Boutique hotel vacation rentals in Shelter Island Heights

Find and book unique boutique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotel rentals in Shelter Island Heights

Guests agree: these boutique hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Hotel room in Bellport

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Bellport Village Temperance Hall: The Ho-Hum Suite

A quaint, seaside village located on the South Shore of Long Island, Bellport Village has long been a destination for both day trippers and summer residents. It offers a variety of shopping and dining experiences, along with one of the most well-known summer theatres in the region, the Gateway Playhouse. Bellport is one of the rare municipalities with its own golf course, private Fire Island ocean beach lovingly referred to as "Ho-Hum Beach" as well as a bay side beach named "Mother's Beach".

Hotel room in North Fork

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

American Beech - King Suite 1

The 19th-century historic and centrally located Stirling Square in Greenport Village has been reimagined into the modern and tasteful American Beech Boutique Hotel, Restaurant & Bar. During your stay, you can explore the vibrant village, natural scenery, and return to a memorable and comfortable room at the end of your day. The boutique hotel features eleven suites, including two, double-bedroom apartments. Our guests pay a resort fee of $35 per night, with additional taxes at check in.

Hotel room in Montauk

3.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

A Wave Inn, Deluxe Studio

Unwind and relax by the poolside or spend time in the scenic nature at A Wave Inn in Montauk. Located in this popular tourist district, we’re ranked one of the best Montauk hotels. Our completely renovated spaces now provide guests with even more comfort and hospitality for enjoying their stay. Your room charge will be paid prior to your arrival. The remaining balance of taxes (8.625% + 3% ) will be charged upon arrival. A refundable security deposit of $XX will also be collected.

Guest favorite

Hotel room in Setauket- East Setauket

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

UV Sanitized 1st fl furnishd rm~3 miles 2 SUNY SB

UV Ozone Germ Remover/Sanitizer used before/ after every guest. Furnished 1st fl rm. Fresh Paint, new curtains & bedding w/brand new sven & son 14" plush twin bed, dresser mirror desk, wood floors. Share bathroom w/ 1. Room has own kitchenette including mini frig, microwave and coffee/tea pot. right off a large kitchen used only by son & I. Room has North west facing triple windows to front of house are shady most of day. Room has ceiling fan. .

Hotel room in Bellport

4.57 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Bellport Inn Enchanting Garden Suite - 2 bedrooms

This enchanting suite at Bellport Inn welcomes you through an inviting porch into a sunlit kitchenette. The primary bedroom offers a queen size bed, pull out full size sofa bed and an ensuite bath. A window lined second bedroom offers a queen size bed and a private bath with clawfoot tub. A shared garden oasis includes an outdoor grill for guest use.

Hotel room in Montauk

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Sun 'N' Sound, Bayfront Studio Lower

Exclusive waterfront resorts make any vacation memorable, especially at a place like Sun N’ Sound. The hotel tops hospitality expectations by all measures. The large accommodations are designed for comfortable long term stays. You’ll feel right at home during your time in our comfy guest rooms.