Island vacation rentals in The Great Lakes

This was the first time renting a cottage on its own private Island for me and my group. We did not know what to expect and were very excited about this new experience. Jan has been super great at communicating and answering all my questions. The experience was an amazing one and left us with wonderful memories. If you love, nature and serenity this is definitely the place. It’s been ages since I’ve seen this many stars in the sky. The cottage itself has everything you need and a great layout with open concept kitchen for socializing with your group of people. We all really enjoyed our stay. Thank you Jan!

A group of us came to Collin’s place for a fishing trip. This place is awesome! The dock was perfect for our pontoon rental. Really enjoyed the kayaks and row boat that were provided as well. The space was spacious, clean, comfortable, and had everything you could want for a trip up north. Collin was very responsive and helpful with a few questions on where to find things. The kitchen is fully stocked, which was appreciated by our group cooking multiple meals per day. The location is great too. Only 10 minutes to the nearest Grocery store, and about 20 minutes to some of the “larger” towns in the area . Highly recommend little Bohemia lodge for their Friday/Wednesday fish fry. The food and drinks were excellent and the atmosphere is very unique. We would love to stay here again.

Great rustic cabin for 5 fisherman. Great location and great fishing as well. Lads want to return next year.

Great view down Shawanaga Bay from the living room. Enjoyed the brand new kitchen. This cottage has a real beach that is not typical for the PAB area. Not only was it a great gathering place, but a nice launching area for their kayaks and canoe.

We had an amazing stay at Brian's. Cottage was equipped with everything we needed. Very clean and spacious. We did alot of fishing and caught many fish. Morrison Lake is beautiful and clean. Loved to hear the call of the loon that swam in the lake. Brian answered any questions we had promptly. We would recommend this beautiful island cottage

It was our 9th wedding Anniversary and we were looking to get away from our busy lives for a weekend. Our entire stay on Garden Island was above and beyond anything we could of imagined experiencing. The Bunkie is perfect size and stocked with all necessities. Tranquil, serenity, peace, nature, Thank you so much Maxim for your brilliant hospitality from the moment we met you until we departed. And until we meet again. Cheers. Alex and Zee 2024

Our family of 4 loved staying on the island! It was definitely rustic living, but the cabin had everything necessary to cook, sleep, and enjoy the island comfortably. The scenery was beautiful and we spent much of our time in, near, or on the water. Donna provided a canoe and we brought our own inflatable paddle board. Both were in use often during our stay. The upstairs of the house would get warm on hot days, but cooled down significantly at night. The beds were comfortable and we had some excellent nights of sleep during our stay. Our dog vacationed with us and she was so happy to run free and wade in the water all day, every day. Donna was an excellent host. She was always available to answer questions. She communicated with us consistently and was flexible when we arrived later than expected. Staying by ourselves on an island was a very cool experience and we will fondly remember this unique and special place for years to come! Thank you Donna!

We had a wonderful, relaxing 8 night stay in this classic cottage on a stunning part of Georgian Bay. The cottage was spacious and was equipped with everything we needed. The wraparound deck offered incredible views of smooth rock islands, open water, and gorgeous sunsets. The property, located on a point, was larger than we expected and offered lots of space for lawn games like Bocce Ball. Swimming off the dock was excellent, and the area was perfect for paddling by SUP or kayak. We had our own boat and the fishing did not disappoint! Overall, a fantastic stay supported by a responsive and helpful host. We didn’t want to leave!

Great place for a weekend getaway! Honey Harbour was only 1.5 hours away and a 6 minute boat ride from the Marina. The place looked exactly like the photo’s and Ming was excellent to deal with. Great area for boating around, fishing, etc. with a near by restaurant you can dock at. Thanks again, we’ll see you again next year!

This place is awesome. Cottage was clean and well equipped with anything you need. Even with some storms on shore we barely got 20 min of rain the whole stay. The sandbars in mitchels bay are unreal to spend the day at. Water was 83 degrees and Crystal clean! Fishing and kayaking are great. Short boat ride to go for dinner in town, or cook at home with the bbq or over the fire. Nick was excellent to communicate with and did everything to ensure we had a great time. We spoke several times over the phone to make the weekend go off without a hitch! We will definitely be back next year.

We really enjoyed our time here. The cottage is super easy to get to, it's got a great layout and it's very rare to have the amount of space on the waterfront that they do. We were able to take our son onto the little beach and let him play, or just lounge on the dock, or jump from the rocks. Great spot within 2 hours from Toronto.

Our stay with Diana and Lorn was even better than what we expected. The location was beautiful with multiple docs and decks to soak in the view from every angle, the cottage itself was right on the water supplied with everything you could need (and quite adorable!), and as hosts, they were so accommodating and responsive. The little coffee shop they have on the island for guests and other cottagers really shows their love for bringing people together. We look forward to going back…every year!

