Vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

A two-story cottage with a pastel pink exterior features white accents and shutters. Lush green plants are visible in the garden, and a pastel green wall provides a vibrant contrast. The entrance is framed by a white picket fence, and clear blue skies are seen above.

Cottage in Tarpum Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Culmer Cottage: experience the REAL Bahamas

Originally built in 1828, Culmer Cottage was restored into a modern sea side home. It is close to groceries, restaurants, and the fishing dock. Its central location on the island permits easy access north or south. My cottage is fully equipped including beach towels and chairs, and a full kitchen. Ceiling fans in all rooms. Both bedrooms are air conditioned. Tarpum Bay is safe and quaint. By choosing to rent in a settlement, you will interact with some of the world's most friendly people.

Superhost

A brightly colored exterior of a house is framed by a decorative black iron fence. The front door is painted a cheerful orange and features a glass-paneled design. Unique orange and white patterns decorate the walls, while a small garden area is visible beside the entrance.

Apartment in Tarpum Bay

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Steps to Ocean - Munroe Cottages Apt 2

Great place to call home! Stay in the quaint fishing settlement of Tarpum Bay. This apartment is less than a minute walk to the ocean! Super clean 3 bedroom home is ready for your Bahamian experience! Fully furnished with washer and dryer in back. Walk to restaurants, grocery stores, and the beach. The local fisherman sell their catch on the dock. Large beach on the bayfront to swim in with flat clear water. Enjoy the culture and pristine nature that surround you in this great place to stay!

Top guest favorite

Several sailboats are anchored in calm waters, reflecting the soft light of the sky. A smaller motorboat moves through the water, leaving a gentle wake behind. Silhouettes of birds can be seen flying above, contributing to the serene coastal scene.

Home in Tarpum Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

On The Rocks 3 bedroom in Tarpum Bay Eleuthera

"On The Rocks" is one of a kind! We offer a unique experience that you will always treasure! Nestled 300 feet from the waterfront in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera, you can sit ‘on the rocks’, view the sunset while sipping your favorite beverage. Our three bedroom, fully furnished, air-conditioned house is a 2 minute walk to the beach and local grocery store. Enjoy fishing, water sports, nature walks or crabbing? Lots of attractions and activities on Eleuthera! So, come stay with us "On The Rocks"!

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

"Baha Mara" Tarpum Bay

Fall asleep 50 feet from the turquoise sea. Great snorkelling, swimming, shelling and relaxing right outside the door. Not just a vacation rental, but a beautifully designed home with all the amenities you will need for a comfortable stay. Comfy furniture, stylish, well-equipped cook's kitchen, great view. Good for couples, friends travelling in a group and kid friendly. Close to Rock Sound airport (15 mins) and Governors Harbour (30 mins). 5 minutes from the quaint town of Tarpum Bay.

Superhost

A dining table is set with five place settings featuring white plates and elegantly folded red napkins with decorative rings. A striped table runner adds a subtle touch, while a decorative black wire basket provides additional interest in the background.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Pineapple Pointe

The quaint settlement of Tarpum Bay is a warm, friendly and beautiful settlement in South Eleuthera. The house’s location is secured and roughly 7 minutes drive away from local shops, convenience stores, the beach, gas stations and the Rock Sound Airport. Our home is the perfect place for your next trip, to relax and enjoy the island life. Smoking is not allowed at all in the house. There is WI-FI, so you can stay connected during your stay! *A rental vehicle is a must on the island*

A wooden deck extends from the villa, surrounded by lush tropical greenery. Sun loungers with floral patterns are positioned for relaxation. Clear skies with scattered clouds create a bright atmosphere, enhancing the serene outdoor setting. The clean lines of the villa are complemented by the natural landscape.

Home in Winding Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Wonderful Winding Bay

Welcome to Wonderful – Winding Bay, a secluded beachfront villa on Eleuthera’s shores. Enjoy luxury, panoramic ocean views, and seamless indoor-outdoor living. Wake to the sound of waves, step onto your terrace, and find white sands and turquoise waters steps away. With airy, light-filled rooms, refined furnishings, and a gourmet kitchen, your stay promises relaxation and adventure. Embrace tranquility and the unmatched beauty of the Bahamas at Wonderful – Winding Bay.

A cozy guest room features a spacious bed adorned with a floral-patterned duvet. A small dining table with two chairs sits nearby, accompanied by a lamp and decorative plant. Air conditioning is installed, and natural light filters through sheer white curtains.

Guesthouse in Tarpum Bay

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Fantastic One Bedroom Cottage with Bayfront Views

Bayfront views abound on this cute guest house. Walk out your front door to Tarpum Bay's beach and steps to restaurants, bars, and grocery stores. Enjoy miles of bayfront beach! This cute guest cottage is located in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera. It is known as a quaint and quiet fishing village where the locals still bring in their catch of the day. Minutes away from the Atlantic with its magnificent coral reefs and miles of beach with no one else for miles.

Top guest favorite

A serene sunset is captured over calm waters, with warm orange and yellow hues illuminating the sky. A sailboat is anchored peacefully in the distance, adding to the tranquil atmosphere of the scene.

Cottage in Rock Sound

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Shorline Cottages, the ultimate getaway!

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Enjoy the sounds and the tranquil smell of the ocean as you relax in bed or lounge on the veranda of your cottage. Watch the sunset every evening or dine on the pier. Simply immerse yourself in pure delight. This one bedroom cottage has just about everything you’ll need for vacation stay. From Sunset dining to night fishing and so much more.

Superhost

The entrance to the farmhouse features a set of wooden steps leading up to a covered porch, framed by lush tropical greenery. Potted plants are placed on either side of the doorway, and a decorative lantern adds a subtle touch of charm.

Home in Rock Sound

Bahamian Farm House

Bohemian Bahamian Farmhouse on an old abandoned farm. Wild horse included. Richly detailed and filled with light. A mix of original architecture, reclaimed materials and cutting edge interior design, they come with stories to tell—but also with room for you to tell your own. It's artsy in a homemade kind of way. No angles are perfect but somehow it inspires relaxation and creativity.

The living and dining area features a rustic wooden table with four chairs and a vase of flowers at the center. A large mirror stands against the wall, reflecting natural light from the nearby window. French doors lead to a patio space, enhancing openness.

Home in Tarpum Bay

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Flanders Cottage

Cute historic hill top cottage with sea views. Comfortable one bedroom home with everything you need. Short walk into the charming settlement of Tarpum Bay for groceries, fresh fish from the dock, restaurants or swimming in the blue waters of the Bight of Eleuthera. Former home and studio of Eleuthera’s well known artist Mal Flanders. Come and experience real island living.

A studio apartment features a spacious bed with a striped blanket. A gray couch sits nearby, with a wooden table and lamp positioned to the side. A kitchenette and additional storage are visible in the background, while light enters through a nearby door.

Apartment in Deep Creek

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Studio Apt Unit Deep Creek #3

Welcome to our stunning oceanfront studio apartment in South Eleuthera! Nestled along the main oceanfront road of one of the Bahamas' most beautiful islands, this idyllic retreat offers the perfect blend of relaxation, natural beauty, and modern comfort. Only a 5 mile(10 minute drive) away from Cape Eleuthera and the Island School