Places to stay near Story Lake

Book unique vacation rentals, homes, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals near Story Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
Cottage in Panacea
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 223 reviews

Vintage Old Florida Charm “For The Birds”

Welcome to Natural Florida! About 30 mi from FSU’s 🏈 Stadium , 5 min from the Gulf. Vintage 1938 cottage, 2 bedrooms/2 bathrooms, under ancient mossy oaks & palms in Panacea, FL. Comfortable, eccentrically decorated w/well-equipped kitchen. Near boat ramp, top seafood markets & wonderful restaurants. Close to public National & State Parks: St. Marks Wildlife Refuge & Lighthouse, AREA X, Wakulla Springs, Florida Birding & Hiking & Bicycle Trails, Gulf, Bays, Lake, & Beach, Birdwatch, Fish, FUN!

Guest favorite
A small, single-story home is situated on a grassy area, featuring a light-colored exterior and a green metal roof. A white picket fence borders the property, with a screened porch visible at the front. Tall trees provide a natural backdrop behind the house.
Tiny home in Carrabelle
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

The Sweet Peach - 2 Adults 1 toddler

This NOT so tiny, tiny home is located across from the bay, has everything needed to enjoy your vacation. Completely remodeled in 2017. Shabby chic, beach decor, Q sized bed, 2 stuffed chairs & complete kitchen. Screened in porch, dining area, chairs. Relax with a beverage & enjoy the amazing view of the bay. Affordable small family (2 adults 1 small child) vacation or romantic getaway. Professionally cleaned after each guest stay. Bathroom is small with corner shower. Pet policy in listing

Top guest favorite
A spacious waterfront home is depicted, featuring a screened porch and a metal roof. Lush greenery and golden grasses surround the base of the house, while calm waters extend across the foreground. The structure is elevated on stilts, providing an inviting appearance.
Home in Crawfordville
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Fisherman’s Oceanfront Dream Home w/Dock & Kayaks

35% discount for monthly stays, 15% for weekly. Million$$ views of Oyster Bay & Gulf from every room. Only 40 minutes to the Florida Capital, FSU, FAMU, TSC & the Tallahassee International Airport. Private dock, trailer parking & boat ramp. Screened porch & 2 walkout decks. Views from any room are breathtaking! Enjoy the hammocks under the house. Kayaks, fish cleaning station & crab trap are provided. With the well appointed kitchen, gas grill & laundry you will have everything you need.

Top guest favorite
A pathway of wooden planks leads to the serene beach, flanked by soft sand dunes. A vibrant, teal outdoor shower is situated nearby, alongside a dining set beneath a straw umbrella, inviting relaxation amidst the coastal scenery.
Home in Alligator Point
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Direct Oceanfront 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Pets Welcome

Newly redecorated & beautifully furnished 3 bedroom, 2 bath, oceanfront beach home. Fully equipped kitchen & outdoor gas bbq. Bedrooms have huge flatscreen tv's with cable. The comfy sunporch has a daybed that opens into 2 twins. Outside the house has plenty of decks & seating areas. Upper deck features a firetable for those nightly stargazing, wine-sipping evenings. The lower deck has a dining table, sofa & chairs, outdoor shower & fish sink. Come stay at MoonShadow & rejuvenate your soul.

Top guest favorite
A wooden cabin with a screened porch is set in a lush green landscape. Surrounding trees provide dappled shade, while colorful flowering plants enhance the serene atmosphere. The cabin features a metal roof and is partially obscured by greenery, emphasizing the secluded environment.
Cabin in Tallahassee
5 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Twisted Pine Lake Cabin, secluded & near town

Close to everything, a million miles away....... Down the two-track driveway, past the view of the nearest neighbors, our new custom cabin awaits. Rest easy on the screened porch, with its view of the two-acre lake or cross the adjacent foot bridge to the island. Fish for bass and bream, stroll the walking path, paddle around and enjoy the wildlife, or just relax far from the madding crowd. This slice of paradise sits on 12 acres; our home is across the lake, out of sight and out of mind.

Top guest favorite
A charming elevated beach house is surrounded by sandy terrain and swaying palm trees. A wooden deck with blue and yellow chairs provides a relaxing spot to enjoy the sun, while a hammock hangs nearby for added comfort. Steps lead up to a spacious covered porch.
Home in Panacea
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Paradise Point! Direct Beachfront Florida Oasis!

Paradise Point is a Direct Beach front home perched on the shores of the Gulf of Mexico! This rare to find Beach House embodies relaxation and solitude. The white sand beach of Florida’s Forgotten coast is just out front. One of the most incredible locations for miles, the views and peacefulness are unrivaled. This is an elevated and updated Beach home with a Brand new appliance suite, custom granite counters & more updates. Wake to the sounds of waves on the beach just outside your door.

