Vacation rentals in Bimini Bay

Brand New Remodeled Villa + Large Private Pool!

Remodeled cottage with a lush tropical backyard, which boasts a Private Heated pool with Waterfall and Swim-up Tiki Table, turf putting green ,Weber Grill, patio bar with 55” Outdoor Smart TV! Calypso is outfitted with a cozy Coastal decor, you feel that vacation vibe as soon as you walk in the door. The kitchen offers quartz countertops with Stainless Steel appliances. Both bedrooms have King size beds, living room has a queen sleep sofa. All furniture was brand new in December of 2024

Salty Harbor AMI pool retreat near the Beach

Charming Salty Harbor sits in a quaint, exclusive corner of AMI and boasts a private heated pool and ample parking for 2 vehicles and even a boat: -We typically have shorter stays available, just ask! -If you don't have a single 50Lb pet, please discuss it with us -One of the twin boutique MyAnnaMariaStay homes, look us up! You'll love the luxury mid-century feel, lush yard, and a 6-min walk to the beach, Publix or the trolley stop. AMI was voted a top 50 vacation spot in the world in 2024

83rd St Villas East by Duncan Real Estate

Welcome to The 83rd St Villas East! A stunning ground-level vacation villa just a 6-minute walk from the beach! With two bedrooms and two bathrooms, this rental sleeps up to six guests. You and your guests can sit back, relax, watch movies, and connect over effortless conversations in the living area. Top of the range, fully equipped kitchen with Caf appliances, ample counter space, cook top and oven, extra-large fridge/freezer making meal prep a breeze.

Bradenton Beach Sunsets 1, Anna Maria Island, FL

Fully furnished water view beach cottage located on beautiful Anna Maria Island directly across the street from white sand beach and Gulf of Mexico. 1 Bedroom 1 bath unit that sleeps 4 with the queen pull out couch. Beach chairs/umbrellas/Boogie boards/laundry room, etc. provided. Three blocks from historic Bridge Street with lively restaurants and bars. Free island trolley and across the bridge from Cortez fishing village. Free off-street parking.

Turtle Cottage - Anna Maria Island

Great 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom cottage on the quiet north end of the island. The house is conveniently located and within walking distance (two short blocks) to the beach and close to the intersection of Gladiolus Street/Alamanda Road. Spectacular sunrises are just a short walk away at the Rod and Reel Pier, and the sunsets at Bean Point Beach are second to none, just a few blocks away. This great getaway sleeps up to 4.

L'Oasis East w/Dip Pool

Completely remodeled, this beautifully 2-bedroom duplex, crafted to enhance your living experience. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to create a serene and inviting atmosphere. New images showcase this stunning transformation, come visit us to see the beauty in person! Additionally, West and East are now available for rent together, featuring convenient adjoining doors through the utility room.

The Peachy Beach House, steps to the gulf

If custom trip length is desired, please send inquiry. Two bedroom, 2 full bathroom, new heated private pool Steps from semi-private gulf beach, this 3 story on a quiet street in N. HB Well-stocked kitchen, 2 TVs, large master which is more like resort suite with new tempurpedic king bed Gulf views from bedrooms. You’ll find: crib, high chair, beach chairs, wagon, canopy, beach toys and towels!

Gulf Front Guest House

Gulf Front Guest House – 1-bedroom king bed efficiency with separate kitchen, and full bath! Downstairs relax in the living room featuring a 75" Smart TV and queen sleeper sofa. Step into the lush landscaped yard, walk down the sidewalk, and you’re on the beach! Amenities include a heated pool, fenced yard, BBQ grills, plus beach chairs, wagon, and umbrella for your perfect island escape.

Loggerhead - Private Pool + Golf Cart - AMI Oasis

Loggerhead 🐢 - Escape to your island oasis on Anna Maria Island — just a 4-minute walk to the beach! 🏝️ Unwind in your private heated pool, sip sunset drinks at the Tipsy Turtle bar, and cruise the island in your included 6-person golf cart. Perfect for families or couples seeking the ultimate beach getaway filled with sun, relaxation, and island charm.

Fanta Sea | Island Fun w/Pool, Hot Tub, Game Room!

Get ready for laid-back luxury! This fun and breezy 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Holmes Beach retreat has everything you need for an unforgettable island escape. Relax by the tropical pool and built-in hot tub, challenge your crew to a board game or ping pong in the game room, or unwind on one of three covered balconies with comfy seating.

1 block to Pine Ave + Shopping + Beach + Dining!

Welcome to Spring Sea’Esta! 🏖️ 🌴A stunning island retreat situated in the heart of Anna Maria Island and less than 1 block away from Pine Avenue. 🌴 Enjoy easy access to shops, local boutiques, ice cream parlors, playgrounds and the beloved Waterfront Restaurant—all just steps from your door.

New! Boat Dock + Dolphins + Beaches + Hot tub!

✨Welcome to Retro Tides! 🌊 ✨A newly renovated waterfront retreat near Anna Maria Island Gulf Beaches! Observe Dolphins from your Private Dock! Relax in the Tiki Hut + Hot Tub! Take the Kayaks for a spin! This getaway is made for boating, fishing, beaching, and relaxing in true Florida style! 🌴