Island vacation rentals in Appalachian Mountains

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated island rentals in Appalachian Mountains

Guests agree: these island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Island in Youngs Point

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Camping on a private island in the Kawarthas

Campout on your very own private island in the Kawarthas. Great for swimming, fishing, and enjoying nature. 14 foot aluminum boat provided, no motor...but it's only about 150 ft from our dock on shore to our dock on the island. Boat traffic on the Trent can be a little busier on weekends, so there could be the odd wave which could make it difficult for swimming with or even fun for children. Always wear proper PFD Weekend noise from the trailer park can sometimes go into the night past midnight.

Top guest favorite

Guest suite in Marysville

5 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

Island Mill Waterfall Retreat-Jan-April Night Free

Listing description *ALL INCLUDED* ( with seasonal variations) HotTub~4 Watercraft~Park Pass~Bikes~Outdoor Fire & Shower~Veggie Garden A one-of-a-kind experience awaits you in our 200 year old converted limestone mill. This eclectic space with a private entrance is nestled between two waterfalls on an island in the Salmon River. The beautifully appointed 525 sq ft suite is right on the edge of the river. Dine & relax on your private patio overlooking the waterfalls and the old one lane bridge.

Guest favorite

Home in LaHave Island

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Stunning Island Home Above Treetops Near Lunenburg

SkyView on LaHave Island is car-accessible, built on the highest point of a gorgeous island like a castle on a hill. A 2-story atrium, multiple large windows and skylights reveal spectacular 360-degree views of picturesque coves, a sprawling bay and the vast Atlantic. Enjoy lounging outside on 3 decks with glass panels. High-speed Internet. 5 mins from Crescent Beach swimming, 7 mins from mainland activities on Lighthouse Route, 40 mins to Lunenburg. See our video on Youtube. A phenomenal spot!

Guest favorite

A serene waterfront scene showcases the vibrant colors of sunset reflecting on the water. Silhouetted trees line the shore, framing a small green house amidst the tranquil landscape of the private island and surrounding waters.

Island in Clayton

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Island Boat House - Fisher's Landing, NY

The Island Boat House is on a private 2 acre island in the 1000 Islands near Fisher's Landing, NY. You may bring or rent a boat, or we can provide rides in our boat for arrival and departure. This rustic & charming two br living space has a double & queen bed in the main room with a double bed in a separate room. An historic boathouse over the water, guests enjoy a private deck, with shower, dock & grill downstairs. Enjoy the majesty of the St. Lawrence River - fishing, swimming and sunsets!!

Guest favorite

Home in Grimstead

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 305 reviews

Gwynns Island Waterfront Getaway

Great cottage on the water with a fantastic view of the bay and best sunset on the east coast. Sliding glass doors make it feel like your on the water when your sitting on the couch or in the kitchen. You can crab, fish, kayak, grill out and swim right off the back deck. Very peaceful and relaxing. The newly renovated island restuarant is a mile away with a bar and bascically anything you would want to eat. My father left us the house, we use all the proceeds from Airbnb to make improvements.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Sturgeon Bay

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Sunset Cabin on Cedarbirch Island, Door County

Our island rests in Sawyer Harbor surrounded by Potawatomi State Park and Idlewild Peninsula. This is a nature lovers haven. It is the perfect place for those that are looking for a peaceful* getaway and up for a bit of adventure. The wooded island is seven acres and home to two cabins- Sunrise (facing Potawatomi State Park) and Sunset (overlooking the Idlewild Penninsula). The cottages are connected by a well traveled path and a short walk. *favorite spot for fishing, boats can be close

Guest favorite

The historic retreat is situated at the water's edge, overlooking a calm bay with gentle ripples. A grassy area leads to an inviting deck and the shoreline, where a small dock is visible. Surrounding trees add to the tranquil setting, reflecting the serene atmosphere.

Farm stay in Westport Island

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

The Stilt House

Once the island Trading Post (in the 1820's) now serves as a private retreat on Westport Island. The whole property has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 1982. The building is nestled at the water's edge, half on land and half on stilts over the tidal waters of the Sheepscot River. The property has its own private deck, island, rocky beach, trails and hammock. This is an old structure - over 200 years old! A great piece of history and an absolute oasis.

Top guest favorite

Island in Lakefield

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Suite Island Retreat

We invite you to relax and recharge with this unique island glamping experience; a tiny lakefront cabin with modern touches. From your private dock, swim in the deep water, play on the floaty mat, lounge, read, paddle in the canoe, and catch -both- a sunrise and a sunset… absolute perfection. Amenities also include an outdoor kitchen and BBQ, a fire pit, an outdoor shower, and a clean and airy outhouse. Oh, and a lovely hammock, made for two! Come and enjoy! :) -Minimum 3 nights-

Guest favorite

A cozy outdoor seating area is illuminated by string lights, creating a gentle glow under the mature tree. The space features a patterned stone patio surrounded by greenery, with a small wooden deck visible to the left, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Guesthouse in Mount Pleasant

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 251 reviews

Bungalow Under The Oaks

Small guest house in the heart of Mount Pleasant! Ideally located to both Isle of Palms and Sullivan's Island beaches (both 7 minutes) and only 15 minutes to the heart of historic downtown Charleston. Our private guest bungalow is a perfect launching spot for all your exploring. End the day relaxing under the shade of our mature live oak. The house has its own entrance and separate yard that is fully fenced in. LHR Permit: ZSTR-02-21-00318, License: LIC-3-21-252314.

Superhost

An aerial view captures a serene landscape of lush greenery contrasted with the blue waters of Casco Bay. Various islands dot the seascape, while the estate, surrounded by trees, is positioned prominently on the land below, highlighting its connection to the coastal environment.

Home in Yarmouth

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Eagle's Nest on 8 acres next little john preserve

Nestled on 8 acres overlooking Casco Bay, the Eagle's Nest cottage has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom. Open plan with full-kitchen and living room including a queen-size sofa bed. Located on an island, you're only 20 minutes from downtown Portland and 10 minutes from downtown Yarmouth. Last but not least the cottage is a 5-minute walk from a 23-acre preserve that has numerous scenic viewpoints, tide pools and ledges, and picnic tables. Coastal Maine at its best!

Top guest favorite

The exterior view of the timber-framed house features large glass-panelled doors opening onto a spacious wooden deck. Comfortable outdoor chairs are visible, surrounded by tall pine trees and showcasing serene lake views through the glass, inviting a connection to the natural surroundings.

Cottage in Sharbot Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Neverland - Private Waterfront Cottage 360º Views

Perched upon a rugged Canadian Shield peninsula is Neverland; a private retreat with a birds eye view of Eagle Lake. Multiple decks surround the timber-framed house and guest/kids cabin and thoughtful paths meander throughout the property ~ leading to the magical (2000 ft) shoreline of beautiful lakefront. Neverland is an oasis of nature and privacy, in a most lovely setting providing an incomparable, soul-nourishing experience.

Top guest favorite

A secluded cabin is nestled among vibrant green trees on a tranquil island. A wooden walkway leads from the dock to the front of the cabin, which features a green metal roof. Two canoes are visible on the calm water, enhancing the serene landscape.

Island in Monmouth

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

Naughty Dog Private Island Log Cabin

Be all alone on this remote island with 1400 acres of Annabessacook Lake as your backyard. Enjoy pristine surroundings, a rustic, off-the-grid log cabin, with solar lighting and a hot shower. Swimming, boating, fishing, birding, and relaxing by the fire - do it all (or not). Prepare for adventure! Pack light: Bring your vacay clothes, pups, favorite food, & be ready for a blissful, private island get away. It's AWAY away.