Guest favorite
A serene sunset is captured over calm waters, with soft hues of orange and pink reflecting on the surface. Silhouettes of palm trees are visible in the foreground, enhancing the tranquil coastal setting.
Condo in Carrabelle
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

St. James Sanctuary

This lovely condo on Florida's "Forgotten Coast" provides guest with a beautiful view and tranquility only seen in this area of Florida. Located in St. James in Franklin county, you are 44 miles from the Tallahassee airport, it is convenient to a big city, while set in a quiet, rural beach area. You are only minutes from St. James Golf club, Carrabelle (7 miles away with public beach), St. George Island, Panacea and Apalachicola. Swimming not recommended (more like a bay).

Superhost
A view features two wooden tiny houses bathed in golden sunset light. Rocking chairs are positioned on gravel ground, facing a fire pit, with palm trees framing the scene. The open space beyond offers a glimpse of the water, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.
Tiny home in Crawfordville
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

Spring Creek Getaway

Located in Spring Creek FL, a safe fish camp community on the gulf waters. This tiny house is the place to relax. Rocking chairs, fire pit, and sunsets all provided right here. Bring your boat and use the private boat ramp or launch the fishing kayaks provided. The house was decorated by my wife and deep cleaned by the both of us!! Relax in the Screened in patio and use the charcoal grill. Kayakers DREAM!! High End Sea Kayaks...wilderness tarpon 14

Top guest favorite
A serene beach scene captures a vibrant sunset over the Gulf of Mexico. The warm hues of orange and yellow reflect on the water's surface, while gentle waves lap against the sandy shoreline, creating a tranquil atmosphere.
Bungalow in Alligator Point
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Unplugged

Experience old Florida in this 1950's 1 bedroom 1 bathroom bungalow located on a tropical spit along the Forgotten Coast. Unplugged sits nestled in between the Gulf of Mexico and Alligator Harbor with beach on one side and a bay-side boat ramp on the other. The house sleeps two in the main bedroom, two on a sofa bed in the living area, and has a small bunk room off the porch that can accommodate two children. Sorry, we do not accept pets.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features large sliding glass doors that open to a wooden deck overlooking the surrounding woods. Natural light illuminates the room, which includes a comfortable seating arrangement and side tables. A ceiling fan and wall-mounted television are also present.
Cabin in Monticello
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Fern Hollow Acres A peaceful retreat in the woods

Three bedroom lodge style house nestled in the woods in a retreat setting. Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Lovely grounds to walk around , enjoying deer, rabbits, owls and the occasional fox Butterfly, bees and bird sanctuary. Just 30 minutes to FSU/FAMU and the Florida Capitol. Twenty minutes to historic Monticello, Fl A short drive to the headwaters of the Wacissa River county park.with kayak and canoe rentals.

Top guest favorite
A two-story studio is surrounded by lush greenery, featuring a well-maintained yard with ornamental plants and pathways. The exterior showcases large windows and a welcoming entry, while a screened porch is visible alongside the main structure.
Guest suite in Tallahassee
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 738 reviews

Private/Entire Studio, Private Keyless Entry

"Private Entrance" 2nd-story STUDIO w/lots of windows. Wood floors, central AC/heat, 1/2 bath, queen bed with new mattress, fridge, Krueig, microwave, WIFI, TV, closet space, ROBES FOR PRIVATE OUTDOOR HEATED SHOWER and towels. Established neighborhood less than 2 miles from FSU and downtown; 1 block to Tallahassee Memorial Hospital. Restaurants under 1/2 mile! It is on our property and we personally clean the studio. Go Noles!

Top guest favorite
A serene lake view is displayed, featuring a vibrant rainbow arching over the calm water. The landscape is framed by lush trees on either side, reflecting beautifully on the lake’s surface, creating a peaceful and harmonious scene.
Home in Tallahassee
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Lakefront | 9 min to FSU | Pergola w/ Grill | EVSE

✈️ 5 minutes from Tallahassee Airport! 🏟️ 12 minutes from Capitol, FSU, FAMU and TCC 🤪 No crazy check out instructions! 🐕 Pet friendly! 🛶 Kayaks available! 🔋Remote control bed! 🌺Nature trails! ⛵️Private Lake access! 👩‍💻Traveling work friendly! 🎣Fish off the dock! 🔑 Remote and keyless entry. ⛳️ Golf course 10 minutes away! 🚿 Walk in shower and separate tub! 🎸 Piano, guitar, and board games available 🍳Awesome Grill set up!

Popular amenities for vacation rentals near Story Lake

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Florida
  4. Jefferson County
  5. Story Lake