House vacation rentals in Sugar Creek

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Sugar Creek

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A dining area features a round wooden table surrounded by four matching chairs, with a decorative plant as the centerpiece. Nearby, a leather chair sits beside a window, while a kitchen area displays white cabinetry and dark appliances, providing a functional and inviting space.
Home in Sugarcreek
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 517 reviews

Gerber Valley Farm Bed & Breakfast

Spend the night "on the farm" in a scenic valley between the rolling hills of Holmes County, Ohio--the heart of Amish Country. Walnut Creek, Berlin, and Sugarcreek are mere minutes away! We offer a private setting so you can relax and breathe in the country air! Sit on the porch and watch the buggies roll by while you enjoy Chris' famous coffeecake--a favorite of our many returning guests! Soak in the whirlpool tub and let your cares float away. You will love our clean, cozy, and charming place!

Top guest favorite
An open-concept living space features a well-equipped kitchen with a central island and seating for four. A dining area with white chairs and a round table is visible, alongside a cozy sitting area highlighted by a rug. Decorative lighting fixtures enhance the inviting atmosphere.
Home in Dundee
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 310 reviews

Woodstone Cottage in the Heart of Amish Country

This quaint cottage is nestled in the rolling hills of scenic Amish Country. It's located within a mile of the historical town of Winesburg and 5 miles from Berlin and Walnut Creek. You can explore lots of Coffee Shops, Restaurants, Antique Malls and unique Boutique Shops. You will also find Breitenbach Wine Cellars in Sugarcreek and your kids will love to visit The Farm in Walnut Creek. You will also find lots of spots for hiking. At the Dundee Falls and the Wilderness center located in Wilmont

Top guest favorite
The exterior of the home features a modern design with dark brick walls and contrasting wooden accents. A prominent entrance is framed by a covered porch and landscaped areas. Two balconies are visible on the upper level, surrounded by lush greenery and ample lawn space.
Home in Sugarcreek
5 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Oasis Downtown in Amish Country

The whole group will enjoy easy access to everything from this centrally located place. This home is in the final stages of being completely remodeled. More pictures will be added soon! This home has been redesigned with the intention of creating an Oasis for you to enjoy whilst visiting beautiful Amish country! We added luxuries to spoil you and leave you so relaxed that you won't want to leave! We are also close to many local attractions in this area!! Walking distance from Park Street Pizza!

Top guest favorite
A rustic cabin features earthy stonework and large windows, surrounded by lush greenery. Stone steps lead to a patio area adorned with planters. A vibrant red door adds a pop of color, while trees provide a natural backdrop, creating a serene environment.
Home in Fresno
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Romantic private cabin w hot tub in Amish Country

Retreat to the Fresno Escape! A private cabin featuring a year-round hot tub, perfect for relaxation. Tucked among pines and rocks in the heart of Amish country, where the occasional clip-clop of horse and buggies adds charm. Styled like a railroad depot, the artistically furnished home displays intricate stonework, tile and custom stained glass. The kitchen includes appliances and cookware, with the outdoor area offering a propane grill. Complimentary firewood is provided for the firepit.

Guest favorite
A bright living room features a brown leather sofa and two light-colored accent chairs. A round wooden coffee table is positioned in the center, complemented by a neutral area rug. Large windows allow natural light to illuminate the space, enhancing its welcoming feel.
Home in New Philadelphia
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

House on 3rd Street with Hot Tub

Your will be close to everything when you stay at House on 3rd Street. Located in New Philadelphia, where you will be only 0.3 miles from Tuscora Park, 1.5 miles from New Towne mall, and within a couple miles from several restaurants of your choosing. Outside you can enjoy sitting around the fire and using the grill, with a nice size backyard for kids to run around. Head inside to our fully functional kitchen, cozy living room, 3 TVs, and foosball table. Enjoy the luxury of convenience.

Top guest favorite
The living room features a soft area rug with a neutral color palette, surrounded by comfortable seating options, including a light brown sofa and an armchair. A round side table and a floor lamp are positioned next to the armchair, while natural light enters through nearby windows.
Home in Sugarcreek
5 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

Grandma's Place - Steps from Downtown Sugarcreek

A newly renovated 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home. Located in a quiet neighborhood within walking distance of all the attractions in downtown Sugarcreek. Conveniently located next to the local farm market, Sweetwater Farms and iconic Swiss Village Bulk Foods. The property has plenty of outdoor space for children and adults with access to outdoor games upon request. With ample outdoor entertainment space, this is the perfect place for your family while you visit Sugarcreek.

