Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Bungalow in Bloomington

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 242 reviews

Blue Lemon Bungalow - Quiet Getaway in Town!

Blue Lemon Bungalow is an adorable, newly renovated two bedroom in Bloomington with full living, dining, kitchen, and washer/dryer. In town with a country vibe. It has a huge yard with old growth trees, yet it is only a 5 minute ride to Downtown Court House Square or Indiana University Memorial Stadium. A large front porch with festive lighting gives you a place to enjoy the view. We have taken special care to make Blue Lemon Bungalow extra comfortable and stylish. Well behaved pets considered.

Nov 21 – 28

G$22,984 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Poland

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Pioneer Log Cabin on the Lake

Take a step back in time to a simpler way of life! Enjoy this log cabin that was originally built in the pioneer days. While the cabin retains the charm of the 1800's, it also has been updated with basic amenities like electricity, indoor plumbing, hot water, and everything you would expect from a modern cabin. Located on Cataract Lake, yards from a public boat launch, this is the perfect spot to get out onto the lake or just relax amongst the trees. Boat parking is provided on the property.

May 21 – 28

G$45,712 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Martinsville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 420 reviews

Grandpa's Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow

Grandpa’s Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow offers exclusive lodging for 6 on our hilly 5 acre wooded property. We offer a peaceful getaway from life while being right in the middle of both Indianapolis and Bloomington! Our quiet rustic cabin has a loft bedroom with stair access that includes a King size bed, 2 twin beds and an air mattress. We have a spacious bathroom and a fully equipped kitchen to help you feel at home. Search YouTube for Grandpas Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow for a video!

Sep 19 – 26

G$18,351 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Brazil

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Tiny Corner Cabin

The Tiny Corner Cabin has a lot to offer! While it's not a wood log cabin, it offers all the fun parts of a camping experience but with modern amenities. Plus, this place is on a small, lake perfect for fishing, kayaking, watching the colors of the sky, and gathering around the campfire too. Looking for a romantic getaway for the weekend? Perhaps you want a peaceful stay near Terre Haute or Indy. Book the Tiny Corner Cabin when you need a beautiful escape from the everyday!

Jul 15 – 22

G$21,289 GYD per night

Superhost

Cabin in Columbus

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 370 reviews

Getaway Brown County - Indianapolis

An easy drive from the city, Getaway is a new way to experience the great outdoors. Nestled across dozens of acres of private woodlands, our modern, tiny cabins have everything you need (comfy bed, bathroom, fresh linens) and nothing you don’t. Featuring a private outdoor area (hello, fire pit), each cabin is designed to help you relax, unwind and disconnect from the everyday. Plus, as part of your stay, you'll receive firewood, a s'mores kit, coffee and bottled water*.

Sep 16 – 23

G$25,378 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Poland

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Captain Bill's Guest House/seasonal swimming pool

Welcome to Captain Bill's Guest Lodge at Cagels Mill Lake! This gorgeous home offers modern amenities in a countryside setting. Perfect for bikers, boaters, fisherman, and anyone looking to enjoy lake life. Our guests are welcome to join us poolside at the main house. Our private pool is open only to us and our listed guests at our two Airbnb units. We're located seconds from the boat ramp and a short drive to Cataract Falls and Lieber State Park. Pool is seasonal.

Jul 5 – 12

G$38,810 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Rockville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Hideaway Hollow

This is a fully furnished picturesque Amish-built cabin in beautiful and secluded Parke County, Indiana. The cabin comes complete with all amenities including full bath with shower, queen bed, A/C, dish TV, wifi internet and full kitchen. There is a large deck attached with a beautiful view of the swinging bridge and the woods. Cook out on the deck's gas grill and enjoy cool evenings by the fire pit (wood provided). Enjoy a nap in the shade in the hammock.

Jul 7 – 14

G$19,799 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Tent in Poland

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Fancy Tent Glamping, Firepit, Power, Carpet

Save money with no cleaning fees!! Quiet safe private area with large tent fully equipped - just bring your clothes ! fire-pit, table and 2 chairs outside, access to common area covered outdoor kitchen and use of heated outdoor shower with towels provided. Tent is set for 2 adults only with deluxe queen air mattress, nice linens, pillows, fan and power. Back of tent faces woods and front of tent faces private gravel road to the east. Host lives on property

Sep 21 – 28

G$13,061 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Home in Brazil

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 262 reviews

Swans Nest

If you are looking for a place to get away from the stresses of life this is it. You can fish on our 10 acres lake, walk thru the woods or just relax on the porch swing. Only 5 minutes from the nearest town, 30 minutes from Terre Haute and 40 minutes from Indy. Front porch faces a walnut tree grove and back porch faces 10 acre lake. At least 3 State Parks are within 20 miles of this property. Also super close to the Parke County Covered Bridge Festival.

Aug 2 – 9

G$19,425 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Crawfordsville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 496 reviews

Mimi's Country Cottage

Quaint, quiet and cozy cottage set in a tranquil park like setting with all the amenities of home. Close to Shades and Turkey Run State Parks. A great place to stay for the Covered Bridge Festival. 15 minutes to Wabash College and 25 minutes to DePauw University. We live on site. We clean the cottage in accordance with the CDC guidelines to ensure your stay is safe. Pets are allowed on a case by case basis. Please contact us to work out any details.

Mar 1 – 8

G$22,059 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Carbon

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Parke County Dream Cabin

Come experience the serenity of country living and get away from the daily grind of everyday life. Come fish in our five-acre lake (catch & release only), paddle-boat, kayak, or stroll through the woods. A covered porch and seating lakeside for relaxing. Located close to Mansfield and Bridgeton, 30 minutes from Turkey Run State Park, and only 30 minutes toTerre Haute or Greencastle. Come explore everything Parke County has to offer! KIDS WELCOME!

Dec 16 – 23

G$25,243 GYD per night

Guest favorite

Loft in Mooresville

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 274 reviews

Entire Apartment: Beautiful Farm and Country Views

This beautiful, over the garage private apartment is located in a wooded area across from our 94 acre farm. A very peaceful setting to wind down and enjoy the nature around you. Conveniently located 15 minutes from the airport and 30 minutes from downtown Indianapolis. A work space is also available that overlooks this beautiful farm!! Also perfect for couples or small families to enjoy some time in the country!

Oct 4 – 11

G$22,013 GYD per night