Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Cabin in Rockville

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Relaxi CABin

Come enjoy our cabin in the woods. It is set up for the perfect combination of rest, relaxation, and recreation. Step away from your busy life to spend some time enjoying nature. Melt away stress in any of the 12 available sleeping spots in the AC, layout in any of the 3 hammocks, sit by the fire pits, or soak in the 5 person Hot tub. When you're ready for some fun the cabin is located at the lake and next to the park. Take your family out in the 4 Kayaks, do some fishing, and so much more.

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Georgetown

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Farm Escape w/Nature Views, Central Location

Retreat to the views of nature at Highland Farm getaway, no shortage of starry nights and prairie winds. We treat guests to an experience that's quirky and cool, we do not pretend to be a 5-star hotel but have hotel amenities like blackout blinds, unlimited wifi, full kitchen and sound machine. Centrally located on the IL/IN border, 15 minutes to I-74. Minutes from Forest Glen Nature Preserve, Beef House Restaurant, Big Thorn Farm & Brewery, Turkey Run State Park and Midwestern covered bridges.

Top guest favorite

Villa in Indianapolis

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

*Luxurious *Quiet *Walkable *Up to 25 *Central

👑 Experience both History and Charm in this stunning 1872 fully renovated Victorian Villa. Located in a peaceful, exclusive 🌲 tree-lined street in a HIGH END neighborhood. This 3 story, 3 master bedrooms, 4,000 square ft. Villa with all modern amenities, designed with luxury in mind. Lavishly entertain your guests in the expansive living areas, and yet have everyone find their own space. Walk to top-rated restaurants and coffee shops and to mass Avenue and downtown. enjoy peace and luxury!.

Superhost

Home in Indianapolis

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

The Y @Keystone4BR 3.5BA Eclectic/Spacious Getaway

Beautiful, eclectic, and spacious. This 3200 sq ft unique home has been featured in design magazines and is sure to meet your needs - from the traveling professional to the adventurous family. This home has the most convenient of locations! Close to shopping, dining, event centers, and nightlife. I465 - 1 minute Keystone @ The Crossing - 3 minutes Broad Ripple Village - 5 minutes Downtown Indianapolis - 15 minutes Grandpark - 12 minutes Minutes from Park Tudor, Willows, and Ritz Charles

Superhost

Home in Crawfordsville

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Acres of serenity

The comfort of this 5bdrm, 3.5bath ranch are enough to earn a spot at the top of your list. The large kitchen features granite counters & double refrigerators. A 9ft island with granite counters. The master bedroom has a his/hers bathroom. A 3tier commercial style fountain makes for a stylish welcome. The yard features outdoor kitchen pavilion, with a shower curtain waterfall, a wood burn fireplace & a path to a fire-pit area. On the back patio from the master bedroom is private jacuzzi.

Top guest favorite

Home in New Palestine

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

2 Bedroom House in New Palestine, Close 2 Downtown

A completely remodeled two bedroom, one bathroom home... all yours. It's fully equipped with everything you need - towels, dishes, laundry detergent, books, and bedding. Just bring your clothes! The home has WiFi and premium TV channels. You can relax and drink your coffee from the front porch or keep up with your busy life by doing laundry and working from the desk. It's approximately $22 for an Uber ride to downtown Indy. Enjoy the quiet but stay close to the city!

Top guest favorite

Apartment in Bloomington

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Resort & Lake Living Close to IU

Indulge in a serene getaway at our stunning Lake-themed condo on Lake Monroe at Eagle Pointe Golf Resort. Enjoy the Resorts restaurant, poolside bar, Live music, 2 pools, Pickleball/Tennis/Basketball courts, weight room, sauna, driving range and golf course! Just around the corner is the beach and marina and only 20 minutes to IU stadiums! Unwind on the deck with a “Winter water view” of the lake. Our home features a full kitchen, washer/dryer, Free WiFi and more.

Guest favorite

Home in Indianapolis

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Indy Adventure: Hot Tub, Arcade, Grill, Sleeps 8!

This spacious and stylish retreat features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, comfortably sleeping up to 8 guests. Perfect for both relaxation and entertainment, the property boasts a hot tub, arcade games, foosball table, and a cozy fire pit. Enjoy the best of downtown living with easy access to top attractions, dining, and nightlife. Whether you're here for a family getaway or a fun weekend with friends, this home offers the ideal blend of comfort and excitement.

Top guest favorite

Home in Terre Haute

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Luxury Lake House: Stay French Lake

This bright and airy 4 bedroom home is a destination getaway perfect for your family, friends, or business retreat. With new furniture, appliances, and décor this retreat is the perfect getaway or staycation for your leisure or business needs. Nearby Attractions: Queen of Terre Haute Casino, Griffin Bike Park, Fowler Park, Laverne Gibson Cross Country Course, Rose Hulman, Indiana State University, and The Mill Concert Venue

Superhost

Home in Indianapolis

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Downtown in 10min, Near Fairgrounds | Pets Welcome

Welcome to Lazy Sunday Rentals! - Fully remodeled 3 bed, 2 bath home with premium finishes - Directly behind Indiana State Fairgrounds - Quick access: <15 min to downtown Indianapolis, <20 min to Fishers - Sleeps 6 comfortably - Modern, minimalist decor for a peaceful stay - Bright, open living spaces designed for comfort - Well-equipped kitchen with high-quality appliances - Ideal for families, friends, or business travelers

Guest favorite

Home in Terre Haute

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

Lakefront Paradise *Indoor Pool* *Arcade*

Have you been looking for the perfect family vacation?? Look no further as this one of a kind lake house has it all. From a heated indoor pool for year round fun to a free play arcade overlooking the lake. This one has something for those of all ages! Come enjoy this serene landscape as you overlook your own piece of paradise while you stay with us. We strive to provide an unparalleled location and experience. See you soon

Superhost

Home in Westfield

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

The Charming Ranch Home in Downtown Westfield

Welcome to BEAUTIFUL downtown Westfield, IN! Westfield is ranked as one of the top small towns in America, and this home has EVERYTHING to offer. There is tons of room for your entire family or even your whole team if you’re playing at Grand Park! Come enjoy the brand new private hot tub in the backyard and relax at this spacious ranch style home! Your vacation awaits! Reach out with any questions!