What a fantastic destination to visit ! Owners were absolutely amazing and accommodating, cottage was clean and one of the most beautiful spots we have visited ! We will definitely be going back !

The house is great. Lots of room. Very clean. Spacious and the yard and view is gorgeous. Can’t wait to return. Allison was great and very responsive.

We had never been to this area of Ontario before and always wanted to. Finding this location on the Bay met our requirements for cozy, rugged beautiful surroundings and some fishing. This location is a must visit if you are wanting a peaceful time away. Word of caution, if you are trying to get here on your own an electronic navigation device with charts is a must. I used my phone and the navionics app and we also had a good device on the boat so it was a breeze for us getting in and finding the island even with some misty rain on the way in. Sitting on the west side of the island looking down into west bay at the sunset with a drink was a highlight. Also catching a 20 pound pike was another highlight. Really appreciate this place meeting expectations. Plan on returning next fall for a similar adventure.

We had the best time at Brett and Lindsay’s Paradise island cottage! The island and surroundings are beautiful. They could not have been more helpful as hosts, answering all of our questions and arranging transport/boat rental. The cottage is well equipped and private. It was perfect for a stay with our dog. We look forward to hopefully being able to stay again in future! Highly recommend.

Great spot!

Amazing place -- the island and bay are beautiful, the cabin is cozy and has everything you need for a weekend (or more) of relaxation & fun. Hosts are friendly & responsive. We had a wonderful time, hope to return again in the future.

Another Great stay at Lisa’s! We were here 4 years ago with our puppy, who’s no longer a pup! He loved it, we loved it! Gorgeous place, perfect weather, very comfy main bed! Lisa is awesome! We didn’t want to leave! Hope to be back again soon! ❤️

My wife and I had a great time at the island. What a cute little town oregon is, this was our first time here. Erin picked us up by boat and we left our car at the public dock, it was safe there. The boat ride was 10 mins and a fun experience. We were dropped off and picked up at the end of our stay. Checking in to a bottle of wine and candles lit was a romantic touch for my wife and I. We forgot to bring bug spray (there are mosquitoes at night) but the host had a bucket filled with different types (deet, no deer, natural, tea tree etc) they also provided a lot of sunscreen products. The house had everything you could wish for. Cold AC. Every type of cooking equipment you could ever need. A popcorn maker was a nice touch and they provided the seeds. Bed was very comfortable. There was multiple fishing rods and a tackle box for us to use. We basically didn’t leave for 4 days and just relaxed, my wife read her book, I fished and we had a great relaxing time. There was a Kayak for us to use, an inflatable boat for 2 and a hammock we spent a lot of time on. Worth every cent. We were offered to rent the boat daily if needed but we had no reason to leave the island. We will be back next summer for sure.

It was amazing journey for our family. Great place to stay, to enjoy a nature and spend some time together. Safe and quiet place for families with kids.

Absolutely phenomenal experience at Bucktooth Island! Debra and Pat's hospitality was top-notch. We spent an unforgettable long weekend swimming, BBQing, exploring, and relaxing in their picturesque cabins. The surroundings were breathtakingly beautiful, and the rustic cabins themselves were cozy and comfortable. What truly impressed us, however, was Debra and Pat's exceptional responsiveness. When we raised a concern, they promptly addressed it, ensuring our stay was seamless and enjoyable. We wholeheartedly recommend Bucktooth Island to anyone seeking a unique and eventful getaway. You won't be disappointed! Debra and Pat's warmth and dedication to their guests' experience shine through in every aspect of their hosting.

This was our second time at the Island Mill Getaway. Our first time was in the other suite for our first dating anniversary. This time we stayed in the Juliette suite for our first wedding anniversary. The gardens were just as beautiful as I remembered, with stunning new additions. The attention to detail both indoor and outdoor was incredible. We felt so comfortable and relaxed. Suzie and Jerry’s hospitality was impeccable so don’t hesitate to consider this relaxing piece of paradise for your next romantic getaway. :)

It is a difficult balance to preserve the rustic nature of a Georgian Bay retreat all while having modern-day conveniences, and Joe and his family have threaded this needle to perfection. The care and attention that has been put into this charming property is evident throughout. We especially enjoyed the solar-lit walkways, the fishing-themed decorations, the swimming deck with lily-pad and the adult/child kayaks. Wonderful views around the island along with different sleeping quarters make for an ideal family vacation. The island is also provisioned with everything you need which takes the pressure off when planning and packing. This was a very memorable vacation all around and we are grateful for our stay.