House vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in South Eleuthera

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Top guest favorite

Several sailboats are anchored in calm waters, reflecting the soft light of the sky. A smaller motorboat moves through the water, leaving a gentle wake behind. Silhouettes of birds can be seen flying above, contributing to the serene coastal scene.

Home in Tarpum Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

On The Rocks 3 bedroom in Tarpum Bay Eleuthera

"On The Rocks" is one of a kind! We offer a unique experience that you will always treasure! Nestled 300 feet from the waterfront in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera, you can sit ‘on the rocks’, view the sunset while sipping your favorite beverage. Our three bedroom, fully furnished, air-conditioned house is a 2 minute walk to the beach and local grocery store. Enjoy fishing, water sports, nature walks or crabbing? Lots of attractions and activities on Eleuthera! So, come stay with us "On The Rocks"!

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews

"Baha Mara" Tarpum Bay

Fall asleep 50 feet from the turquoise sea. Great snorkelling, swimming, shelling and relaxing right outside the door. Not just a vacation rental, but a beautifully designed home with all the amenities you will need for a comfortable stay. Comfy furniture, stylish, well-equipped cook's kitchen, great view. Good for couples, friends travelling in a group and kid friendly. Close to Rock Sound airport (15 mins) and Governors Harbour (30 mins). 5 minutes from the quaint town of Tarpum Bay.

A dining table is set with five place settings featuring white plates and elegantly folded red napkins with decorative rings. A striped table runner adds a subtle touch, while a decorative black wire basket provides additional interest in the background.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Pineapple Pointe

The quaint settlement of Tarpum Bay is a warm, friendly and beautiful settlement in South Eleuthera. The house’s location is secured and roughly 7 minutes drive away from local shops, convenience stores, the beach, gas stations and the Rock Sound Airport. Our home is the perfect place for your next trip, to relax and enjoy the island life. Smoking is not allowed at all in the house. There is WI-FI, so you can stay connected during your stay! *A rental vehicle is a must on the island*

A wooden deck extends from the villa, surrounded by lush tropical greenery. Sun loungers with floral patterns are positioned for relaxation. Clear skies with scattered clouds create a bright atmosphere, enhancing the serene outdoor setting. The clean lines of the villa are complemented by the natural landscape.

Home in Winding Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Wonderful Winding Bay

Welcome to Wonderful – Winding Bay, a secluded beachfront villa on Eleuthera’s shores. Enjoy luxury, panoramic ocean views, and seamless indoor-outdoor living. Wake to the sound of waves, step onto your terrace, and find white sands and turquoise waters steps away. With airy, light-filled rooms, refined furnishings, and a gourmet kitchen, your stay promises relaxation and adventure. Embrace tranquility and the unmatched beauty of the Bahamas at Wonderful – Winding Bay.

The exterior of the cottage features a welcoming porch surrounded by lush greenery and well-maintained landscaping. A charming staircase leads to the entrance, while decorative stones outline the garden area, providing a serene atmosphere.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Cozy Beach Cottage, Private Shore and Ocean Views

Welcome to Seabreeze Cottage-your island hideaway in South Eleuthera. Just steps from your own private stretch of sand, this cozy cottage offers the perfect mix of barefoot relaxation and authentic Bahamian charm. Wake up to the sound of waves, sip your coffee with ocean breezes on the porch, and end your day watching the sunset over the turquoise water. Inside you will find a bright comfortable cottage designed for easy living.

The entrance to the farmhouse features a set of wooden steps leading up to a covered porch, framed by lush tropical greenery. Potted plants are placed on either side of the doorway, and a decorative lantern adds a subtle touch of charm.

Home in Rock Sound

Bahamian Farm House

Bohemian Bahamian Farmhouse on an old abandoned farm. Wild horse included. Richly detailed and filled with light. A mix of original architecture, reclaimed materials and cutting edge interior design, they come with stories to tell—but also with room for you to tell your own. It's artsy in a homemade kind of way. No angles are perfect but somehow it inspires relaxation and creativity.

The tranquil outdoor space features lush green grass leading towards the Caribbean Sea. Palm trees provide shade, while a pathway guides guests to the water's edge. Comfortable seating is positioned on the lawn, offering a picturesque view of the shoreline.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.33 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Down By The Seaside - 6 Bedrooms

BOOK 5 nights get 6th night free! If our house was any closer to the water, it would float! 6 bedrooms, 65 ft from the Caribbean Sea. Best sunsets in town, easy access to the water, or "the front yard" as we like to call it, and all the conveniences of town without the traffic. Grocery stores within 10 -15 minute walking distance. This is not an "investment property", but our home.

Superhost

The living and dining area features a rustic wooden table with four chairs and a vase of flowers at the center. A large mirror stands against the wall, reflecting natural light from the nearby window. French doors lead to a patio space, enhancing openness.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Flanders Cottage

Cute historic hill top cottage with sea views. Comfortable one bedroom home with everything you need. Short walk into the charming settlement of Tarpum Bay for groceries, fresh fish from the dock, restaurants or swimming in the blue waters of the Bight of Eleuthera. Former home and studio of Eleuthera’s well known artist Mal Flanders. Come and experience real island living.

A vibrant green home is surrounded by low-lying shrubs and flowering plants. A path leads to the entrance, flanked by greenery. Sunlight reflects off the windows, visible along the front facade, with a clear blue sky above creating a bright atmosphere.

Home in Greencastle

3 Bedroom House in South Eleuthera

Tiled home very quiet idyllic quaint settlement of Greencastle with nearby beaches of Paw Paw Bay with blue holes and marshes for snorkeling and fishing, Whyms Bight miles of sandy beach and Cotton Bay on the Atlantic, great sunning on both.

A softly lit bedroom features green walls and a spacious bed dressed in white bedding. Bright yellow and brown curtains frame the windows. A small nightstand with a lamp sits nearby, complementing the cozy atmosphere.

Home in Tarpum Bay

Kute Edge

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. centrally located, stylish 4 minutes away from the town beach and 7 minutes away from Rock Sound Airport. Beautiful Backyard

A one-story home is featured with a light-colored exterior and a pitched roof. Large windows allow for ample natural light, while a manicured lawn surrounds the property. A single-car garage and a paved driveway are visible, framed by neatly arranged shrubs and palm trees.

Home in Tarpum Bay

Cool Springs Home Away From Home

This 3 Bedrooms 3.5 Bath Home is located in a small Gated Community that's in heart of Tarpum Bay where most of the locals and tourists come to enjoy the festivities.