Top guest favorite
A well-appointed bedroom is depicted with a spacious bed featuring multiple pillows and a neutral palette. Two minimalist side tables are positioned beside the bed, accommodating decorative items. Natural light filters through window blinds, highlighting a framed artwork on the wall above the bed.
Home in Millersburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Ida's House - Walnut Creek Modern Amish Farmhouse

Welcome to Ida's House... We invite you to be our guest! Perfect for a family, ladies' getaway or couples' trip - This 4th generation Amish Farmhouse is quaintly nestled on a country road in the heart of Ohio's Amish Country. While allowing you to get a taste of the country life, complete with neighboring horses in the backyard, Ida's House is conveniently located just minutes from all the attractions the area has to offer in Walnut Creek, Sugarcreek and Berlin.

Top guest favorite
A welcoming front porch is framed by lush greenery and features a classic wooden door. Two rocking chairs are positioned beside the entrance, which is adorned with an American flag. The brick pathway leads to three steps that enhance accessibility.
Home in Sugarcreek
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Charming 4 Bedroom Downtown Classic

Enjoy easy access to everything in Amish country from this perfectly located home base in the heart of Sugarcreek. Featuring 4 bedrooms and a 50" television in each room, this unique property is perfect for couples, a family getaway or a girls trip to this special area. Within walking distance to several restaurants and the downtown Sugarcreek area, you won't be disappointed in this stylish in-town retreat.

Top guest favorite
A two-story blue home is prominently featured with a welcoming entrance. Simple landscaping surrounds the front, and an American flag is displayed near the steps. A carport extends alongside the home, offering covered parking. The neighborhood greenery suggests a peaceful residential setting.
Home in Coshocton
5 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Charming & spacious 1st floor in the heart of town

Located in the heart of Coshocton, this newly remodeled first floor home will make for a comfortable stay! The complete kitchen, full bathroom and laundry, large dining room and spacious living room is perfect for your weekend getaway or month-long stay. The carport, attached to the home, makes for a safe and convenient entry. Charming backyard gives space to be outside. Pet friendly with a deposit.

Top guest favorite
The exterior features a spacious wooden deck supported by a structured wooden frame. A barbecue grill is positioned next to an outdoor dining area, complemented by modern seating. Large glass doors provide a view into the interior space, enhancing the seamless indoor-outdoor connection.
Home in Sugarcreek
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Hollow Valley Crates

Nestled in a flowy little valley, Hollow Valley Crate's "Hilltop" Container is your new favorite place to rest, relax and recover. We're a few minutes from interstate 77 and a few minutes from the heart of Amish Country. Surrounded by wineries and local dining favorites you won't want to miss. Spooky Hollow Road is quiet and peaceful. What more can you ask for when needing a get away?

Guest favorite
A modern kitchen is equipped with stainless steel appliances, including an oven, refrigerator, and dishwasher. Light-colored cabinetry complements the granite countertops. Three sleek bar stools are positioned at the island, providing a casual dining space under warm pendant lighting.
Home in Strasburg
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Riverside Retreat: Hot Tub, Peaceful Setting

Welcome to our Riverside Retreat in Strasburg, Ohio! Relax on the front deck to the sound of the river or unwind in the hot tub on the back patio. Located just a short drive from Amish County, you can explore the shopping and restaurants in the area. Enjoy a comfortable stay in a fully furnished home with all the amenities you need. We look forward to hosting you!

Top guest favorite
An inviting porch area is illuminated by warm overhead lights, highlighting the stone accents of the entrance. Comfortable chairs are arranged along the front, with a small potted plant nearby. The structure features a welcoming door and large windows that enhance the exterior's charm.
Home in Dundee
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 484 reviews

Walnut Valley Farm guesthouse

Nearby the Dundee Falls (3 miles) Central Amish County Location, 9 miles to Berlin, 6 miles to Sugarcreek or Walnut Creek. Enjoy your morning coffee (or tea!:) looking out over the rolling farmland of Ohio’s glorious Amish Country. Known for its peaceful landscape and peaceful people. This is the perfect place to come and leave the cares of the world behind.

Popular amenities for Sugar Creek house rentals

When is the best time to visit Sugar Creek?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Avg. priceG$38,276 GYDG$43,923 GYDG$37,230 GYDG$37,649 GYDG$43,923 GYDG$43,923 GYDG$43,714 GYDG$45,597 GYDG$44,551 GYDG$42,041 GYDG$44,342 GYDG$43,923 GYD
Avg. temp-2°C-1°C4°C10°C16°C21°C23°C22°C19°C12°C6°C1°C

Quick stats about house rentals in Sugar Creek

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 30 vacation rentals in Sugar Creek

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Sugar Creek vacation rentals start at G$20,916 GYD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 2,260 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly vacation rentals

    30 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    10 properties have a dedicated workspace

  • Wi-Fi availability

    30 of Sugar Creek vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Sugar Creek rentals

  • 5 Average rating

    Sugar Creek stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 5 out of 5!

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Ohio
  4. Tuscarawas County
  5. Sugar Creek
  6. House rentals