right on the Niagara Escarpment, halfway between the majestic Niagara Falls and historic Niagara On The Lake. ***NOTE: We are not able to accommodate any pets or service animals due to serious allergies in the family. Thanks for your understanding.

Guest favorite
A modern kitchen features a wooden countertop with two place settings, including plates and glasses. A stainless steel sink is paired with a silver refrigerator. Shelves hold potted plants and glassware, while a wall clock adds a practical touch to the light-colored walls.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 499 reviews

Blue 74 Niagara Falls USA(3 beds/1.5 baths)

Welcome to Blue 74 of Niagara Falls, NY USA! We offer a private, fully furnished home that sleeps 7 total ( 2 queen beds, trundle and a sofa. We're located 6-8 minutes from the US side of the Falls. Conveniently located in nice, quiet neighborhood near Outlet shopping, Seneca Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. WE ARE LEGALLY PERMITTED BY THE CITY. Please see rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! - Colin and Jim

Top guest favorite
The cottage exterior showcases a charming façade with a peaked roof and large front windows. A small wooden deck features a red umbrella sheltering a bistro set, offering a welcoming entryway surrounded by greenery.
Cottage in Niagara Falls
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 218 reviews

Waterfront Niagara River Cottage

Listed since November 2020. Completely remodeled cozy cottage on the Niagara River! Quick 15minute drive down the river to Niagara Falls! Also easy access by car to surrounding Buffalo and all that it has to offer. Or relax, secluded away with full access to the entire cottage and amenities during your stay. Sleeps up to 4 people, two beds, washer/dryer, electric stove, oven, and microwave, complimentary internet access, Smart TV, and a private river-front backyard with sweeping views!!

Top guest favorite
A spacious sleeping area is highlighted by a large bed with a patterned coverlet and decorative pillows. A television is mounted on the wall, while a white dresser and nightstand are present. Natural light enters through a window dressed with blue curtains.
Apartment in Sanborn
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 581 reviews

Niagara Falls area home

In a great little town centrally located in Niagara County. 20 minutes to the American Falls State Park in Niagara Falls, NY, 15 minutes to Artpark and the very popular Village of Lewiston, 20 minutes to Lockport Locks and Erie Canal Cruises, and 15 minutes to the Herschell Carrousel Factory Museum in North Tonawanda. Close to Fatima Shrine, Fashion Outlets of Niagara Falls, U.S.A., Fort Niagara, Canadian border for cross-border shopping City of Buffalo and Canalside, and so much more!

Superhost
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed with white bedding, positioned beside a small table and a desk with a chair. Natural light enters through two well-draped windows, illuminating the hardwood floor and areas of soft gray walls.
Home in Niagara Falls
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 375 reviews

♥3 bdrm Niagara Falls Home ♥ A/C♥ Hot Tub♥ Parking

• Full, clean two-level house with hardwood floors (Recently remodeled) • Very quiet and safe neighborhood • Central Air Conditioning • Fully stocked and equipped kitchen with granite countertops. • On-site laundry • Large private backyard with grill, spa, and deck. • Streaming device on TVs, Netflix and Disney+ • Private off-street parking • Close to the interstate 190 entrance & 7 minutes to Niagara Falls State Park • Close to the Niagara River for fishing and some beautiful hikes.

Top guest favorite
Home in Niagara Falls
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 226 reviews

Forest Hideaway - Private Apartment

Welcome to the Forest Hideway Convenient location in Canada, a short walk to Niagara Falls and the main attractions. A home away from home. This completely private unit has a Double bed and a big bathroom with a rain shower. Private entrance. A private full kitchen with everything you need. Includes free coffee and tea. Includes free a parking spot. A 43inch flat screen TVs with complimentary NetFlix and fast wifi.

Popular amenities for Cayuga Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Niagara County
  5. Niagara Falls
  6. Cayuga Island