Cabin vacation rentals in Upper Cataract Falls

We had the most incredible weekend at Garrett & Ewa’s place! They communicated so well with us before hand when planning my sister’s wedding celebration! Everyone loved the space. It was all as pictured and even better than expected!

My husband and stayed for a few days - the pictures and descriptions are accurate. The house is about 25 minutes to the town of Nashville, but it is a beautiful drive. It is very well maintained and is one of the cleanest vacation properties we have stayed at. We loved the quiet, remote area. The back deck has a pleasant view of the lake, which appears to be a nature preserve. We would definitely stay here again and recommend to our nature-loving friends.

Beautiful home in a quiet, peaceful setting. Jeff provided some specifics on how to find the place that were very helpful. Huge, well stocked kitchen. Every room has interesting and beautiful artwork and the softest blankets and throws I’ve ever seen! Very cozy. Wonderful family weekend!

This home is so peaceful and the outside space makes you feel like you’re in Narnia! We never wanted to leave! Thank you for this space and beautiful place!

Gary and Kris's house was amazing! The space was roomy and fun. It was well appointed and the kitchen had every pot or pan you could imagine. The deck is very nice and the view from it was serene. We saw lots of wildlife in the back and side yards and were able to catch fish right from the dock. It was easy to find and there's a lot that's close in case you forget anything. We had a wonderful time! Thank you!

Michael is a great host! We really enjoyed our time at the cabin. It has a beautiful view of the lake. It was comfortable with lots of amenities. We would go back!

Melissa was a great host. We had to cancel our trip on short notice and then rebooked on even shorter notice. She was very understanding and helpful. The house is very cute and quiet with a lot of space indoors and out. We didn't get the chance to use the fire pit or the hot tub (maybe next time).The living room furniture and the beds and pillows were very comfortable. The kitchen table was perfect for eating and playing games. The kitchen appliances were top notch. The house feels remote but is not far from Nashville, IN and all it has to offer. Good pizza and beer at Bog Woods Pizza. Also check out the Farm House Cafe & Tea Room, just down the road, for great food and a nice nursery with a lot of plants. We'd definitely stay here again.

This place was awesome. Very spacious inside. Loved the screened in porch. Plenty of wood for fire pit. Stocked very well with everything you needed. Definitely returning next year. 💕💕💕

Sam was very responsive from booking to checkout! Cabin was very clean and we enjoyed our stay! Wish we had more time to explore. Would recommend

Reserved the house a year before our stay in anticipation of son's graduation. EVERYTHING was exactly as described in the listing. We had a marvelous time in Nashville, Bloomington, and Indianapolis as well as a 1/2 day at Lake Monroe. Easily drivable for food, supplies, and entertainment venues. We had a wonderful time at the cabin. Thanks Dave.

Wonderful place to stay that is very close to Nashville shopping. We love the mix of vintage and modern. Would definitely stay here again.

very peaceful location and space was large enough to accommodate everyone in our group. The house decor was beautiful. We definitely enjoyed our time there.

We had a small family gathering to celebrate my parent's 50th wedding anniversary. The property is excellently maintained. Quiet and peaceful. Our favorite thing to do was to sit on the back deck, read, and listen to the birds in the woods. Lots of things to do on the property for both adults and kids. Within a 10-15 minutes drive to the little neighboring town that has a lot of small shops and restaurants to visit. Great spot for a long weekend away!

We had a wonderful stay at Brooks Run Cabin in beautiful Brown County! The cabin was the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern convenience—think cozy wood beams and the gentle creek of vintage wooden floors, but also strong Wi-Fi and a great shower. Ashley was an excellent hostess—thoughtful, responsive, and clearly someone who knows how to make guests feel welcome. The nearby Brown County State Park is absolutely glorious—lush, peaceful, and teeming with natural beauty. That said, for my fellow city folk: this is real nature. Be prepared to meet ticks, enthusiastic flies, and the occasional snake and frog who think they owns the place. (They actually do!) One tiny note—not Ashley’s fault at all—there was construction happening on the neighboring property, which was a bit of a disappointment. But finished in time for us to truly enjoy our last day. All in all, a wonderful escape into the woods with everything we needed and more. Would definitely return—with bug spray in hand!

We had a wonderful stay! Leah was very responsive to our questions and gave amazing recommendations on things to do. Our kiddos loved the swim spa, collecting chicken eggs, and getting to pet the very friendly chickens. The back porch was a favorite spot, perfect for unwinding, doing art, reading a good book, and watching the sunrise over the tree tops.

Peaceful getaway in a private setting but not too remote. Great space for hanging out with games and hot tub for entertainment. The hosts were attentive to our needs and responded quickly to questions. Plan to go back again next year.

This is our second stay at this cabin. It was so peaceful. It rained some of the time, but it was so cozy listening to the rain inside the cabin. We had a nice Easter brunch on the porch. We love staying at all John's cabins.

Great place. Worked great for us.

We absolutely loved staying here! The cabin was so cozy and welcoming. It had everything we needed and more. The outdoor space is perfect! Waking up and enjoying our coffee under the new pergola was pure bliss! The birds singing created the most enchanting and relaxing atmosphere. It was the perfect way to start each day and truly unwind. Highly recommend taking advantage of this beautiful outdoor space! We couldn't have asked for a better place to call home during our trip. We would highly recommend this spot to anyone!

Spent a IU football weekend here while visiting our daughter on campus. Quaint cabin in the woods that met all our needs. Chris’s instructions were very thorough. Only about 14 minutes from campus too. Great hiking in Hoosier national forest that was minutes away. Would be a wonderful place to stay also if you were doing a lake weekend over the summer.

Cute little cabin like place with a very responsive and helpful owner. Would definitely stay again if I ever go back to Indianapolis

We loved our stay at Terra and Brian's place. It's a beautiful cabin; very clean and well decorated; set nicely back from the road so there's plenty of privacy. Terra was very proactive with check-in and check-out instructions and responsive during our stay. Our only regret is that we didn't pay attention to the extensive number of games or fun titles on the bookshelves. Two days was not enough time to explore all of them!

Wonderful communication from the host, clear instructions sent out before hand, absolutely my favorite cabin in the woods trip to date! I've done this 1-2 times a year for the past few years, and Anna's kitchen was by far the best stocked I've seen, incredibly appreciative of this! The only thing of note is a couple of the nails in the flooring were up and could have been a potential painful step, but I would 100% recommend this stay and would absolutely stay here again myself!

We had an excellent stay! With 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, our group of 5 had plenty of room and privacy. The location is great - beautiful woods and right next to Turkey Run. The house was very clean! Lots of towels, pillows, and blankets. They had a nice selection of big spray and sunscreen, but bring your own shampoo/conditioner/body wash.